Lily’s Dream: A Fairy Friendship

Lily is a fairy who dreams of flying high. However, Lily is the only fairy who cannot get her wings to lift her. As she practices, much of her time is spent taking in the beauty of nature from the ground. 

One day, after a particularly difficult flying lesson, Lily stumbles on an acorn and finds a small alcove in a tree filled with fairy-sized treasures. As Lily explores the new environment, Willow, a young human girl, approaches her, causing Lily to run away in fear. When she realizes she has left her golden bracelet there, Lily returns. Willow returns Lily’s bracelet and offers to help her learn to fly. But can a human—completely grounded—help a fairy connect with her wings? 

Told from the third-person point of view, Lily’s Dream follows a young fairy’s journey to achieve flight. Unlike other fairies with beautiful, shimmering wings, Lily has small, colorless ones. Lily yearns to be like the rest of the fairies and asks her mother, “Will my wings ever look like yours?” Lily’s mother tells her that each fairy’s wings are unique, and though Lily’s wings are not yet colorful, it does not mean that she is not special. This interaction will teach readers that a person’s beauty comes from within and that their individuality is what makes them truly extraordinary. 

Willow, a human girl, plays a key role in helping Lily achieve her dreams. Though she cannot directly relate to Lily’s struggle, Willow uses her artistic side to create an acorn helmet, a landing cushion, and a mini trampoline for Lily. Willow makes sure to create a safe space for Lily and encourages her. With Willow’s daily support, the fairy and the girl become friends. 

Each page contains one to six sentences with full-page illustrations that match the text and convey Lily’s emotions. For example, “while all the other fairies soared to dazzling heights, Lily was the only one who knew about the beauty closer to the ground.” The illustration shows her smiling on a lily pad, watching the fish below. Lily is small in comparison to the nature around her. For example, one picture shows tall, pink, and white flowers towering over her. These detailed, dream-like images will enchant readers and draw them into Lily’s magical world. Additionally, the vivid colors and detailed facial expressions will help readers identify Lily’s frustrations with flying and her joy in connecting with nature. 

Lily’s Dream explores themes of resilience and friendship through Lily’s persistent pursuit of flight. Despite her struggles, Lily never gives up on her dream and continues working toward her goal. She demonstrates tenacity by taking flying lessons and practicing independently every day. Young readers will relate to Lily’s determination and feel encouraged to face challenges with similar strength.  

Though Lily shows inherent determination as an individual, she only succeeds after receiving Willow’s unwavering support. The human girl not only creates a safe environment for Lily but also cheers Lily on, uplifting her fairy friend as if they share the challenge together. Their unlikely friendship demonstrates how kindness can help someone reach new heights. Readers will learn the importance of supporting their friends — even when they cannot directly relate to the struggles those friends are facing. Though Lily and Willow come from different worlds, their blossoming bond proves that anyone can find common ground and offer meaningful support. Through these lessons, Lily’s Dream becomes a heartfelt celebration of self-belief and the transformative power of friendship. 

Sexual Content 

  • None 

Violence 

  • None 

Drugs and Alcohol 

  • None 

Language   

  • None 

Supernatural 

  • None 

Spiritual Content 

  • None 

by Madeline Hettrick 

Savvy

When a child in Mibs Beaumont’s family turns thirteen, they gain a savvy, an inherited superpower that can range from mundane to magnificent, such as her mother embodying effortless perfection or her brother creating life-threatening hurricanes. With no idea what her savvy will be, Mibs needs all the support she can get, but just two days before her thirteenth birthday, a car crash changes everything.  

Suddenly, Mibs’ dad is in a coma, and her mom is out of state watching over him, leaving Mibs without parental support on her big day. But in her darkest moment, Mibs’ thirteenth birthday brings the solution to all her problems. Her savvy is to wake people up. Convinced only she can save her dad, Mibs will do anything to reach him as soon as possible. Mibs becomes a secret stowaway in the back of a delivery driver’s van, along with her brothers, Fish and Samson, and her neighbors, Bobbi and Will Junior.  

But as she travels across the country, Mibs realizes she may be in over her head, and her savvy may be another power entirely. While her father’s health may be out of her control, the journey teaches Mibs more about herself and her personal relationships with others. She feels like an outsider in her small town, but maybe she is just looking for belonging in the wrong place.  

Mibs is a brave and headstrong young girl, determined to save her dad no matter what obstacle stands in her way. However, in pursuit of her goals, she occasionally makes dangerous and ill-conceived choices. For example, Mibs hitchhikes a ride in the back of a stranger’s van without telling any adults. While the driver, Lester, turns out to be a good person, Mibs did not know that at the time. Readers may disapprove of her reckless decision-making, as her actions could have endangered not just herself, but also her brothers and neighbors. However, considering the stress of her situation and her naiveté at such a young age, Mibs remains a deeply sympathetic character that is easy to root for. 

Will is a year older than Mibs and serves as her love interest. In contrast to Mibs’ classmates, who often tease and isolate her, Will does not make Mibs feel strange and “freakish.” Instead, he makes her feel rather special and gifted. He is kind and clearly has romantic feelings for Mibs. Even when she feels too young to reciprocate, Will accepts the rejection in stride and remains positive and supportive, teaching readers the importance of accepting others’ boundaries.  

Will’s older sister, Bobbi, fills a somewhat antagonistic role. She is a stereotypical angry teen, prone to lashing out at others without justification. For example, she makes fun of Mibs’ birthday dress and kicks Fish. While her antics may annoy some readers, Bobbi has occasional moments of vulnerability, such as thinking about her loneliness, that make her rebellious nature come off as insecurity rather than genuine meanness. Readers will learn to not judge someone by their appearance because they may be going through hidden struggles.   

Savvy is told from Mibs’ point of view. She acts like an authentic thirteen-year-old, who occasionally makes misjudgments that the reader will know are wrong long before Mib catches up. For example, Mibs hears Bobbi’s thoughts, and it becomes clear her savvy is not “waking others” but mind reading. Yet, for a significant chunk of the book, Mibs ignores the evidence in favor of what she wants to believe. Despite her good intentions, Mibs ends up accomplishing the opposite of her goal – to protect her family. The desire to help a loved one clouds her judgment, ironically putting more loved ones (her brother and friends) in danger. 

While Mibs’ personal relationships are the heart of the book and keep the reader emotionally invested in the story, they are not the main focus. Savvy is a journey of self-discovery. Mibs learns what her power is, both in terms of her savvy and her independence. For a book about superpowers, the stakes are relatively low. Instead, the conflict derives from a much more intimate, personal scale, allowing the reader to understand Savvy’s characters better. Savvy feels like a realistic, grounded portrayal of how a family would handle superpowers. They go about their daily lives, occasionally receiving assistance and experiencing societal ostracization along the way, but they are mostly normal people.  

This book has won the Newbery Honor and was a runner-up for the Indian Paintbrush Book Award, with its success extending to two spin-off books. Although this book was published in 2010, it remains relevant today due to its timeless story. Through a flawed yet compassionate protagonist, Savvy tackles mature themes, such as the loss of a parent. He demonstrates a girl growing into herself while avoiding the pitfalls of growing up too quickly.  

Sexual Content    

  • Will Junior has a crush on Mibs, as seen through his attentiveness. For example, Mibs observes that “Will always seemed to be walking on our heels or watching us when he was supposed to be praying. One time he even gave me his own cup of juice.”  
  • Likewise, Mibs has a crush on Will Junior, as seen through her jealousy. Mibs states that she doesn’t “like the way Ashley kept staring at Will, or the way her staring at him bothered” her.  Ashley is Mibs’ mean classmate.  
  • In a pool, Will Junior kisses Mibs, then her brother asks Will to stop. Mibs describes, “Then [Will Junior] moved forward and his lips touched mine, quick and awkward with the taste of chlorine and salt, like maybe he’d just slipped and bumped his face into mine accidentally.”  
  • Mibs later tells Will Junior that she likes him, too, but is unwilling to be in a relationship due to their age. He supports her decision and decides to wait for her.  
  • Will Junior was born out of wedlock and then secretly raised by his grandparents. Mibs describes, “I might have been wrong in believing that Will Junior was Bobbi’s brother. Will had a secret. Now I knew his secret.”  

Violence    

  • After drawing on Will Junior’s hand, Mibs discovers that when ink touches a person’s skin, she can read their mind. Mibs panics, so Fish attacks Will Junior. Fish “spun him around, clocking him hard and fast in the eye with his fist. . . Bobbi joined the scuffle, climbing over the seats and throwing herself at Fish, scratching his cheek with her fingernails.” The fight ends when Fish finally understands why Mibs is scared and spits “a big, thick wad of juicy spit right into Will Junior’s hand. ‘Eww, man!’ Will hollered out in disgust.” The comedically chaotic fight lasts three pages, with no characters getting injured aside from scrapes and bruises. 
  • The group takes a detour at a restaurant, where they encounter the manager, Ozzie, being rude to one of the waitresses. After Ozzie fires the waitress and throws her final paycheck across the ground, Samson “leaned forward from his hidey-hole behind the counter and bit The Great and Powerful Ozzie hard on the leg.” The extent of Ozzie’s injuries is unknown, as the group immediately flees the scene. However, Samson’s mouth is not bloody, so readers can assume they were superficial.  

  Drugs and Alcohol    

  • None 

Language   

  •  None   

Supernatural   

  • Mibs and her family have supernatural abilities. For example, Mibs can read minds and Fish can create storms. Mibs once reads Will Junior’s mind, where he hints at having a secret.   

Spiritual Content    

  • The van driver, Lester, delivers Bibles, and Will Junior’s grandfather is a pastor.   
  • Overwhelmed with her new savvy, Mibs begs God to take it away. “I tried making a deal with God. I vowed that I would eat my green beans without complaint. . . If only I could stop hearing voices when someone nearby had ink on their skin.”   

by Kerry Lum   

Rule of Wolves

The cursed king of Ravka, Nikolai Lantsov, is preparing for war against Fjerda’s massive artillery and an army of Grisha (magic-users) addicted to the drug jurda parem. Disputing Nikolai’s right to the Lantsov throne, the Fjerdans seem to outmatch the Ravkans on all fronts. To make matters worse, Nikolai is holding hostages—a Shu Han princess, Ehri, and a member of her guard named Mayu Kir-Kaat. He plans to marry Ehri and forge an alliance between Shu Han and Ravka. But the princess’s sister, Queen Makhi, would prefer to see Nikolai dead. Trapped between Fjerdan bombers and Shu assassins, Nikolai wonders if his time as king is coming to an end. 

Recently gifted the powers of Sankt Juris, Zoya is struggling with the death of her mentor. As a blight of darkness threatens to engulf her world, Zoya turns to the newly resurrected Darkling for answers. When the Darkling escapes from her grasp, she must divert her attention to the war brewing between Ravka and Fjerda. Nikolai and Zoya make their final stand to protect Nikolai’s throne and the kingdom of Ravka. Can they protect their people and all they hold dear without sacrificing the relationship between them? 

Grisha Nina Zenik and her Fjerdan companion Hanne Brum are fighting a different kind of war—one of espionage and trickery. Still undercover as the Fjerdan widow Mila Jandersdat, Nina must use her powers over the dead to gain intel on Fjerda’s plans while protecting the persecuted Grisha of Fjerda. Because of Nina, followers of the “New Saints” (in reality, Grisha spies) have emerged throughout the country. She and Hanne form a relationship with Prince Rasmus, the heir to the Fjerdan throne. With him, they hope to sway the Fjerdan government towards peace, even if it means giving up the relationship that they have formed together. 

Like its predecessor, King of Scars, Rule of Wolves has a constantly changing perspective. Every chapter features a new third-person narrator, whose name is announced in the chapter’s title. Perspectives include Nikolai, Zoya, Nina, Mayu (a Shu soldier), Queen Makhi, and “The Monk.” Each narrator focuses on their plot thread, making it challenging to follow their stories, which are interrupted every time a new chapter begins. While Nikolai is perhaps the central figure of the book, the wide cast of narrators expands the already vast world of the “Grishaverse” and encourages the audience to understand previously dismissed perspectives. Bardugo’s writing treats both the commoner and the royal with the same level of respect, and every character feels important to the story. Rule of Wolves reintroduces many figures from previous “Grishaverse” series, such as Malyen Oretsev from Shadow and Bone and Kaz Brekker from Six of Crows. Ample exposition is offered, but audiences who have not read the previous books will miss much of their backstory and characterization. 

The duology’s message of resilience remains present in this sequel, and each character faces challenges that they must overcome, utilizing both mental and physical strength. With the overarching threat of war, Rule of Wolves shows the multi-faceted impact of international conflict. Innocents die, malicious parties go free, and the protagonists are repeatedly forced to decide between mercy and vengeance. These issues make Rule of Wolves an extremely pertinent book for our modern era, as it combines fantasy elements with universal lessons of compassion in the face of brutality and open-mindedness amidst chaos. 

Sexual Content 

  • The Shu royal leader, Queen Makhi, remarks that her grandmother is free to “rusticate with a series of wildly handsome lovers.” 
  • The Ravkan Count Kirgin is infatuated by Zoya, and she feels “his eagerness, his longing” and imagines that his goals for their relationship “involv[e] bodies entwined.” 
  • Nina mentions having spent time in the “brothels of Ketterdam.” What occurs in the brothels is not described. 
  • Nina notices Jarl Brum’s (a Fjerdan military commander) eyes looking “lower” than her neck. She later fakes an affair with him, and the Fjerdan guard Joran asks her, “You did not want to be his whore?” Nina and Joran’s conversation regarding her affair takes place over two pages. 
  • Zoya “place[s] a kiss on [Nikolai’s] forehead” and expresses her desire to stay with him in his room. 
  • David kisses his wife Genya’s knuckles, and “Genya’s cheeks flus[h] pink with pleasure.” They later kiss at the altar during their wedding. 
  • Nikolai wonders if Zoya has “a lover,” and her romantic life is further alluded to. 
  • Nikolai jokes that Zoya is trying to get him “into bed.” 
  • Nikolai and Zoya’s romantic tension builds throughout the book. Nikolai’s guard, Tamar, tells him, “Your heart is in your eyes, Your Highness.” He thinks, “I am greedy for the sight of you [Zoya].” Later, Nikolai confesses to Zoya, “I would make you my queen because I want you. I want you all the time.” This confession scene lasts four pages. 
  • The Fjerdan royal guard to Prince Rasmus, Joran, pretends to have “presumed upon” the Grisha spy Nina. Prince Rasmus remarks, “It’s not as if he put her up against the wall and lifted her skirts.” 
  • The undercover Fjerdan Grisha, Hanne Brum, and Nina kiss in Nina’s bed. The scene picks up again, chapters later, when Hanne’s mother, Ylva, finds them, “gowns half on, a rumple of silk and mouths bruised from kissing.” 
  • Nikolai and Zoya kiss after she admits her love for him. “And she did, drawing him up to her, feeling the stubble at his jaw, the soft curl of his hair behind his ear, and at last, after all these long days of wanting, his witty, brilliant, perfect mouth.” After this, they kiss again several times. 
  • Nikolai says to Zoya regarding his alter-ego sending a message to Ketterdam, “If it involves you out of that dress, I have no doubt I can convince him.” 

Violence 

  • Since the book contains a substantial amount of violence, not all of it is detailed below.  
  • Queen Makhi planned to have her royal guards kill Nikolai: “Mayu’s task was to get close to King Nikolai, murder him, then take her own life.” The Queen also planned for her sister, Ehri, to be murdered by her royal guards in the ensuing Shu invasion that would cause many casualties. 
  • A blight of darkness is engulfing the world and causing everything in its path to die. Queen Makhi’s niece, Akeni, dies after being caught in the path of the “shadow. . . spreading like a stain.” 
  • Fjerda trains soldiers called drüskelle to “merrily go to murder Grisha.” 
  • Nikolai reflects on how Mayu is “the girl who had driven a knife into Isaak’s heart,” killing him. 
  • Nina has a nightmare that the wolf Trassel is “covered in blood . . . feasting on a corpse.” 
  • Zoya recalls how she “murdered a Saint bent on destruction, driven a blade into the heart of a dragon . . .” These events occur in the previous novel. 
  • Zoya and the Ravkan Count Kirgin’s meeting is interrupted by an assassination attempt. Zoya uses her powers to knock the first attacker into the wall “with a bone-breaking crunch” and kill him. The second assassin is knocked unconscious. 
  • The first battle of the Ravkan-Fjerdan war takes place over eight pages. Ravka places mines in Fjerda’s path, causing tanks to “burst into flames” and burning many soldiers alive. Grisha and non-Grisha soldiers fight the Fjerdans on the ground, and Zemeni airships join to fight on the Ravkan side. 
  • The previous king of Ravka was banished after being ousted for assaulting Genya Safin. 
  • Following their queen’s orders, the Shu royal guard “burst into flame” and died in the self-inflicted fire. They severely burn Ehri in the process, but she survives. 
  • Prince Rasmus hits his guard, Joran, with a riding crop. Joran is left with a bleeding cheek. This repeats for over a page. 
  • Zoya and an army of Sun Summoners fight the Darkling and his shadow soldiers. Shadows grab hold of Ravkan flyers and cause them to “plumme[t] toward the earth.” Zoya saves her allies and slightly wounds the Darkling. This is described over two pages. 
  • Ravka is bombed during David and Genya’s wedding. Nikolai sees “burning in the lower and upper towns” of the capital, and the castle is partially destroyed. Nikolai takes a flyer and uses his demon to attack the Fjerdan bomber. “Blood poured over the demon’s mouth—his mouth—hot and salty with iron.” The explosions kill David. This fight occurs over four pages. 
  • The stories of the Saints are filled with bloodshed. For example, Sankt Ilya was “thrown to his death” from a bridge. 
  • Mayu’s brainwashed twin, Reyem, “br[eaks] every bone in her hand” by crushing it. This scene evolves into a fight in which Tamar, a Shu Grisha loyal to Nikolai, and Mayu struggle against Reyem and the Tavgharad (the Shu Han royal guard). This battle spans two pages and concludes with Reyem joining his sister’s side. 
  • Nina reflects on Matthias’ (her late Fjerdan lover) murder, saying that Joran “shot an unarmed man and left him . . . to die.” 
  • The final fight between Ravka and Fjerda occurs over several chapters. It begins with the Fjerdans approaching by sea and Zoya and her fellow Grisha Squallers sending lightning into the water. “Nina could not hear the men in the shallows scream, but she could see their mouths open wide, their bodies shaking as current passed through them.” The result is a massive death toll. 
  • Nikolai, with the help of Ravkan Grisha, fights the Fjerdans. Fjerda attacks with drugged Grisha and large bells that incapacitate the Ravkans with a “horrifying, paralyzing sound.” Nikolai uses his demon to destroy the bells. 
  • Nina is sedated by the spiritual leader of Ravka, the Apparat, and kidnapped. He threatens to have a Heartrender “take the skin from her body inch by inch.” Zoya rescues her by “burning [the Apparat’s guards] from the inside,” creating corpses that Nina uses to escape. 
  • The khergud, mechanically altered Shu soldiers, join the battle between Ravka and Fjerda, flying onto the battlefield and ripping the arms off of Fjerdan soldiers. 
  • Zoya uses her dragon powers to scorch the Fjerdan tanks. She saves Nikolai and his soldiers from certain death. Nina is wounded by a bullet while riding on her back.  
  • Nina finds a “broken body” bent and bleeding beneath the observation tower. Later, it’s discovered that this is Prince Rasmus’ body. After Prince Rasmus slapped her, Hanne accidentally crushed his heart with her powers. 
  • Jarl Brum is shot after pointing a gun at Prince Rasmus. Joran shoots him thrice: “once in the leg, twice in the arm.” 
  • The Darkling’s final martyrdom is violent. “The thorn pierced the Darkling’s chest and he screamed, his head thrown back, the sound pure, human, and terrible.” 

Drugs and Alcohol 

  • Alcohol is used and referenced frequently. 
  • Nina expresses a desire to drink wine, but she laments that “Fjerdan women weren’t permitted alcohol, certainly not in public.” 
  • Jurda parem is a synthetic drug used to enhance a Grisha’s powers. It is highly addictive and usually deadly. Nina is a recovering parem addict, and she reflects on how the drug nearly ended her life. Fjerda weaponizes parem and bombs Ravkan armies with the substance. 
  • Nikolai tells his guard, Tolya, that he has faith in “Good engineering and better whiskey.” Nikolai frequently drinks at political and social gatherings as well as before battle. Drinks mentioned include wine and brandy. 
  • Count Kirgin pours Hiram Schenck, a Kerch member of the Merchant Council, an “extraordinary vintage that had come straight from Kirgin’s legendary cellars.” 
  • While in the Brum parlor, Nina mentions “a bottle of brännvin.” 
  • Vadik Demidov, a member of the Lantsov family who is vying for Nikolai’s throne, “does not partake of spirits” due to his religion. 
  • Genya and David hold a wedding where alcohol is served. 
  • “The Monk” finds his way to “a beer hall in Shura” and drinks “sour beer.” Later, while preparing for battle, he desires whiskey. 
  • Nikolai reflects on how he and David did not spend any “raucous nights . . . singing dirty drinking songs.”

Language 

  • Profanity is rarely used. Profanity includes bastard, damn, hell, ass, shat, and whore. 
  • Nikolai is repeatedly called the “bastard king.” One Ravkan says to him, “I said you are a bastard and not fit to sit that fancy horse.” 
  • Damn is used most frequently. Nikolai lists his enemies, thinking, “the Darkling, the Fjerdans, the Shu, jurda parem, the damned demon living inside him.” 
  • In Fjerda, “Djel” is used in place of “god”. Hanne says to Nina, “Sweet Djel, put a robe on.” 
  • Ravkans substitute “oh my god” with “All Saints” and similar phrases. During a meeting, Zoya thinks, “All Saints, how did [Nikolai] meet with these spineless, self-satisfied toads without committing murder once a day?” 
  • Nikolai thanks the Zemeni Kalem Kerko for his help in battle, saying, “You just saved our asses.” 
  • The Fjerdan soldier Redvin says of Prince Rasmus, “Only Djel knows how they shat out a weakling like that.” 
  • Jarl Brum calls someone a “whore mother” and another person a “Grisha whore.” 

Supernatural 

  • The Grisha are individuals born with special powers. There are three categories of Grisha: Corporalki, Etherealki, and Materialki. Ravkan Grisha are recruited into the Second Army, using their abilities in battle. David explains that Grisha’s power is linked to “the making at the heart of the world.” 
  • Nina is a Corporalnik whose powers over the living were altered after an experience with jurda parem. She now has control over the dead, and she uses her powers to hear the voices of the deceased while in the presence of the Fjerdan queen. “Kings and queens and favored retainers had been buried on the White Island since before the Ice Court had been built around it, and Nina could hear their whispers. An army awaiting her command.” 
  • Adrik Zhabin is a Grisha Squaller (order Etherealki) who can control wind. Zoya has similar abilities. 
  • Leoni Hilli is a Grisha Alkemi (order Materialki) who can control poisons. 
  • Nina’s appearance was altered by Genya, a Grisha Tailor. Nina is now “in Mila Jandersdat’s body, her face and form tailored to keep her true identity secret.” 
  • Hanne is a Corporalnik who can tailor appearances and manipulate the living. She repeatedly uses her powers to ease Prince Rasmus’ ailments, but she eventually accidentally kills him by crushing his heart. She later alters his corpse to look like her and changes her own appearance to mimic his. 
  • A vendor in Fjerda is a Grisha Tidemaker who creates “a wall of seething water” that drenches Brum’s soldiers. 
  • Nikolai is “host to a demon,” a winged creature linked to the Darkling’s power. It is attached to his soul, but he learns to control its powers. He uses the demon during a heist: “He was seeing through the demon’s eyes. He felt its arms—his arms—extend, muscles flexing, claws reaching.” 
  • The Darkling was resurrected in King of Scars, and he now inhabits the body of the monk Yuri Vedenen. He later regains his powers by driving a “piece of the thorn wood” through the hands of Alina and Mal and summons “nichevo’ya,” shadow soldiers, to defend himself. 
  • The blight of darkness comes from the Fold, a magic wasteland created by the Darkling’s abuse of Grisha power. People call the blight “Kilyklava. . . vampire, after a creature from myth.” 
  • After slaying a dragon, Zoya gains the power to see into other people’s minds and feel their emotions. She calls this a “sudden drop into someone else’s pain or joy.” 
  • Grisha infantry divisions use their powers to fight off the Fjerdans: “The Squallers drove back the Fjerdan tanks as the Heartrenders gave them cover. A squad of Inferni used the burning remnants of the tanks to create a wall of flame, another barrier the Fjerdan troops would have to breach.” 
  • The Sun Soldiers are special Grisha, who are “heirs to Alina Starkov’s power.” They control light and are able to defeat the Darkling’s shadows. 
  • After being burned, Ehri is saved by Grisha healers, “who had restored her body and kept her pain in check as they did it.” 
  • Zoya learns to harness the talents of other Grisha orders, using not only her abilities as a Squallor but also manipulating water as a Tidemaker. 
  • The Darkling, Aleksander, uses his powers on the statue of a Saint to gather followers. “Slowly, shadows curled from Sankt Ilya’s open hands; they began to bleed from his mouth.” 
  • Zoya unlocks the ability to shapeshift into a dragon. She is bulletproof with the power to breathe “silver lightning.” 
  • The Darkling is sealed into Sankt Felix’s thorn wood with a branch piercing his heart, sacrificing himself in a magic ritual that stops the blight of darkness and reverses its impact. 

Spiritual Content 

  • The royalty of Shu Han is referred to as “born of heaven.” 
  • The god of Fjerda is called Djel. Fjerdan soldiers are said to “hea[r] the words of Djel” at their initiation ceremony. Some Fjerdans claim that the Grisha are “the favored children of Djel. That their powers are actually a sign of his blessing.” 
  • People outside Fjerda worship the Saints, martyred figures who supposedly had otherworldly abilities. Saints have their own fables, temples, and monks. 
  • Cult followings of “the Sun Saint” and “Leoni of the Waters” appear in Fjerda, and Jarl Brum calls Saint worship “Corruption. Heresy.” 
  • Living Grisha also have religious followers. Zoya is worshiped as “Sankta Zoya” (Saint Zoya), and she gains a significant following after using her dragon form to save the Ravkans from Fjerda. 
  • The Apparat is the spiritual leader of Ravka. He defects to Fjerda, and, according to Brum, “He says the Ravkan king is possessed by demons, that Vadik Demidov was anointed by the Saints themselves to rule.” The Wellmother, leader of a Fjerdan convent to Djel, calls him “a heathen priest.” 
  • The Darkling is worshipped as “The Starless Saint” by a cult referred to as “The Starless.” After his “martyrdom,” he is recognized as a Saint by the Ravkan government. 
  • Nikolai calls the Tula Valley “the site of some of the holiest land in Ravka.” 
  • Nikolai is not religious but prays for help: “Right now, though, he hoped that each Ravkan Saint, Kaelish sprite, and all-powerful deity was looking down with some fondness in their hearts for his country.” 
  • The Lantsov family is considered “divinely chosen to lead Ravka.” 
  • Nina claims to have been “blessed by Djel” and pretends to be his prophet.  
  • The Darkling explains the history of the Grisha and Saints: “You know as well as I that the line between Saint and Grisha was once blurred. It was a time of miracles.” 
  • Genya says in her speech at David’s funeral, “May the Saints receive him on a brighter shore.” The Ravkan belief in an afterlife is never explained further. 

by Gabrielle Barke 

The Demon Tide

Newly exposed as the Black Witch of Prophecy, Elloren Gardner Grey is on the run. She has finally made it to the Eastern Realm, but the Eastern authorities are convinced the Black Witch has arrived to kill them all as the Prophecy foretells. If there’s any chance of defeating High Mage Marcus Vogel, Elloren must find her friends and make new allies. As Elloren hides from the Eastern authorities, she learns more than ever about different cultures and what’s truly at stake if the Eastern Realm were to fall to Gardneria. With her magic bound, her fastmate captured, and a bounty on her head, Elloren battles intolerance as fierce as she battles Vogel, and uncovers secrets all countries have long since buried.  

The Demon Tide oscillates between the perspectives of Elloren’s friends, building them up as individual characters with distinct loves, fears, and ambitions. Elloren’s brother, Trystan Gardner, and her friend, Tierney Calix, are two prominent perspectives explored. Trystan’s and Tierney’s points of view allow readers to see the war from two fronts. Trystan is reviled because of his Gardnerian heritage, and Tierney is ostracized for befriending him. When Elloren arrives, they do everything in their power to protect her, which is difficult because they have their own romantic lives to distract them. Overall, the author explores twenty perspectives; this overload of perspectives makes things confusing at times and slows the story’s pacing, making the novel seem less eventful.  

Cornered and afraid, Elloren proves herself to be an empowering and intelligent protagonist. She tries to navigate the customs and traditions of the Eastern Realm. Plus, she has strange visions of death and destruction that are seemingly delivering vague warnings she cannot decipher. She grapples with a complicated love that haunts her dreams and distracts her from the waking world. With love at the forefront of everyone’s minds, Elloren and her friends learn how to multitask and see beyond the veil of intolerance and ignorance that seems to exist in every culture.  

Like many long fantasy series, the intricate worldbuilding can be overwhelming at times, with numerous events, characters, and details to track. There is also a lot of exposition required for each character’s background. This bogs down the story and makes it drag. However, the story is powerful and moving, and each character has depth. Many of the characters have been developed over the entire series, delivering potent and thorough perspectives. The author has successfully created a complex fantasy world, complete with diverse cultures, despicable villains, and intricate magic systems to match.  

The series has been building up to the explosive battles and new, official romantic relationships found in The Demon Tide. Readers who love digging into intricate political dilemmas and a kaleidoscope of characters fighting for a good cause will love Forest’s direction in The Demon Tide. Elloren and her friends teach their audience that intolerance is beatable and the best way to fight it is to love yourself and others. Elloren and her friends teach that bravery in the face of fear is necessary and achievable, especially if you rely on your loved ones to support you and ask for help.  

Sexual Content 

  • Freyja, an Amaz soldier, reminisces about a past encounter with her old boyfriend, Clive. “Freyja’s heart twisted as she held Clive’s impassioned stare and remembered. . . sneaking off into the woods. . . falling into each other’s arms. . . and taking each other with an intensity that stole Freyja’s breath and ignited that familiar, piercing yearning to be with Clive always.” 
  • While Trystan, Elloren’s brother, is training in the East, he starts crushing on his guard, Vothe. At one point, he watches Vothe and Basyl (Vothe’s current friend with benefits). Basyl “reaches up, threads his fingers through Vothe’s silver-tipped hair, and pulls him into a sultry, farewell kiss.” Later, Vothe runs his “tongue just below Basyl’s ear as Basyl slithers against [him] enticingly” to provoke Trystan and make him jealous. 
  • While Elloren’s friends, Thierren and Sparrow, are escaping East through the desert, they grow more attracted to one another. One morning, while asleep, Sparrow “presses her lips to the warm nape of [Thierren’s] neck, a thrill singing through her as Thierren shivers against her.” Thierren returns the affection but then realizes that she’s dreaming. He wakes her up, and they’re both embarrassed.  
  • Safe in the East, Elloren has a vision of Vogel’s prisoner, Lukas. His “lips press down on [hers], sending a tight shiver through [her], the kiss suffused with breathless hunger. . . strong hands grip [her] arms, a hard male body fitted to [hers]. An aroused male body.” Elloren realizes that they’re psychically linked and quickly breaks away from Lukas. 
  • While exploring an Eastern market, Elloren witnesses two women “fall into each other, laughing, as if in the midst of some private joke, and the spike-haired woman pulls the flowery woman into an embrace, kissing her deeply.” Elloren moves on without seeing more. 
  • Authorities find Elloren and chase her through the market streets. Elloren runs into her mate, Yvan, and they “kiss like [they’ll] merge straight into each other, [her] fingers knotting in his hair.” They break the passionate kiss to discuss Resistance business. 
  • Similar to Valentine’s Day but more magically induced, the East celebrates a holiday of love that heightens emotions for one evening, complete with a purple moon. Nearly every one of Elloren’s friends kisses or has sex with their partner, crush, or significant other. As the moon settles into effect, Elloren has a “vivid remembrance of Lukas’s lips on [hers], the two of [them] entwined in the forest . . . the memory shifts to a flush-deepening recollection of Yvan’s heated embrace in the North Tower, that night in [her] bed.” 
  • During the purple moon, Elloren’s friend, Tierney, kisses Elloren’s cousin, Or’myr. Tierney “makes an irresistible little sound of surprised pleasure, her full breasts soft against [Or’myr’s] chest, her hand coming up to caress his neck with unmistakable want.” However, the encounter ends quickly, and both decide they do not want to date each other. Later that night, Tierney kisses her friend, Viger, and “her lips meet his in a swirl of darkness.” 
  • To cool down from an argument in the mess hall, Trystan walks to the water, followed by Vothe. While having an emotional conversation, “Trystan grabs hold of him, his lips coming to Vothe’s.” They kiss a bit until Vogel’s forces suddenly arrive at their city. 
  • Elloren’s old professors, Jules Kristian and Lucretia Quillan, are also in the East on holiday. They decide to have their first date. Tired of waiting, Lucretia shows him her Sanjire root (a birth control method) and says, “I’m asking you to kiss me whenever you want from here on in.” They kiss but are interrupted by Vogel’s forces breaching the city. 
  • Elloren’s old friends, Aislinn and Jarod, are in the forest of the East’s capital city during the purple moon. Aislinn asks Jarod to “take [her] to mate.” They go into the woods, and it is implied that they have sex. 
  • Thierren and Sparrow, finally in the East, celebrate this holiday by kissing. “Sparrow falls into [Thierren’s] loving, passionate kiss.” They are interrupted by Vogel’s forces arriving at the city. 
  • Mora, the woman who volunteered to house Elloren in the East, and Elloren’s old professor Fyon, are trying to celebrate the holiday at Mora’s house. Fyon’s hands “slide around her waist and up through her braided hair, his honeyed kiss deepening as Mora traces her fingers down the long column of his neck.” They are kissing when Vogel’s forces arrive and interrupt them.  
  • Vogel gains a form of mind control over Elloren, and Yvan attempts to break it by kissing her. His “mouth claims [hers] once more, forcing a stream of power into [her] that drives Vogel’s hold on [her] back a fraction further.” He is successful and frees her.  
  • Elloren escapes from Vogel into the forest and becomes a Dryad. Yvan and Elloren choose to renew their mating bond by kissing again. Yvan “leans down, eyes molten, and brings his lips to [hers].” They kiss, and then the book ends. 

Violence 

  • In the prologue, Marcus Vogel finds the Shadow Wand and takes it from a Death Fae in the forest. He murders the Fae in the process. He “draws his iron blade and hurls it across the table. The knife slams into [the Fae’s] chest, a look of shock passing over the young man’s face as he falls to the ground.” 
  • Vogel has flashbacks of being abused as a child. “Blows rain on the priest’s face, his small shoulders as he cowers and curls into a pathetic ball, pleading in a child’s voice, Momma, stop. . . no! I repent! I vow to repent! 
  • At the end of the previous book, Elloren teleports to the East and immediately encounters a creature attacking a family and promptly defeats it. In this book, the teenage girl of the family attacks Elloren. “Her knife finds its mark above [Elloren] with a dull thwack.” However, they make peace, and no harm is done. 
  • As Trystan trains in the East, he’s unpopular because of the color of his skin. Everyone thinks he’s trying to sabotage them from within. An assassin attacks him during training. “She draws back her arm and hurls a silver rune star at Trystan.” He is unscathed, and the assassin is arrested.  
  • Aislinn has successfully escaped from her abusive husband, but Sparrow watches as Aislinn undresses, noting “lash marks all over her form and bruising on her breasts. And bite marks.” 
  • As Trystan tries to save refugees from the river’s current, one of the refugees is suspicious of him because he’s Gardnerian. Once everyone is safe on the boat, the teenage refugee “surges forward and pushes Trystan clear off the boat.” Trystan has recovered safely.  
  • When Aislinn reunites with her crush, Jarod, she tells him about the abuse. Jarod offers to kill her ex-husband, but Aislinn replies, “No, I’ll be the one to kill him.” 
  • Over the course of fourteen pages, the country of the Amaz is attacked and razed to the ground. The Gardnerians surprise the Amaz and storm into the capital city, killing and wounding thousands with enslaved dragons. As an example of the violence, during the battle, “a Mage’s neck snaps back as [a] dragon’s head bursts into a ball of emerald flame, the dark creature’s flight pattern chaotic as the Mage’s wand falls from his hand.” The Mage and the dragon are attacked and killed by the head of the Amaz queen’s guard, Valasca.  
  • Lukas Grey is Vogel’s prisoner, and Vogel sporadically tortures him. “Pain strafes through Lukas’s [magic] lines as he’s hit by a blast of Shadow, a guttural cry escaping his throat as his body spasms.” Lukas’s magic is depleted, and his body is left sore and aching. 
  • During the purple moon, one of Elloren’s friends, Nym’ellia, is attacked by citizens of the East. She cries while saying, “One of them threw a rock at me and it hurt.”  
  • One hundred pages of the novel consist of Vogel’s forces attacking the capital city of the East, and each of Elloren’s friends fighting them off. It starts with the Death Fae, Viger, announcing that he “can sense impending death,” and there’s a loud noise as a mountain in the distance explodes. This starts Vogel’s onslaught, which hurts and kills many citizens of the East. Elloren and Vogel battle, but she escapes in the last thirty pages of the book.  
  • At one point during Elloren’s battle with Vogel, he brings Lukas Grey in front of her and transfers Elloren and Lukas’s marriage-binding magic to himself. Vogel is magically bound to Elloren in marriage and hurts Lukas in the process. Elloren’s “heart tightens with agony” and soldiers “grab hold of Lukas’s bindings, dragging him away.” 
  • As Elloren communes with the trees in the forest, they show her images of the Shadow Wand’s historical destruction. She watches as “an army of grey-eyed Keltish soldiers amassing around the king as they advance on the city. Death everywhere.” 

Drugs and Alcohol 

  • On a national holiday, a friend of the Resistance, Thierren, suggests to Elloren’s friend, Sparrow, that they “start [celebrating] with some forbidden wine.” As the night drags on, the two have a conversation while drunk; Sparrow is “seeming[ly] entranced by the glowing beauty of the rose-flavored spirits.” 
  • While confronting Vogel, Elloren and her old roommate, Ariel, are threatened by him. Ariel has a history of forced addiction; she had been kept in prison and force-fed an opiate-like substance called nilantyr. In this confrontation, Vogel threatens to “shove nilantyr down [Ariel’s] throat until [she] begs for more.” This doesn’t actually happen, and Ariel is now addiction free. 

Language   

  • Language such as stupid, idiot, and hell appear frequently. 
  • The word whore is used three times. 
  • Bitch is used twice, and ass is used once. 

Supernatural 

  • This series contains all manner of supernatural creatures, including magic spiders, horrifying monsters, Fae, demons, Kelpies, Lupines, witches, dragons, Dryads, Amazonian warrior women, Icarals, lizard people, wyverns, Selkies, and people with skin of all colors of the rainbow. 
  • Most of the magic appears in magical battles in two ways. The first is Marcus Vogel’s magical creation of shadow monsters that attack Elloren and her friends. “In unison, the Marfoir grin. Their legs click outward as one, extending then drawing inward once more toward the shield, almost touching it. Curling shadow begins to rise from the tip of each pale spider limb to flow over the [Amaz capital city’s protective] dome, hugging its surface and spreading out, the Marfoir’s forms darkening as the fog of Shadow advances. . . the insectile eyes of the Marfoir directly before [Freyja], a terrifying smile on his bone white lips.”  
  • The second way magic is used in battle is through wand magic and spells. When trying to unbind Elloren’s magic from the forest, “Trystan and Lucretia bring the tips of their wands close to Or’myr’s stone and murmur spells.” They are attacked by the forest and use wands and spells to protect themselves.  

Spiritual Content 

  • The book opens in a prologue from Priest Apprentice Alaric Fynnes’s point of view. In the name of their religion, he “accompanies his mentor, Priest Vogel” to the Lost Islands, where Vogel finds the Shadow Wand and kills a Death Fae.  
  • As Vogel’s forces surround the Amaz capital city, Vogel says to a random soldier, “It is the Ancient One’s will [that the Icaral of prophecy stays alive]. So, let the Prophecy come to completion. The Holy Magedom will soon have possession of Erthia’s most dangerous weapon, and she will smite the Icaral demon without mercy.” 
  • Elloren’s friend, Wynter, is under the influence of the Zalyn’or necklace—the religious brainwashing instrument used by the Elves to enslave people. “The Zalyn’or necklace tightens and Wynter’s head arches back, a strangled cry torn from her throat. She shudders as she’s swept up in a new, overpowering Zalyn’or yearning, the old yearning to be purely [Elven] stripped away. Yes, she still wishes with everything in her for her demonic wings to be torn from her back. But there’s a staggeringly fierce, new longing in her now—to have black hair, glimmering green skin, and black clothing. . . not the path of the [Elven] fate at all, but the [Gardnerian] religion.” 
  • The Gardnerian religion discriminates against non-heterosexual sexual orientations, and Vothe comments, “such a bizarre thing for a religion to hate. But [he’s] heard that there are whole passages in the Gardnerian religious book that condemn anyone who loves another of the same gender.”  
  • While in the Eastern Realm, Trystan discovers that the Eastern religion is more peaceful. “The Way of Vo. The prayer text practically everyone raised in [the East] knows by heart, and Vothe can tell that there is something new in it for Trystan.” Trystan begs Vothe to teach him his religion. This religion is not based on a god but on nature and meditation, more similar to Buddhism.  
  • As Elloren and Vogel fight, and Vogel strips Lukas and Elloren of their marriage and transfers it to himself, Elloren tells him that he can’t marry since he’s a priest. Vogel says he “relinquished [his] priestly role before [he] took hold of this fasting, as is allowed by the Blessed Book. Elloren, the Ancient One has made it clear to me. We are each other’s destiny.” 

by Kate Schuyler 

Diana and the Journey to the Unknown

Diana cannot rest until every kid is saved from Zumius, the alien boss who has kidnapped many children. After her voyage into the Underworld, Diana feels guilty that she couldn’t save every superpowered kid that Hades kidnapped. So, while the Amazons debate how to keep her safe, Diana decides to confront her enemies by herself. Determined to help, no matter the cost, Diana transports herself to a strange facility. 

After being drugged and thrown in a cage, Diana escapes outside, looking up to find three moons in the sky and no way home. However, nothing can stop Diana. She befriends some of the planet’s native inhabitants, but when the monsters tracking her threaten her new friends, Diana sacrifices herself by surrendering to protect them. This time, the guards take her to Zumius’s lair in the mortal world.  

When Zumius sends guards after Imani, the last superpowered child, Diana escapes once more. She emerges in an unfamiliar city filled with advanced technology and oddly dressed inhabitants. Despite facing extraordinary challenges for a twelve-year-old, Diana overcomes them with impressive resilience. Diana saves Imani and reactivates Imani’s powers. Then, Diana and Imani put themselves in danger to save the rest of the kids. With the power of the gods failing, no adults to help, and a skyscraper filled with guards in their way, Diana and Imani are bravely undaunted. Along the way, Diana discovers that, while she does have secret superpowers she never knew about, her real superpower is love—love for her family, friends, and people that push her to perform acts of wonder. 

Diana and the Journey to the Unknown serves as a perfect conclusion to the trilogy, although the sequence of events is somewhat overcomplicated. There are only a few implausible moments, such as guards repeatedly underestimating Diana, but these don’t overshadow the power of Diana’s character and the magic of this world. The Amazons are a great example of women empowering one another, and the kids Diana rescues will be an inspiration to kids everywhere. The rest of the story is well-constructed, using simple language and an easy plot that will engage the average reader.  

Readers who enjoy out-of-this-world adventures, Greek mythology, and amazing independent kids will love the world-jumping, new superpowers, and the brutish villains of Diana and the Journey to the Unknown. Diana travels to multiple worlds to save others, complete with monstrous aliens, magical poisons, and plenty of guards for Diana to outwit, all making for creative entertainment. Diana proves again that she’s a powerful character, accomplishing what even the gods could not by defeating Zumius. Overall, this is an inspiring story with a wonderful message: there’s always a way to adapt to the situation, no matter how hopeless it may seem. 

Sexual Content 

  • None

Violence 

  • After Diana escapes from the alien facility, she encounters an alien called a Targuni in the woods. Assuming the Targuni has come to imprison her, she attacks them. “With a swoop, she lassoed the creature with a final flourish. The Targuni rose unsteadily to their feet. They tugged at the rope encircling their shoulders, pulling frantically, struggling to break free. Diana tightened her grip.” The Targuni eventually tells Diana that they mean Diana no harm, and Diana lets them go.  
  • When Diana gets recaptured, she breaks the bars on her cage and interrogates a nearby guard for her friend Imani’s whereabouts. “Diana didn’t have time to negotiate. [The other guard] could be back any second, and it would be much harder to fight two. Swinging her lasso, she hurled it toward [the guard]. It launched into the air and wrapped itself around him. He pressed his arms against the lasso as though he could burst it with sheer force. His cheeks turned bright red. A few seconds later, as she expected, his shoulders drooped in defeat. His head hung low.” She gets the information from him and lets him go.  
  • The second guard comes back, and Diana attacks him. “Before [the other guard] could finish his sentence, Diana struck her sword out, upending the food in his hands and splattering the cheeseburger against his face. Then she shoved him as hard as she could. He fell backward onto the carpeted floor with a loud groan.” She runs past him and escapes.  
  • Once she finds the rest of the kids, she fights the guard so they can escape. “Diana crouched, waiting for [the guard] to approach. He was almost there. His hands inches from her wrist. She sliced the air with her sword; it skimmed his arm.” It’s a small wound, and while there are a couple more punches thrown, no one is grievously injured.  

Drugs and Alcohol 

  • After grasping the cage fragments and teleporting somewhere new, Diana is surprised by two scientists who are walking into the room. They see her and assume that she is in an altered state because of a gas triggered when someone teleports into that room. One of the doctors says, “Be that as it may, she’s under twice the usual dose, and she’s definitely not one of [the superpowered] kids. There’s a protocol to prepare for their arrival. Some sort of glitch must have occurred. It’s not the first time.” This implies they have drugged the other kids into submission. However, Diana is unaffected by the drug and pretends to be unconscious to buy time. 
  • While trying to rescue the kids from Zumius, Diana discovers that they’re being drugged by a substance that induces the feeling of hopelessness, ensuring the kids’ compliance. Diana’s friend Augustus says, “The kids won’t do anything. I can’t be absolutely certain what it is he’s given them to cause their apathy, but based on the scent when he administers it, I believe he’s using a pazzo bean. It instills hopelessness in whoever imbibes it.” Diana is briefly drugged by this substance but manages to ignore the effects. 

Language 

  • Language is tame. Words like stupid, idiot, and imbecile appear frequently

Supernatural 

  • Diana is a superhero, complete with superpowers and magical relics, like the Lasso of Truth. She fights monsters, aliens, and gods. Every page of this novel exhibits some kind of supernatural content. However, the magic is primarily wielded by kids with superpowers without spoken spells, just the wave of a hand. Magic is also present in the landscape, such as the magical island of Themyscira, hidden from the eyes of men. The monsters encountered are mostly aliens, and, while fantastically described, they do not have supernatural powers.  
  • The kids Diana is trying to rescue are described by two scientists trying to figure out how to contain Diana. “‘I’m just saying. If she’s one of those kids, her size doesn’t matter. You’ve seen them,’ [one scientist] replied defensively. ‘The metal bender nearly ripped the door apart when the charm wore off a smidge. And [another superpowered kid] had my arms go soft like jelly without even touching me before we got the second dose on her.’” 
  • Diana’s powers are described after she saves a kid from falling off a play structure.  “[A girl] held up her device [for Diana to see]. [In the video] there was a shifting of green grass—a blur—and then there was Diana; she swooped in, grabbing Fiona before she hit the ground. Someone had captured the moment. How is this possible? Diana stared at the image as it played and replayed. She wanted to wave it away as a trick of the eyes, except it was her. The blur in the image was Diana. She’d known she could run fast, but seeing herself doing it. . . it was far faster than she’d realized. In this video, she was. . . impossibly fast.” 
  • While Diana is trying to rescue the kids, she climbs up a building and falls, discovering a new superpower. “Diana hadn’t fallen. She was levitating in midair; her hands were up and swimming frantically inches from the edge of the beam she’d slipped from. Diana gritted her teeth and, reaching up, she grasped onto a ledge. Hastily, she scrambled atop it and climbed onto the balcony.” 
  • After defeating Zumius, the kids need to figure out how to escape the skyscraper. A new friend, Aristaeus, can control insects and the wind. While escaping, bees flew through the open window and “propelled Aristaeus in the air. Diana shivered. They held him much like the [aliens] had held Diana up not so long ago [to capture her]. But this time was different. These creatures promised safety. Imani tapped her hands against the bees and closed her eyes—and within seconds, they flew invisibly through the air. As the kids let the bees sweep them up, Imani guided them to her home.” 

Spiritual Content 

  • Princess Diana grew up among the Amazons, a community of warrior women who worship the Greek gods. In Diana and Journey to the Unknown, she meets, fights, and even collaborates with a couple of them. The Greek gods or references to them appear on nearly every page of this novel. For example, when Diana confronts Zumius, claiming the gods will come to her rescue, Zumius replies, “The gods! They’re frazzled as can be, aren’t they? Hades was dishing out the yummiest gossip before they neutralized him. But the fact of the matter is it’s too late for any of your gods to actually do anything at this point.” 
  • Diana’s friend Imani is a demigod and the child of Zeus. Diana mentions this when trying to get Imani to activate her abilities. “Zeus—your father—said you could stay in our world and learn more about your powers and who you were. He said returning to this world—the mortal world—with your memories and powers intact compromised your ability to live a normal life. You chose to forget. That is why none of what I’m telling you rings a bell. But it’s all true. Every last word.” 
  • Once the kids find their way back to Imani’s house, Zeus appears at the end to congratulate the kids on saving the day. “Lightning crackled in the distance. The home rumbled gently beneath their feet before a white burst of light appeared in the room. Diana blinked. It was Zeus. He wore a white tunic and a gold crown and held an enormous staff in his hands.” 

by Kate Schuyler 

Reckless

Reckless follows the shocking events of the previous book, Powerless. In an act of self-defense and revenge, rebel traitor Paedyn Gray kills the King. To escape punishment, Paedyn flees Ilya, leaving the kingdom — and its princes — reeling in her wake. Crown Prince Kitt, shaken by his friend’s betrayal, becomes increasingly paranoid and withdrawn, refusing to leave his room. Prince Kai, Ilya’s Enforcer, swears to hunt Paedyn down, even if he once loved her.   

Kai tracks Paedyn to the nearby kingdom, Dor, where she has become an underground fighter. With his men, Kai captures Paedyn and forces her to hike through barren desert land to return to Ilya. However, a group of rebels captures them, hoping to trade Kai’s release for Paedyn’s pardon. Their plans are subverted when Rafael, Paedyn’s old boss at the fighting ring, captures her and Kai. To escape, Paedyn and Kai must set aside their differences and work together. In the process, forbidden feelings threaten to return, forcing the ultimate choice between old duty and new love.  

Paedyn is an underdog, relying on her wits to stay one step ahead of an entire government that is calling for her arrest, dead or alive. She often prioritizes survival over morality, though not without guilt. For example, she hesitates to steal from the hardworking people of Dor, yet ultimately does, lacking any other means to support herself. While Paedyn is dedicated to the rebel cause of seeking to uplift Ordinaries from Elite oppression, her lack of resolve may frustrate some readers. Despite swearing multiple times that she will kill Prince Kai, Paedyn does not do so. On an emotional level, readers will sympathize with Paedyn’s inability to harm someone she once cared deeply for. However, considering the greater good, Paedyn’s choices unintentionally come off as selfish, prioritizing her personal feelings over the survival of her people.   

Likewise, Kai’s charming and witty nature often clashes with the grim reality of his mission, which he rarely takes seriously. For example, Kai often flirts with Paedyn, which diminishes both the severity of his objective and his relationship with his late father. Readers looking for a fun enemies-to-lovers story, in which characters claim murderous intent but instead reignite their romance with a passionate kiss, will find much to appreciate in Kai’s character and his romance with Paedyn. While Kai often falls on the wrong side of the conflict, siding with the Elite, readers will understand that he is not an inherently bad person, but rather forced into a morally compromising position by his family. Readers will root for him to break free of his late father’s corrosive influence. However, a more cynical eye will question whether Kai can truly love the same person who killed his father, traumatized his brother, and threw his kingdom into chaos.  

Reckless focuses on the progression of Kai and Paedyn’s relationship as they fluctuate between enemies and lovers, against the backdrop of a country on the brink of revolution and ruin. In the kingdom of Dor, where the people do not have supernatural abilities, Ordinary Paedyn and Elite Kai are finally on even footing. In captivity, faced with a more pressing threat than their mutual animosity, Paedyn and Kai become reluctant allies with the potential for romance. While the conflict between the rebels and the established hierarchy provides thrilling action sequences, it contributes more to the development of Kai and Paedyn’s relationship than to the advancement of the plot. Large portions of the plot are repetitive and do not further the story, instead falling into a cycle of capture, escape, capture, escape, capture, escape – thereby negating any significance of the capture or the escape.  

This story is told from the dual points of view of Paedyn and Kai. Both rehash the major conflict of the previous book — the struggle between duty and love. They are forced to ask themselves if pursuing a romance is worth jeopardizing their worldviews, morals, familial obligations, and the future of their kingdom. Readers who instantly answer no will not enjoy this book. Due to the lack of stakes and consequences – unlike the major character deaths and world-shaking revelations featured in the previous book – Reckless ultimately feels like a placeholder for the conclusion of the series, Fearless 

Sexual Content   

  • After agreeing to a temporary alliance, Kai and Paedyn share an angsty, yet steamy kiss. Kai describes, “Our mouths crash together. I can taste the loathing on her lips, the anger in each swipe of her tongue. She kisses me hard, biting my lip to draw blood… Her fingers are buried in my hair while mine dig into her hips. This kiss is deep and anything but tender.”  On the brink of death, Kai and Paedyn share another passionate kiss. Kai describes, “I kiss her frantically, memorizing the feel of her lips against mine. . . Her arms slide from my wrists to wrap around my neck. She’s clinging to me as though I’m an anchor she’s willing to sink with.”  
  • The kiss is then described from Paedyn’s perspective. “I sigh against his mouth when his tongue meets mine… His teeth pull at my bottom lip… The action sets my body ablaze, spreading fire through every vein. My mouth moves in time with his, matching every swipe of his tongue, every move of his lips.” The scene lasts two pages. 
  • Kai’s inner monologue frequently emphasizes his attraction to Paedyn; however, he is often tormented by it. For example, he thinks, “She’s unbearable, really. But not in the way that makes it any easier to look away. No, everything about her is a bold sort of beauty, like a rose proudly displaying its thorns. She’s alluring in the way that most deadly things are. It’s captivating.” Paedyn is more reluctant to admit her feelings, though her heart often “beats hard” in Kai’s presence.     

Violence   

  • Kai and Paedyn falsely promise to kill each other. Upon gaining an opportunity to kill Kai, Paedyn thinks, “I could kill him… I’m hesitating… he makes his way out of the alley… I won’t hesitate again.”  
  • When pressed on whether he will complete his mission, which will presumably result in Paedyn’s execution, considering the severity of her crime, Kai sincerely replies, “Of course. It’s my duty.”  
  • To prevent Paedyn from running away, Kai throws a dagger at her. He describes, “with the flick of my wrist, I send the knife flying toward her… it meets its mark, slicing through her thigh as she leaps. Her cry of pain makes me flinch… she staggers to her feet, blood streaming down her leg.” The wound is superficial, leading to no serious long-term injury. 
  • In self-defense, Paedyn kills a guard attempting to collect her bounty. During a brief, yet bloody fight, “the back of his skull collides with my [Paedyn’s] nose. I cry out, already feeling blood… The guard throws me onto my back, his weight pressing down on me nearly as hard as his hands crushing my windpipe… I can barely see what it is I do next. The blade slides easily into his heart.”  
  • Kai and Paedyn attempt to escape Rafael, Paedyn’s ex-boss. After getting trapped in a tunnel filling with water, Kai and Paedyn believe they will drown. However, at the last moment, they escape into an alley.  
  • While working as an underground fighter, Paedyn fights. For example, during a match against a fan favorite, Slick, Paedyn describes, “Slick is persistent, raining down… He blocks my jab before barreling into me, pushing me hard against the cage… my foot finds the inside of his knee, kicking hard… Slick bites down a scream… [he is] clutching what is likely a dislocated kneecap… His elbow strains as I pull his arm down unnaturally, hyperextending the joint.” Paedyn wins the fight, which lasts around three pages. The gory action is interwoven with descriptions and brief flashbacks of her friendship with Adena, a character who died in the previous book.  
  • Ambushed by bandits while traveling through the desert, Paedyn witnesses an arrow strike Kai’s arm. He “slowly sinks to his knees, displaying the deep gash stretching across the length of his shoulder. I saw the flash of an arrow before it tore through his skin, splitting flesh in an instant.” Kai makes a full recovery, although he is left with a scar. 

Drugs and Alcohol   

  • After Kai and Paedyn are unable to remember important details of their capture, Kai speculates that “they may have drugged us.”  

Language  

  • Profanity is used often. Profanity includes damn, hell, ass, shit, and bitch. For example, before Paedyn kills a guard, he calls her a “crazy bitch.”   
  • As a result of getting back together, Kai tells Paedyn he now “believe[s] in a God” because she is “paradise.”  

Supernatural  

  • The Elites have superhuman abilities. For example, a “brawny” is an Elite with superhuman strength, depicted as smashing through a door.  

Spiritual Content   

  • None  

by Kerry Lum  

The Hammer of Thor

A couple of months ago, Magnus Chase’s life changed forever. . . because he died. But Magnus didn’t go down without a fight, and he earned himself a place in Valhalla, the Norse afterlife for heroes. It’s not easy getting accustomed to life in Valhalla, where Magnus’s days are filled with fighting and feasting amongst the honorable dead. But just when Magnus is finally settling in, his afterlife is disrupted by the news that Thor, the formidable god of thunder, has lost his hammer. A hammer-less Thor means a defenseless Earth, and armies of giants are lining up to invade while the god is weak.  

With his friends by his side, Magnus embarks on a perilous quest to find Thor’s hammer. With Loki, the cruel trickster god, pulling strings from his prison, will Magnus be able to complete his mission, or will he play right into his enemies’ hands? 

The Hammer of Thor is a witty and entertaining dive into the world of Norse mythology. Narrated by Magnus, readers will be guided through the story by his sarcastic sense of humor. Throughout the novel, Magnus often acts out of empathy and compassion for others. This, combined with his self-aware commentary, makes him a lovable and relatable character. Readers will find themselves invested in Magnus’s story. 

One of this book’s greatest strengths is its diverse cast of characters. On his quest, Magnus is joined by Sam, a devout Muslim whose faith is as strong as her work ethic and skills with an ax. Her knowledge and determination drive the plot and save Magnus on many occasions.  

Fan-favorite dynamic duo Hearth and Blitz also accompany Magnus. Hearth, a deaf elf with a skill for sorcery, and Blitz, a dwarf with a passion for fashion design, are fiercely protective of one another. The pair’s unique skills and personalities steal every scene they share.   

Finally, Magnus finds himself drawn to Alex, the shapeshifting child of Loki, who adds a bit of chaos to the story. Alex is a fierce fighter who is proud of her identity as both a shapeshifter and a transgender and genderfluid person. In addition to driving the plot and making this novel unforgettable, these characters offer readers an opportunity to consider new perspectives and learn about those who are different from them.  

The Hammer of Thor balances tension with moments of levity and handles serious topics in a way that is respectful and impactful. This novel addresses issues such as homelessness, ableism, transphobia, and child abuse in ways that are easy for younger audiences to understand. It also explores themes of trauma and grief, depicting the various ways characters mourn their losses. These subjects are explored in an age-appropriate manner that feels safe and inviting to children, as the story maintains its optimistic and entertaining voice. 

Readers do not have to be familiar with Rick Riordan’s previous works to enjoy the Magnus Chase and the Gods of Asgard Series. This trilogy is a strong standalone series with unique new characters and settings. Fans of Riordan will enjoy references to his other series, as well as his entertaining conversational writing style. Fans and new readers will be interested in reading the Magnus Chase and the Gods of Asgard Series because it opens a new world of magic and mayhem.  

This novel contains themes of friendship, perseverance, and strength. Throughout the story, Magnus and his friends often support each other through difficult situations. The bond the characters share empowers them as they work together to overcome every obstacle that comes their way. Despite facing setbacks, the heroes continue to work towards their goals, refusing to abandon their quest. Magnus and his friends are resilient, and readers can find strength through their actions. 

The Hammer of Thor is a must-read for middle-grade audiences that will entertain readers while encouraging empathy and introspection. This novel will help audiences find the joy of reading while taking them on an adventure that explores mythology and friendship. This fast-paced story will hook readers from the start and will be remembered long after they turn the last page.     

Sexual Content 

  • Magnus’s friend Halfborn implies that his girlfriend Mallory likes seeing him shirtless when they are preparing for a practice battle. Mallory comments that Halfborn “always goes into battle bare-chested.” Halfborn replies, “Are you complaining about that?” This causes Mallory to blush.  
  • Loki arranges a marriage between Sam and a giant against Sam’s will. Sam says, “We have to find Thor’s hammer before the first of spring or. . . I will have to marry a giant.” Sam and her friends prevent the wedding from occurring.   

Violence 

  • A magical goat named Otis is struck in the chest with an ax. “Living in Valhalla, I was used to deadly weapons flying out of nowhere, but I was still surprised when an ax sprouted from Otis’s furry chest. . . the ax had pierced his heart.” Otis dies, but due to his magical nature, he comes back to life.   
  • Magnus chases after Otis’s killer and engages in combat with them. “An ax hurtled from above, slicing the buttons off my denim jacket. An inch closer and it would’ve opened up my chest.” The fight scene is described over five pages. The killer escapes and leaves Magnus behind on a rooftop. 
  • Magnus and his friends participate in a practice battle in Valhalla against the other dead heroes who live there, such as Charlie, T.J., and Big Lou. During this battle, “Halfborn and Mallory chopped us a path through a pack of berserkers. T.J. shot Charlie Flannigan in the head. . . We dodged a volley of fiery tar balls from the balcony catapults. We had a brief sword battle with Big Lou from floor 401.” Because they are in Valhalla, everyone who dies in this battle will come back to life. This fight scene is described over 15 pages. 
  • Alex decapitates a wolf using a garrote after the wolves attack an old man in an alley. Alex “lashed out with her wire, using it like a whip. With a single flick, one of the wolves lost its head.” 
  • Alex is bitten on the neck and killed by a wolf. “The last beast took her by the throat. She wrapped her fingers around its neck, but her eyes were losing focus.” After her death, Alex is reborn in Valhalla.  
  • Hearth breaks his ankle after falling into a tomb. Magnus “heard a wet snap followed by Hearth’s grunt, and [he] knew immediately what happened.” Magnus heals Hearth. 
  • Magnus and his friends fight zombies in a tomb. “Sam thrust her spear under [a zombie’s] jaw. The weapon’s light burned away his head like a flame going through toilet paper.” This fight is described over four pages.  
  • Magnus’s Uncle Randolph stabs Blitz in the stomach with a magical blade called the Skofnung Sword because he is following Loki’s orders. “With a cry of horror he buried the Skofnung Sword in Blitzen’s gut.” Blitz is badly injured, but he eventually recovers. 
  • After Uncle Randolph stabs Blitz, Magnus retaliates by slashing “upward, and the Skofnung Sword flew out of Randolph’s grip, along with. . . a couple of pink things that looked like fingers.” Randolph recovers from his injuries.  
  • The police shoot Hearth as he and his friends run away from a party that had become dangerous. “Behind us, a shot rang out. Everyone flinched except Hearth. . . Hearth stumbled, a red stain soaking his shirt.” Hearth recovers from this injury. 
  • Sam kills a giant named Little Billy with an ax. “In one fluid moment, Sam turned and threw her ax right at Billy. The giants gasped. Little Billy’s eyes went even more cross-eyed as he stared at the hatchet now sprouting from his forehead.” 
  • Sam hits a giant named Thrynga in the side with an ax. “Samirah’s ax hurtled across the room and embedded itself in Thrynga’s side.” Thrynga recovers from this injury. 
  • Magnus breaks his ribs when he collides with a stalagmite during a battle. Magnus “slammed into a stalagmite. Something in [his] chest went crack.” 
  • Loki kills a snake by breaking its spine. Loki “grabbed the snake that had been dripping venom on him, yanked it off its stalactite, and snapped it like a whip.” 
  • Uncle Randolph falls into a pit and dies. Uncle Randolph “slipped sideways into the darkness without a sound.” 
  • Thor smites Thrynga, killing her. “Thor pointed his hammer at Thrynga as casually as if he were channel surfing. Tendrils of lightning shot from the runes engraved in the metal. The giantess burst into a million bits of rubble.”      

Drugs and Alcohol 

  • Sam goes into an alley that “heroin junkies liked to shoot up in. . . which made it a great place to get beaten, robbed, or killed.” No drug use is depicted in this scene. 

Language   

  • Halfborn calls someone a “meinfretr.” Magnus says that this is an Old Norse swear word that translates to “something like stinkfart.” 
  • Mallory makes a gesture with her hand that is equivalent to giving someone the middle finger. “Mallory made a V with her fingers and flicked them under her chin.”  
  • The word idiot is used many times. For example, Mallory tells Halfborn, “You’re an idiot.”

Supernatural 

  • Sam is a Valkyrie, a warrior who leads the souls of dead heroes to Valhalla, the Norse afterlife for heroes who died bravely in battle. Sam comments on her role, calling it her “part-time job reaping souls of the dead and running top secret missions for Odin.”  
  • Magnus comments on the various things he has done since his death and rebirth. Magnus “travelled the Nine Worlds meeting Norse gods, elves, dwarves, and a bunch of monsters with names I couldn’t pronounce. I’d scored a magical sword that presently hung around my neck in the form of a runestone pendant.” 
  • Magnus speaks with a magical anthropomorphic goat named Otis. “Otis climbed into the chair I’d reserved for Sam. He sat on his back haunches and put his front hooves on the table.” 
  • Magnus recalls fantastical things he did in the previous book. “I’d played catch-the-lava-ball with fire giants. I’d eagle-skied over the rooftops of Boston. I’d pulled the world serpent out of Massachusetts Bay and defeated Fenris Wolf with a ball of yarn.”  
  • Magnus learns that he will have to encounter a wight, which is “a powerful undead creature that likes to collect magical weapons.”  
  • Magnus has a magical talking sword named Jack. “As I bounded across Newbury Street, Jack sprang to full form in my hand. His blade—thirty inches of double-edged bone-forged steel— was emblazoned with runes that pulsed in different colors when Jack talked.” 
  • Alex can shapeshift because she is a child of Loki. “The animal grew into a regular teen, long and lanky, with a swirl of dyed green hair. . .”  
  • Sam and Magnus go for a ride on a flying horse. “Sam saddled a white stallion. She climbed on his back and pulled me up behind her, then we galloped out the gates of the stable, straight into the skies above Boston.”  
  • Hearth performs magic by casting runes. “From the inside pouch of his jacket, he produced a small collection of runestones.” 
  • Zombies come to life and attack Magnus and his friends. “To absolutely no one’s surprise, the twelve mummified warriors stepped out from their niches along the walls.” 
  • A pilot named Barry is briefly possessed by the mysterious person who killed Otis the Goat. “Barry’s new voice crackled with distortion and went up and down in pitch.” 
  • Magnus and his friends walk across the Bifrost, a rainbow bridge connecting Earth with Asgard, the home of the Norse gods. “Radiance surrounded us, fuzzy and hot. Rather than walking across a slick, solid surface, I felt like we were wading through the waist-high field of wheat.”  

Spiritual Content 

  • This novel is centered around Norse mythology and contains frequent depictions of and references to Norse gods. 
  • Sam is Muslim and comments on how she views the Norse gods. Sam says that she “doesn’t accept that Norse gods are gods. They’re just powerful beings. Some of them are my annoying relatives. But they are no more than creations of Allah, the only god, just like you and I are.”  
  • Magnus watches as Sam prays. “Sam took off her shoes. She stood very still at the foot of her rug, her hands clasped at her stomach, her eyes half-closed. She whispered something under her breath. . . Then she began her prayers, a soft, singsong chanting of Arabic that sounded like she was reciting a familiar poem or a love song. Sam bowed, straightened, and knelt with her feet tucked under her and pressed her forehead against the cloth.”    

 by Kelly Barker 

The Jumbies

Young Corinne La Mer isn’t afraid of anything, especially things that go bump in the night. While all the other kids in her small island village are scared of the creatures in the forest, Corinne lives on its edge and has seen nothing to validate her friends’ fears. After her mother passed, Corinne refused to be afraid of anything anymore.  

A practical and shrewd protagonist, Corinne is suspicious of a new woman who arrives on market day. The other children avoid her like the plague, whispering that she reeks of the forest, and their murmurs intensify when she approaches the witch’s table. Yet this mysterious figure intrigues Corinne. When the stranger stops at Corinne’s fruit stand, Corinne greets her politely. The woman, who introduces herself as Severine, raves about the oranges and insists they possess an almost magical quality. Soon, Severine seems to be everywhere in Corinne’s life—seducing her father and attempting to mother her. The longer Severine stays, the more strange phenomena occur.  

Strange incidents begin plaguing the village: Corinne’s friend Bouki nearly drowns while playing by the river, the local witch grows increasingly on edge with ominous warnings about Corinne’s family, and an unnatural stench fills Corinne’s house whenever Severine attempts to cook. As an accomplished cook herself, Corinne refuses to let her father eat anything Severine prepares. But one evening, she returns home late to find her father in a strange trance, staring at a bowl of Severine’s soup. 

Severine then reveals her true nature as a jumbie—a supernatural, hideous forest creature who claims to be Corinne’s aunt. She insists that Corinne is half jumbie herself, which explains her extraordinary talent for growing divine fruit. Severine demands that Corinne join her in reclaiming the village and island for the jumbies. When loyal, honest Corinne refuses, Severine uses magic to banish her from her own home and begins controlling the villagers one by one, starting with her father. 

Left with no resources and shaken by questions about her origins, Corinne recruits several friends to defeat Severine and protect their village—because failure means none of them will have a home to return to. 

The Jumbies is a wonderfully macabre story with a straightforward plot and accessible language, perfect for younger readers. However, readers averse to horror may want to avoid it due to some heavy, scary elements. The adult characters, aside from the witch, play disappointingly weak roles—Corinne’s father succumbs to Severine’s influence with little resistance, which feels somewhat lazy. Despite this flaw, the novel proves inspiring and creative, expertly weaving Caribbean folklore themes into well-crafted worldbuilding that remains descriptive without becoming overly complicated. 

The Jumbies offers a creepy atmosphere, imaginative monsters, and youthful wit that will captivate readers. The book features supernatural creatures ranging from evil to good, and Corinne discovers that many are simply seeking a better home in a world that has banished them to the forest. While some use horrifying methods to reclaim their territory, Corinne proves to be a kind and intelligent protagonist who recognizes that monsters like Severine don’t represent all of her kind. Ultimately, this beautiful story delivers a sweet message: blood doesn’t define family, and home can always be found elsewhere. 

Sexual Content 

  • None 

Violence 

  • When Corinne first meets brothers Bouki and Malik, they steal her necklace, tie it to an animal, and giggle as Corinne runs into the forest to retrieve it. When she returns with her necklace, she finds one of them “[holding] a small frog in his hands over the top of the well. It was struggling, but he held it firmly. Their next victim, Corinne thought. Corinne let [her necklace] dangle from her fingers. Its smooth surface gleamed. The smile slid off the boy’s face.” The boys run away, though they later become friends with her. 
  • When Corinne sets up her food stand, a woman insists that Corinne stole her spot. “‘Go somewhere else, darling,’ the seller said. Her lips smiled, but her eyes were as hard as pebbles.” Corinne decides it isn’t worth fighting and sets up elsewhere.  
  • To get back at Bouki and Malik, Corinne sets a trap for them, making them fall into a pit of scorpions. Bouki “barely noticed the small insect that scrambled up the rope and out of the well. Soon there was another and another. Bouki jumped back. ‘Scorpions!’ he cried out. Malik dropped the rope and ran to his brother. There was a scorpion hanging onto Bouki’s tattered shirt.” Nobody is hurt, and this settles the score between Corinne and the brothers. 
  • While Corinne swims in the river with her friends, Severine attacks them. The witch notices Severine trying to drown Bouki and dives in after Severine. “[The witch] knocked [Severine] away from the children. The jumbie turned and dug her bony fingers into the witch’s flesh. She bore down hard. The witch raised her right arm and struck mightily at the jumbie’s chest. At the same time, she felt a sharp pain as her other arm snapped in two.” The children are fine, but the witch loses her arm. The scene is one page.  
  • After Corinne kicks Severine out of her house, Severine storms into the forest. In her anger, she kills an animal. “[Severine’s] hand shot out and grabbed a small furry creature by the neck. It wriggled as Severine squeezed tighter and tighter with her thumb and forefinger until the small bones snapped and the creature became still.” 
  • When Severine cooks a trance-inducing dinner for Corinne and her father, Corinne refuses to eat it. “Severine pushed the bowl of stew toward Corinne. Corinne jerked away, causing Severine to slop stew onto the floor. Severine grabbed Corinne’s wrist and shoved her to the ground, right into the foul-smelling stew. ‘You can’t resist me!’ Severine shrieked.” The stew burns Corinne. 
  • There is a brief mention of slavery as Severine recounts her history with her sister. “I had a sister. She pitied people. She went inside the ships and saw that some of the people were chained below. She helped them escape and swim to the island while I dealt with the others. Some of the people [on the ship had] chained up others and left them to rot in the bottoms of their ships. My sister felt sorry for them. I never did.” 
  • Corinne tries to escape from Severine with her father, Pierre. “Corinne grabbed her papa around the waist and tried to hoist him out of the chair. He was much too large and heavy and they both fell on the floor. She got up and began to pull him away, but Severine grabbed his other hand and pulled Pierre back into his chair. Then she picked Corinne up by the neck. Corinne struggled and kicked at the air as Severine’s fingers began to squeeze tighter and tighter around her throat.” Corinne escapes with minimal bruising. 
  • Frustrated with Corinne, Severine decides to call all the monstrous creatures of the forest to her aid. One of them, a soucouyant, attacks Bouki and Malik. “As they crawled back toward the fighting, they picked up several stones and shoved them into their pockets. When they were finally at the side of the road, they loaded up their slingshots and started to shoot. The soucouyant backed up at first, but then it barreled toward them in a blur of flame. Just as it was about to engulf the boys, an oar smacked it to the ground.” The boys and Hugo, the baker who saves them with the oar, are unharmed. 
  • In the aftermath of the creatures attacking their village, Corinne describes the bloody scene. “Every now and then, the children stepped over gory tracks where the wounded had been dragged off into the woods. Whether the victims were human or jumbie, they could not tell. The island had never been so quiet.” This is the only part of the battle described.  
  • However, the jumbies soon come back for Bouki and Malik, kidnapping them and dragging them to the forest. “A little jumbie man was right behind Malik. Bouki grabbed Malik’s arm quickly, but the [jumbie] caught Malik’s other arm and Bouki’s leg in a vicious grip. It dragged the brothers back between the trees. The fighting adults never noticed. In seconds, all that was left of the brothers was one fake coconut husk foot and the small straw hat.” The boys are recovered unharmed.  
  • Corinne’s friend Dru has to fend off a jumbie alone when she gets separated from her friends. She sets her attacker on fire. “The smell of burning fur filled the air. The lagahoo rushed forward and fell against the bush that had entangled Dru. The force of the crash freed Dru. Only torn bits of her shirt and a few strands of hair were left behind.” Dru is unharmed; however, she loses most of her hair. 
  • When Corinne confronts Severine, Corinne’s father is under Severine’s control and restrains Corinne. “Pierre put his hands over Corinne’s mouth. She stamped on his feet and struggled to get free but it was no use. Fishing out on the sea had made her father a strong man, and now that Severine had changed him, he was even stronger. Corinne looked at the fallen oranges. She brought her foot down on a large one and turned her face away as the juice flew right up into Pierre’s face. He howled again and loosened his grip long enough for Corinne to pull away. Corinne grabbed another orange and threw it right at her father’s face.” Corinne’s father gains control of himself, and no one is harmed.  
  • After Pierre frees himself, Severine accidentally falls off a cliff. “Severine flailed and managed to grab onto the rock face, but her green cloth snagged in the branches of the tree. She tugged at the cloth. The tree tipped again and tore away from the cliff. A branch swept her hand off the rock, and Severine spiraled down, down, down with the tree toward the sea far below.” There is no description of her beyond this, and the story implies that Severine is dead.  

Drugs and Alcohol 

  • The story features magical potions, though characters only reference them rather than actually drinking them. While advising Corinne, the witch explains that “everybody wants a fast, easy solution. Maybe if you took care of your skin, you wouldn’t have gotten the boil in the first place. Maybe if you worked harder, you would make more money. Maybe that person isn’t the right one for you. Maybe if you found a better way to farm, your crop would come up better. But nobody wants to hear those things. They want a bottle. Instant success! Something to drink, or sprinkle, or spill on the ground. They want magic from nothing.” 
  • In an effort to kidnap Corinne, Severine drugs Pierre. “Severine leaned in to make sure every single drop went in. She watched him intently as the liquid went down his throat, and something in his eyes began to change. They became cloudy, as if a storm was swirling right in his eyes. She watched Pierre scoop more of the stew into his mouth. Then he dropped the spoon and attacked the bowl like a greedy animal.” 

Language 

  • Language is tame, but words like stupid, idiot, and hell appear frequently. 

Supernatural 

  • This novel uses Caribbean folklore and references to the supernatural on nearly every page. Corinne and her friends have many interactions with magic, mostly through magical creatures called jumbies and potions, though Corinne does have abilities of her own.  
  • For example, Severine is a jumbie. Before obtaining human form, Severine cries about her missing sister, and as her tears hit the ground, “they turned into centipedes that scattered over the graves.”  
  • The villagers have many stories about jumbies. Corinne explains that the villagers talk about “creatures with backward feet, and women who could shed their skin, and women with hooves for feet. Even though her papa told her these stories were not true, there must have been a reason no one ever came this far into the forest.” 
  • While saving Bouki from drowning, the witch notices Severine “turn herself invisible.” 
  • When Corinne figures out that Severine is a jumbie, Severine lets her façade fade. “Severine came closer. As she did, her body shrank down a little. Corinne could see insects were crawling up and around Severine’s body. Hundreds of millipedes and centipedes, cockroaches, and beetles crawled in and out of the crags of her body. They dashed in and out of the fine fur and bored their way through her chest, so that Corinne could see straight through it like an old rotten tree.” 
  • Severine studies Corinne’s necklace and notes that “it was Forming Magic, an ancient power that was created at the same time that the very earth was made. It was bigger and more powerful than she herself — more powerful than anything she had ever known.” This is why Corinne can grow oranges unnaturally well.  
  • When Bouki and Malik defeat the soucouyant, they describe her. “She was a soucouyant — a malicious fireball that would suck the lifeblood out of anyone, even a baby. Her skin pooled around her, leaving Bouki holding the empty shell of her hand. He shuddered and let it fall with a slap against the rest of the discarded skin while the flame-body gathered up into a ball and hovered a few feet above the ground.” 
  • Standing a ways away from where the jumbies are attacking her village, Corinne spots a jumbie who has clearly broken away from the fight. “When Corinne looked up, the woman smiled, then shed her skin and burst into yellow flames.” 
  • In her final confrontation with Severine, Corinne cries out of hopelessness. However, “The tears that streamed down Corinne’s cheeks had formed a tiny, muddy pool around [a] seed. The seed trembled. Then it split open at the bottom and a tiny shoot of the palest green emerged from it and rooted itself into the ground. Corinne blinked. This was not the witch’s magic. It was her own.” The tree grows and tempts Severine to climb it.  
  • In the aftermath of Severine, Corinne and the witch heal the village by planting new orange seeds. “‘Grow,’ [Corinne and the witch] said together. The seeds began to sprout. A few people in the crowd gasped. The orange trees curved upward. They hardened and turned brown as they grew into each other and formed a solid wall that reached far into the sky. The trees looked beautiful, but more than that, they smelled delicious. The people in the village couldn’t resist picking the fruit and eating it on the spot.” 

Spiritual Content 

  • The book begins on All Hallows’ Eve. While walking with her father, Corinne overhears villagers talking about how “the spirits are out tonight,” and the children whisper about wanting to stay inside for fear of jumbies and the spirits.  

by Kate Schuyler

Our Crooked Hearts

When unusual events start to take place around Ivy, she begins to question what she knows to be true. First, Ivy has a mysterious interaction with a naked woman in the woods. Then she finds a mutilated rabbit in her driveway. And her mom goes MIA – what is going on? As Ivy searches for the truth, she discovers that magic exists and, in fact, has played a large role in her life. Along with this, Ivy unveils family secrets that force her to confront past relationships as well as form new ones.  

Each chapter alternates between Ivy’s present-day perspective and a flashback perspective of Dana, Ivy’s mother, teenage years. Both the present day and the past are equally covered throughout the book. Best friends Dana, Fee, and Marion began practicing magic in their teens and were enchanted by the wonders and possibilities of it. However, after a disagreement, a rift is formed, and Marion practices dark magic. Dana becomes unsettled by the dangerous magic that Marion wants to unleash and does what she feels is needed to protect herself.   

Determined, Ivy begins to unveil the dark witchcraft that her mother has kept from her and begins to put together the missing pieces of her life. However, she still can’t find her mom or Aunt Fee anywhere, but her curious and strong-willed nature won’t let her quit. Ivy soon realizes that they are in danger, and she must save both from enemies who are seeking revenge. Will she be able to save them from powerful witches seeking vengeance? 

As a teenager, Marion Peretz introduced Dana and Fee to magic. For her whole life, Marion has felt lonely and has lacked a real connection with those around her. Once she discovered magic, Marion was infused with confidence. Her thirst for magic reflects her desire to feel empowered, causing her to take magical risks. However, this comes at a cost, and Marion’s selfish tendencies lead her to put herself, Dana, and Fee in danger. Readers are likely to find Marion’s vindictive behavior and actions grating as she only grows worse throughout the book. 

This magic-filled book explores the possibilities that magic has to offer and how it can be abused. Many of the characters struggle with immense curiosity, guilt, and selfish tendencies. Because of this, the story takes unexpected turns and keeps the reader in suspense. Moreover, the events that take place display the author’s imagination as well as a peek into the world of witchcraft. For example, one imaginative element is the occultists book. “You couldn’t look for things in the occultists book, couldn’t read it cover to cover . . . it worked. . . like a tarot deck, delivering the pages you needed to see.”  

The changing perspectives throughout the book provide the necessary background information for the plot and help to connect the past with the present. These perspectives make the reader wonder about Ivy and Dana’s strange relationship. Dana is very distant from her family, especially from Ivy. So, reading about Dana’s teenage years allows for the reader to understand her behavior and the events that led up to this. The author transitions from each perspective seamlessly, and it does not get confusing for the reader switching back and forth. Overall, the changing perspective adds to the story. 

Our Crooked Hearts’ eerie events grab the reader’s attention from the start, and the tension escalates, making the book hard to put down. The book’s creative storyline will leave readers impressed and searching to read another book by the same author. In particular, the unique content regarding the supernatural world makes the story all the more appealing. The author explores the ideas of friendship and betrayal but focuses on the importance of trust. This is a must-read for those interested in the world of magic and witchcraft. Its creative storyline will leave readers impressed. 

Sexual Content     

  • Ivy and her neighbor Billy, who happens to be her romantic interest, find themselves in Billy’s backyard treehouse, the same one that they used to play in as kids. They are lying beside each other, and they begin to kiss. “We smiled at each other, and when he kissed me, we were still smiling. Until we weren’t. He was beside me, then above me, propped up on one arm. He ran a hand firmly down my body, rib cage to thigh, then held me there and pulled me up closer. We kissed and kissed.” 

Violence 

  • During their teenage years, Marion, Dana, and Fee performed a spell that involved the death of a rabbit. “[The rabbit] was wild this time, and skinny despite the season . . . It fought and fought, twisting in Marion’s grip, finally jerking its head into a broken angle to bite her. Even through the pain of its yellow teeth she was silent. The rest of us hissed in dismay as her blood hit the wax. With a decisive stab her knife went in . . . Dying, it twisted free; Marion wrestled it back. She held it more efficiently this time, sawing away so fiercely a spurt of arterial blood hit my knuckles.” 
  • During the same spell, the three girls slice their palms with a knife. “[Marion] signaled to us and we sliced our palms, dropping to our knees to press them to the floor.” 
  • When Marion’s spell does not go to plan, she blames Fee and begins to go after her physically. Dana steps in, protecting Fee. “I pulled Marion off my best friend by her hair… Fee socked her in the gut to make her let go. Marion went at her again and I caught her around the stomach, hauling her down and pressing an arm to her throat.” 

Drugs and Alcohol     

  • At a high school party, Ivy and her best friend, Amina, discussed Ivy’s ex-boyfriend, Nate. “‘Did you see what he was drinking last night? Absinthe.’ Amina had big tattletale energy. ‘To be fair it was probably vodka with green food coloring, but still.’”    
  • Ivy and Billy illegally buy alcohol one evening. Ivy is using her fake ID to prove to Billy that it works. Ivy “marched him over to the liquor aisle and considered what I could afford, settling on a bottle of strawberry wild vines.” 
  • Marion, still stuck in the mirror world she had been bound to, drinks liquor, although she cannot get drunk because of the magical world she is in. “She couldn’t get drunk, but she drank anyway . . . Marion drank from every one of those bottles . . . Their liquors were bitter or treacly or sharp as a lightning bolt.” 

Language  

  • Profanity is used often, including fuck, motherfuckers, fucking, fucked, shit, bitch, asshole, and bullshit. 
  • The naked woman who appeared in the woods attempts to lure Ivy and Nate out from behind the trees they are hiding behind. In this creepy scene, the woman says, “Come out, come out, whoever you are . . . I said show yourselves, motherfuckers.” 
  • In response to the naked woman in the woods, Ivy and Nate are increasingly scared. “I felt the terror in Nate as he saw how this was gonna go. ‘Fuck this,’ he muttered.” 
  • When Dana and Fee discover that Marion is a witch, they are fascinated and want her to show them what she knows. When Marion asks what specifically they would like to learn, they respond with, “just… all of it. Fucking all of it.”  
  • Dana and Fee meet another witch, Sharon, and begin to learn a little bit about her past. Sharon tells them briefly about her brother, “He saved me when nobody else could be fucked to try.” 
  • Marion, Dana, and Fee get into an argument, and Marion grows increasingly angry. “Marion’s flat blue eyes came alive with rage. ‘You bitch,’ she said to Fee and charged her.” 
  • In a flashback, Dana and her future husband, Rob, meet for the first time at a bachelorette party. During their flirty banter, Dana says, “Don’t be the asshole quoting Tennyson to girls at the party.” 

Supernatural     

  • Two older, creepy men bother Dana, Fee, and Marion at the restaurant where they worked as teenagers. Marion performs a spell. “Marion went still . . . When she spoke, the words came low. A cadenced murmur that played havoc with my heart. ‘Let all his thoughts be seen . . . Let their dark matter touch the air. Let them trouble him from without.’”  
  • As the two men began to leave the restaurant, weirded out by Marion and what she is saying, cicadas begin landing on the men, one by one. “He [went] down, he was screaming with his lips closed, he was mashing his face into the sand. I didn’t know whether the insects were stinging or biting or just crawling over his skin, but they kept coming.” 
  • Marion shares her occultist book with Dana and Fee. Marion explains, “You couldn’t look for things in the occultists book, couldn’t read it cover to cover . . . it worked. . . like a tarot deck, delivering the pages you needed to see.” 
  • Marion, Fee, and Dana do their first spell together. “It began with a purification ritual. For three days we stayed inside, playing sick so we could avoid mirrors, direct sunlight, and human touch. We drank herbs steeped in spring water, briny with rock salt, and performed ablutions once an hour between sundown and sunup. . .  At sundown on the fourth day we gathered the spell’s ingredients.” This was meant to prepare them and their space for future spells.  
  • As Dana and Fee discover the world of magic and the power that it gives them, they practice with the occultists book. “We learned the many uses of moonlight. Every piece of magic the book gave us worked like a gateway drug, until we couldn’t imagine our lives without that thrill, that bend, that shock of the world giving way beneath our hands.” 
  • Marion describes the dead owner of her occultists book: Astrid Washington. Astrid is referred to on numerous occasions. Marion said, “Astrid was amazing. She wasn’t just an occultist; she was a healer.” 
  • Fee, Dana, and Marion perform a love spell, but the spell does not go as planned due to Marion’s deception and alternate agenda; summoning Astrid Washington. “The occultists book showed us a love spell. Its ingredients were for a wedding bouquet: ribbons, roses, lavender . . . In the middle of the spell Fee screamed. She reached under her shirt for the necklace that always nestled just below her throat’s hollow. . . When she pulled up her shirt to look, there was a fine cross-shaped mark where the crucifix had lain.”  
  • Marion proposes that they do a spell to increase their magical force. “Marion pinned the page with her finger and read aloud. ‘A blessing of power for those bold enough to take it. That my gifts may not stagnate . . . A spell for eight hands . . . Increased magical force. That’s the spell.’” However, due to Marion’s deception, the spell that they perform does not increase their magical strength but instead puts them in danger. 
  • Marion tricks Fee and Dana into doing a summoning spell. Fee says, “We were dragging Astrid Washington out of, what, Hell? Mother of God, Marion!” At the last minute, Dana and Fee figure out how Marion was deceiving them, and they put a stop to it.  
  • As Dana, Fee, and Marion begin another spell, they could feel that “Astrid was with [them], a presence at [their] backs, ahead of [them], pressing in from the sides.” 
  • Marion once again tricks Dana and Fee into casting a binding spell. “Holding the drifting veil above the manhole of mirror, [Marion] began to speak. ‘I charge you Astrid Washington, to do my bidding. To serve me. I charge you to bind yourself to me. To be my helpmeet and my familiar.” During the spell, Astrid begins to rise out of the mirror world. “Astrid hefted herself through the glass, crouching on its edge with her toes still dipped into mirror world.”  
  • Once Fee and Dana realize what is going on and see how angry Astrid feels, they try to break the spell and save Marion from Astrid’s resentment. Fee said, “Draw tight the power of three, add blood to a loving cup, and if ever the three should part, let the river swallow them up.” The spell begins working, and “the chant, multiplied by three, fizzing with the unwieldy charge of Astrid’s borrowed magic.” They are then pulled into the magic circle/mirror world, where Astrid was trapped, and they are forced to face her.  
  • Astrid threatens Fee. To stop the binding spell, Dana has only one choice. Since Marion and Astrid are bonded together, Dana thinks that “maybe I could steal just enough time to kill Marion. If she died, Astrid died, too. The circle broke. We were free.” Dana heaves Marion’s body through the mirror. Marion and Astrid are trapped in the mirror world and cannot be released without a spell.  
  • Ivy has magical abilities. She has lucid dreams and pulls other people into her dreams.  
  • Dana explains magic to Ivy. Dana says, “Some kinds of magic are just for you – the magic that grows in your blood. Everyone is well fed by different springs, different traditions. Folk magic, myth magic, we’ve got lots of that in our tree. You have to be careful, you’ve gotta keep your eyes off of other people’s paper . . . [Fee and I] learned when we were young not to siphon off springs that don’t belong to us.” 
  • Dana travels to see Mr. Lazar, an old man who sells obscure magical objects. She buys a forgetting box, which is used to make Ivy forget that she is a witch and can use magic.  
  • Dana gets fired from her waitressing job and stumbles upon Linh, an old friend of hers who can talk to the dead. Linh explains, “It’s never a good thing when a spirit comes looking for me. It’s way, way better when I’m the one doing the courting.” 
  • Ivy performs a spell in her room. “Ivy propped a mirror against her footboard. She pressed a blend of clarity oils into seven crucial places. She looped a thread of dark hair around her right ring finger – spirited off of her best friend Billy’s shoulder – and incanted as she used that fingertip to trace a sigil over the mirror. Mist spilled into the glass, displacing her reflection.” She can now see what Billy is doing through the mirror.  
  • Ivy discovers a man not moving in the home that Marion had broken into. She panics and asks Marion what is wrong with him. Marion explains what she had done to the man. “They’re not dead. While they’re sleeping, they won’t die, or age, or thirst. They’re as safe as it’s possible to be in this world. Their house fulfills a need, and I’ll give it back when I’m through.” 
  • Marion gives Ivy the forgetting box that Dana used on her years ago, hoping Ivy will regain her memories. Ivy attempts to open it, “The box didn’t glow or hover or hum. It just warmed to my skin, loosening like a tablet of wax. I could see the seam now, and the catch, as easy as if they’d always been there.” 
  • Marion performs a scrying spell. “Steadily Marion poured water into a heavy silver bowl. She sprinkled its surface with Dana’s blood and spoke the words and waited to see what would come. There was a haze, pearlescent, then a figure came into view: Dana’s red hair.” This spell allows Marion to see the real world and escape her entrapment.  
  • Astrid Washington and Marion perform a spell together to release them from the world they have been trapped in. “Astrid began the incantation that would unwind their world. As she incanted Marion closed her eyes against a cast melancholy.” 
  • There is a scene that essentially tells the entire story of Ivy’s life, which was trapped in the forgetting box. It recounts all her experiences with magic, Billy, and the life she was forced to forget.  
  • When Ivy finds her mom and Fee under a spell, she tries to save them. “If they [are] sleeping, there [is] a chance I could reach them. I could fall asleep right here and pull them out of Marion’s nightmare, and into a dream of my own.”  
  • Ivy puts Marion’s soul into the forgetting box, ultimately saving both her mom and Aunt Fee from Astrid and Marion. “I . . . pulled out the golden box, and pressed it to the place I’d drawn [Marion’s] blood . . . the box opened its hungry mouth.” 

Spiritual Content     

  • None    

Heartless Hunter

Two years ago, the Republic was founded when rebels killed the witch queens. Thus ended the tyranny of the Reign of Witches and began the dawn of a “better” world. However, not much has changed since the cruelty of the witches has been replaced by the ruthlessness of the Blood Guard. Now, all witches are condemned and executed. Those who sympathize with or harbor witches also suffer a grim fate.  

Rune Winters is the perfect aristocrat: shallow, fashionable, and arrogant. After turning in her witch grandmother, Rune Winters is the darling of the Republic. But what the Republic doesn’t realize is that this image is an act, put on to protect Rune’s secret identity as a witch vigilante, the Crimson Moth. 

Rune, as the Crimson Moth, is focused on protecting and saving girls from being purged. She was on her way to save her grandmother’s friend, Seraphine, but got there too late. Now to save Seraphine, Rune will need insider intel, and her target is the captain of the Blood Guard and witch hunter, Gideon Sharpe. Gideon has been locked in a deadly game with the Crimson Moth, as every witch he captures is magically spirited away by her. New intel has led him to suspect Rune Winters, and so his current objective is to get close to Rune and figure out her secrets. As the two of them flirt, scheme, and manipulate to reach their goals, they find themselves betrayed by the thing they least expected, their own hearts.  

Rune has never forgotten the day she had to turn in her Nan and channels her pain into saving others. She couldn’t save her grandmother, but she can save the next innocent girl taken by the Blood Guard. Readers will be absolutely captivated by Rune’s strength of will and heart, as she continues to risk herself in order to save just one more girl. As an aristocrat and beloved by the Republic, Rune doesn’t need to endanger herself, but she does. She uses her privilege to help witches and witch sympathizers who are looked down upon by society. Rune’s stubbornness and determination make her likeable and admirable because she refuses to compromise or give up when things become difficult. Rune is a role model for audiences because even as she struggles with conflicting emotions and harrowing circumstances, she always tries to do the right thing. 

Rune is not alone in her quest. She can rely on her friends Alex Sharpe and Verity de Wilde. Alex is the genuine heart of this book with his steadfast loyalty and caring nature. While everyone is consumed by hatred, he alone sees a future where witches and non-witches can live together in peace. When he discovers that Rune is a witch, Alex accepts Rune as she is and continues to love her. While Alex helps Rune because she is his friend, Verity assists Rune because she is just as committed to saving witches. Verity is smart and dedicated to Rune’s cause because of her love for her dead sisters, who were witches.  

Rune even captivates Gideon Sharpe, Alex’s brother, with whom she falls in love. Gideon is a tortured soul and absolutely committed to the cause of hunting witches. He thinks that witches are all ultimately evil, but this belief comes from a place of hurt and trauma. His beliefs are ultimately tested when he starts to fall for Rune. Like his brother, Gideon is loyal to a fault and compassionate. He cares about everyone so much that he will do whatever it takes to protect them from the suffering he endured. Readers will find Rune and Gideon’s romance hopeful, but heartbreaking, as they find acceptance in each other for their scars, but must separate because of their competing allegiances. 

Ciccarelli creates an incredibly suspenseful story where one wrong move will cause Rune’s doom. The pace is perfectly timed as the buildup of Rune and Gideon’s romance is believable and heart-wrenching. Ciccarelli plays with her audience as Rune and Gideon’s burgeoning feelings give readers hope, only for it to be ripped away by lies, secrets, and brutal circumstances. This is a great first half of Ciccarelli’s duology where emotions are heightened to a fever pitch and the stakes seem insurmountable. Heartless Hunter’s characters are flawed and therefore relatable, just like their rich and deeply divided world.  

The characters’ differences lead to conflict, which also sets up unity that will be explored further in the next book, Rebel Witch. 

The novel reaches its climactic peak through a series of devastating revelations and sacrifices that fundamentally alter the story’s trajectory. The witch queen Cressida’s unexpected survival delivers a shocking twist, while Alex’s ultimate sacrifice to save Gideon casts a shadow of despair over the conclusion and simultaneously lays crucial groundwork for future installments. The story’s most painful element emerges in the final schism between Rune and Gideon, whose relationship fractures under the weight of competing loyalties and unresolved emotions. Despite sharing the fundamental desire to protect others, their divergent approaches—shaped by personal trauma and mistrust—create an irreparable rift that leaves readers with a sense of tragic inevitability rather than resolution.  

Sexual Content 

  • While in Rune’s room, she flirts with Gideon. When things get heated and they are about to kiss, Rune suddenly spills her wine. “He’s going to kiss me, she realized. And the scariest thing was, Rune wanted him to… in this moment, she wanted to know how his mouth would feel against hers… if he’d give in to that ravenous hunger, taking his fill of her.” 
  • Gideon measures Rune for a dress he’s going to make her, so Rune undresses. “Rune was already undressing. His gaze dropped to her lace bralette and remained there for a beat, before quickly shooting back to her face, his cheeks burning with color.” 
  • Gideon says he’s going to start measuring at the top and move down, but he and Rune immediately think of a sexual innuendo. “She knew what he meant, but the way he said it made her imagine him working his way down her in a… less vertical way. Apparently, she wasn’t the only one. Gideon froze, opened his mouth to clarify what he meant, and coughed instead.” 
  • Gideon is still measuring Rune, but gets distracted. “From here, he had a perfect view of the low scoop of her bralette, the delicate lace leaving little to the imagination. He had just measured her bust, so why it suddenly mattered, he wasn’t sure. He kept his gaze on the line of her throat instead.” 
  • When Gideon worked for the witch queen Cressida, he would “fulfill her [sexual] needs.” He would be “punished… for neglecting [his] duties.” 
  • Gideon thinks about when he and Cressida “traded kisses in empty palace rooms, hands wandering over each other.” 
  • Gideon tells Rune how Cressida blackmailed him into sleeping with her. “When I told Cressida we were done, that I wanted nothing more to do with her, she warned that if I refused her advances my little sister would suffer my mother’s fate.” 
  • Gideon discusses the abuse he suffered. “Sometimes, it felt like Cressida preferred Gideon unwilling. Like it brought her more pleasure to force him.” 
  • Rune and Gideon go skinny-dipping in the ocean. “She pulled in a sharp breath, her blood running a little hotter at the sight of his muscled shoulders and arms. She coiled her fingers into her palms, pressing the nails into the skin, trying to stop herself from tracing him with her eyes: the rigid lines of his collarbones, abdomen, hips.” 
  • Gideon gets fully undressed before going in the ocean, and “Rune wanted to drop her hands and look at him. Desperately…” But she does not. 
  • Rune and Gideon are swimming when she thinks, “What would it feel like to have his body flush against hers? It was perverse, the way she wanted to find out.” 
  • Rune follows her impulses and kisses Gideon, “dragging her fingers through his hair and pulling his mouth down to hers.” 
  • Gideon is not immune to her charms, as he also wants Rune. “When her teeth grazed his bottom lip, a wicked heat surged through him, and he reached for her waist. So soft. He wanted to sink into her softness. To bury himself in her.” 
  • Gideon and Rune continue to make out on land. “He moved lower, pressing his lips to a more sensitive place on her neck… Gideon moved lower still, to the base of her throat… When his teeth grazed her collarbone, Rune inhaled sharply, fisting her hands… She pushed her hands into his hair, cradling his head.” They eventually stop without going further. 
  • One of Rune’s rejected suitors insults her, saying, “If the rumors are true, she’s as loose as a whore.”  
  • After Gideon’s brush with death, Rune goes to see if he’s okay. They profess their love for each other and have sex. “He wanted her, and she clearly wanted him… The breath shuddered out of him. His hands tightened on her thighs, pulling her closer… It made the warm ache between her legs sharpen and grow… Gideon continued, moving against her. Deeper, harder, insistent.” This scene lasts for eight pages. 
  • After Gideon betrays Rune, she seeks out Alex. He asks her to marry him because he has always loved her. “When his kisses turned hungry, she leaned in, open to the possibility of him. He backed her toward the desk and lifted her onto it. When he stepped between her legs, pulling her flush against him…” They stop when Rune accepts his proposal.  

Violence 

  • The Red Peace was born after witches were massacred: “Two years had passed since these streets ran with the blood of witches and the Republic of the Red Peace was born.” This event began Rune’s quest to save persecuted witches.  
  • The government marks the foreheads of children who are “descendants of witch sympathizers.” 
  • A dangerous witch has been killing guards for months. “Three nights ago, another mutilated body had been found dragged under a bridge. Chest ripped open. Blood drained out.” 
  • Gideon is talking with his colleague about the young witches he captured and put in jail. “He could picture them huddled behind the bars of the cell he’d locked them in: wide-eyed and trembling as they clung to each other.” 
  • In order to save her life, Rune had to turn in her witch grandmother to be purged. “Blood Guard officer smashed his pistol into [her grandmother’s] face… they stripped the old woman down, found her scars, and dragged her off to be executed.” 
  • Gideon became a hero of the Republic and a highly respected officer because “[he] risked his life leading revolutionaries into the palace and single-handedly killing two witch queens.” 
  • Rune falls into a trap set by Gideon and fights to escape. She stabs Gideon. “With the weight of him gone, Rune was free to reach for the knife strapped to her thigh… Rune drew the knife from its sheath and stabbed hard, not caring where the blade went in, so long as it went in deep.” Gideon is slightly injured as he rushes to attend a ball after this fight. 
  • Rune eventually escapes but is shot at and receives a minor injury. “A third shot rang out. This time, Rune felt the sharp sting of a bullet as it sliced her forearm. Warm, sticky blood seeped out.” 
  • Gideon meets the leader of the new Republic in a boxing ring, where “Gideon was getting the shit kicked out of him nightly. Those matches always ended the same way: with Gideon hauling his bruised body from the floor of the ring, dragging himself to a table.” 
  • Gideon’s parents were designers employed by the three witch queens. The two eldest cast magic on Gideon’s mother and drove her mad. “His mother accused them of worse things, too: her husband, of being unfaithful to her; Tessa, of poisoning her; Gideon, of abusing Tessa… And always, he could smell it on her: the coppery scent of a witch’s spells.” 
  • While Gideon is telling Rune about his past, he remembers the worst of what the witch queens did. “He walked in on [Cressida] and her sisters standing over a body in a pool of blood.” It is implied that Cressida and the other queens killed this person and collected the blood for magic. 
  • Cressida cast a spell on Gideon’s little sister, Tessa, to infect her with a disease. Then she barred people from treating her. “Tessa wept and begged from the other side, delirious with fever, calling for their mother. He screamed at Cressida, who only smirked. So he lunged and pinned her down. He had his hands around her throat, prepared to stop squeezing only when she went limp beneath him, but the guards dragged him off and chained him to the floor of a cell.” 
  • Gideon explains that his parents committed suicide. “My mother drowned herself a day [after Tessa died]. My father hung himself a few days after that.” 
  • Cressida branded Gideon with her crest. “He recalled the night she branded him. She’d pinned him to the wall with a spell so he’d be helpless to stop her from searing his flesh. He remembered his body spasming beneath the glowing iron, every muscle tightening at the lightning-hot pain.” 
  • In retaliation, Gideon helped the new ruler of the Republic and “the other rebels take the palace, shooting [Cressida’s sister witch queens] in their beds.” Gideon killed those two witch queens, but he did not kill Cressida because Alex “had found and dealt with her so Gideon didn’t have to.” 
  • Rune remembers when her Nan was taken and executed. “The chains raised her grandmother skyward, by the ankles. There she dangled, upside down… One of the Blood Guard stepped forward with a knife and sliced her grandmother’s throat. The blood splattered and gushed. Nan choked, gasping for a breath she couldn’t take, her body writhing like a worm on a hook.” 
  • Verity tells Rune about her dead witch sisters, who their stepfather abused. “He would lock them up for days. Beat their bare backs with belts. Force them to kneel for hours on broken glass.” 
  • Gideon and his officers find bodies with their blood drained, and this time, it’s soldiers in his squad. “[Gideon’s] gaze descending to the Blood Guard’s neck, which was hacked open like a second gaping mouth. White bone shone in the mess of torn skin, tendons, and congealed blood. James’s spine appeared to be the only thing keeping his head attached to his body.” 
  • Alex found his brother getting beaten up every night in the boxing ring. Cressida was also abusing him. “That the young man getting beaten in the ring was Gideon. His face was so bruised and bloody, I didn’t recognize him.” 
  • Gideon asks Alex if Cressida is still alive, but Alex assures him, “I shot her three times. ” 
  • Alex tells Rune the truth about what happened when he confronted Cressida. “She woke to the barrel of my pistol pressed against her head.” Alex threatens Cressida, but ultimately spares her. 
  • Cressida sets a trap for Gideon and his guards. “But before he could grab her arm and pull her back into the room, a loud BOOM! shook the walls and floors. The red-hot force of an explosion threw him backward, slamming his body into solid brick.” Gideon is only slightly injured, and some others go to the hospital for injuries. 
  • Cressida sets a second blast at the guard headquarters. “Twenty-seven are confirmed dead and many more are injured.” 
  • Rune is captured and learns that Cressida “killed Verity and stole her identity.” 
  • In a bid to save Rune and the other witches from execution, Cressida finally reveals who she is.  She then kills a bystander to get blood for her magic. “As her victim screamed and fought, trying to get away, Cressida bared the girl’s pale throat to her knife’s crescent edge, and slit it.” 
  • Cressida shoots and kills the leader of the Republic. “Silence bled through the square as the Commander’s body tipped slowly forward, collapsing in a heap. His eyes were blank as they stared at Gideon.” Cressida then aims for Gideon, but Alex is killed instead. “When the gun went off, [Alex] stepped in front of it.” 

Drugs and Alcohol 

  • When Rune is flirting with Gideon and trying to get information, she orders some wine. “Lifting the decanter, she poured wine into both cups.” 
  • After his parents and sister died, Gideon started drinking heavily. “He’d started drinking after that. Every day. Sometimes, as soon as waking up.” Alcohol was the only thing that would numb his pain.   
  • While being abused, Gideon went to get beaten up at a boxing ring. “Like he came there every night, drunk or high, and let them beat him half to death. Like he thought he deserved it.” 
  • Alex helped Gideon as best he could. “After the revolution, it was Alex who stayed by Gideon for weeks, helping him fight off his laudanum addiction. Alex didn’t leave Gideon’s side until he no longer shook with the cravings.” 

Language 

  • Language is used rarely. Language includes fuck, shit, hell, and whore. 

Supernatural 

  • The world of Heartless Hunter involves witches who are able to cast magic spells by using their blood and the blood of others. The blood is used to write magic symbols and activate the magic. The scars made from drawing blood turn silver. “Mirage Spells are simple illusions held for short periods that require little blood. The fresher the blood, the stronger the magic, and the easier casting will be.” 
  • A witch can’t take blood without consent. “Blood must be taken with consent or given freely, as blood taken from an unwilling person will corrupt a witch and their magic… if a witch took someone’s blood against their will, the spell using that blood would corrupt the witch. She would crave the power it gave her, and resort to more coercive bloodletting, often killing her sources.” 
  • Rune casts her signature magic spell, Ghost Walker, to conceal herself. This magic is made possible through symbols written in blood. “Summoned into being by the magic in Rune’s blood and held together by the symbols drawn on her wrist, binding the spell to her.” 
  • Rune describes how she collects blood for her magic without cutting herself. “Rune had developed her blood storage system shortly after learning she was a witch… It was how Rune kept her body free of casting scars: by collecting her blood at every monthly cycle.” 
  • Witches are not magical at birth, but come into their power at a certain age. “It was the initial sign of a witch: at the onset of your first bleeding, you didn’t bleed red, but black.” 

Spiritual Content 

  • The people of this world believe in seven “Ancients.” These beings created the world and gifted magic to the people. “And each entry was named after one of the seven Ancients. Mercy, Liberty, Wisdom, Justice, Amity, Patience, Fortitude.” 

Mirage

All eighteen-year-old Amani has ever dreamed of is her coming-of-age ceremony. She loves her community and her home, even though she lives on the planet Andala’s more impoverished moon, Cadiz. Growing up, Amani’s family’s finances never worried her. She always focused on the positives: her family’s two farms, plenty of room to run wild, and her distance from the Andalan capital, Walili. Living on Cadiz, she can fully immerse herself in her favorite forbidden hobby: poetry. Ever since the Vathek Empire appeared in Andalan skies twenty years prior, the Empire’s been trying to erase their culture. The Vathek Empire only cares about important nobles and revolutionary leaders. No one worries about her family living on the edge of the world. Or at least, that’s what Amani believes. Then, Imperial soldiers appear at her coming-of-age ceremony and kidnap her.  

Trying to be brave despite her fear, Amani proves herself to be a strong and fierce protagonist with relatable flaws. She is taken to the Ziyaana, the Vathek palace in Walili, and left at the feet of the princess, whom she bears a strong resemblance to. The half-Vathek, half-Andalan princess, Maram, is on the cusp of receiving her inheritance, the Vathek Empire. However, the entire Andalan population despises Maram due to her cruelty. Therefore, Maram requires a body-double—and that is Amani.  

Imprisoned by the Empire, Amani is forced to contend with manipulative courtiers, Maram’s handsome though mysterious fiancé, Idris, and a stubborn underground rebellion that waits for her allegiance. Amani isn’t sure where to turn or whom she can trust. She doesn’t even know if she can trust Idris, for whom she is developing feelings. She only wants one thing: to go home. The longer she stays, the more danger she is in, as any wrong step would condemn her to death. However, she also realizes how much power this position gives her and that no empire can last forever, especially one as spread thin as the Vatheks.    

Amani is an independent and clever character who grows when challenged, leading by example and standing firm in her moral principles. The light romance between her and Idris doesn’t distract her from her goals. She exhibits a capacity for kindness and acceptance in both her budding love for Idris and for the family and friends she cultivates and learns to trust along the way. Overall, by following Amani’s example, the other characters grow and learn from their mistakes.  

Daud crafts powerful characters with unique personalities. Unfortunately, their development sometimes feels too rushed and is not as thoroughly explored as it could be. The Emperor, Mathis, is flat, and his daughter, Maram, goes from overly cruel and abusive to kind and sincere too quickly. While this doesn’t happen with Amani, it does detract from the overall story, which is very creative and complex in a fun way.  

The story is easy to follow, though there are occasionally words in Arabic that aren’t explained, but they’re simple to deduce from context clues. On the whole, Mirage boasts plenty of interesting political intrigue, inspiring female characters, and a wonderful science fiction atmosphere, all while incorporating elements of Middle Eastern and North African culture.  

Readers who enjoyed Children of Blood and Bone, Cinder, and Iron Widow will love the flair of the court drama, the otherworldly technology, and the fierce rebellion of a teenage girl who finds her voice in Mirage. The book is filled with people trying to find their place in the world, even when their culture, traditions, and religion are being stolen from them. Mirage tells a beautiful story with an uplifting message: true leadership potential exists in everyone, regardless of their economic background, family lineage, or personal doubts—they simply need to find the courage to advocate for themselves first. 

Sexual Content 

  • Amani and Maram’s fiancé, Idris, fall in love. Then, he discovers she is not Maram. Soon after he tricks Amani into revealing herself, they have a deep, emotional conversation and go swimming together. While in the water, “[Idris’s] hands tangled in the wet mass of [Amani’s] hair. [She] felt as though [her] whole body was waiting for his kiss. [Her] fingers tightened in his and [she] rose up on her toes to meet him. . . He drew [Amani] closer until the lines of [their] bodies were pressed against one another.” It ends after the kiss.  
  • After an argument with Maram, Idris finds Amani, and they play a game together. At the end of it, “[Idris] leaned forward and kissed [Amani].” They kiss, but they break away quickly, going to sleep individually.  
  • While visiting his family, Idris gifts Amani his parents’ old poetry book. It contains a lot of romantic poetry, including the lines, “I urge you to come on feet faster than the wind, /Come and rise over my breast and take root in me and plough me. /And no matter what befalls you while we’re entwined, / Don’t let me go until you’ve flushed me thrice.” Amani blushes from reading it and sets it down. They talk a little more, and Idris kisses her goodnight. 
  • After an assassination attempt on Amani, Idris finds her, worried about her. “[Amani’s] heart gave a painful thud as he leaned down and kissed [her]” to calm her down. He asks her to run away with him, and she declines, so he leaves.  

Violence 

  • When Amani is abducted by the Imperial droids and taken from her coming-of-age ceremony, the robots attack her friend, Khadija, and her brother, Husnain. “There was no sound as the phaser went off, only the sudden weakening of Khadjia’s grip around my hand. Her fingers slipped from mine, and her body fell forward. Her knees hit the ground, and then she fell sideways, eyes open in shock. Red bloomed on her shoulder like a flower, staining the green lines crisscrossing her arms.” As Husnain protests Amani being taken, he is “[thrown] back nearly halfway across the courtyard. He landed against the fountain with a bloodcurdling sound, then fell to the floor, unmoving.” Neither of them dies from their wounds.   
  • As Amani meets Maram, she talks back to her, angry about being taken from her family. In response, Maram “move[s] quickly, like a viper, and backhand[s] [Amani] with her ringed hand. Pain was quick and hot; it radiated over [Amani’s] cheekbone and down [her] jaw.”  
  • After the slap, Amani continues to talk back to Maram. Maram calls for her pet bird and orders it to attack Amani. “The [bird] was silent as its claws slammed and then dug in [Amani’s] shoulders. They clenched, digging into flesh and bone, before it lifted [Amani] off [her] feet and dragged [her] back several feet.” The bird releases her, and Amani is dismissed from Maram’s presence. She heals quickly from the shoulder wounds. 
  • Maram’s fiancé, Idris, is an Andalan hostage, forced to be engaged to Maram as part of a peace treaty. When Amani asks her servant, Tala, about his history, she discovers that he was forcibly taken from his family. Tala says, “There was no trial, no warning. A year passed. And then one night, Vathek forces stormed the strongholds of all the dissident families, pulled them from their beds, and shot them. Idris was allowed to live.” This is the extent of the violence described in terms of the Vathek takeover of Andala.  
  • As Amani poses as Maram in a council meeting, the emperor, Mathis, suggests that they “bomb the coastal cities” to quiet the rebellion. They just discuss it during the meeting, but they don’t take action. 
  • During Maram’s coronation as the official Imperial Heir, Amani is again posing as Maram when there is an assassination attempt against her. “One of the [guards] collapsed in front of [Amani]. [She] stared at him for a moment, uncomprehending, and watched a red stain spread across his chest.” The assassin approaches Amani, but she reveals herself as Maram’s body-double, and he pauses. The guards apprehend the assassin and handcuff him with no further violence. It is unclear if the shot member of the guard died or not.  
  • When Maram and the emperor’s steward discover that Amani knew about the assassination before it happened, they punish her by showing her a live feed of her family being attacked. “One of the [guards] moved on screen, and slammed the butt of his gun against the back of her head. [Amani’s] mother was silent, though her face contorted into a grimace.” Nobody is fatally injured. After Amani begs, the steward shuts the live feed off, leaving Amani crying on the floor.  

Drugs and Alcohol 

  • None 

Language 

  • None 

Supernatural 

  • None 

Spiritual Content 

  • The Andalans and people on Cadiz have their own monotheistic religion. They worship the god, Dihya, and the prophetess, a Jesus-like figure, Massinia. Before her secular coming-of-age ceremony, Amani thinks about how “when Dihya wanted to give you a sign He slipped a feather into your hand [from a bird]. When He wanted to command you to a calling, to take action, He sent the bird itself. It was a holy and high calling.” At the end of the novel, Amani receives one of these birds, a sign she believes to be a reminder to stay brave. 
  • Before her coming-of-age ceremony, Amani explains that “Massinia was the prophetess of our religion and though we all loved her, I loved her above all other things in our faith.” 
  • Sent in Maram’s place to visit her grandmother’s palace, Amani visits the catacombs under the building, finding a religious statue. Amani “was transfixed by the image of [Massinia] on a horse, her black robes whipping in an unseen wind.” Amani comes across similar statues of Massinia during her travels and duties as Maram’s body-double. 

The Shadow Wand

Elloren Gardner is the spitting image of her grandmother, with the power to match. She is the Black Witch, destroyer of worlds and subject of prophecies. Her friends have fled to the East. She has been married without consent to Lukas Grey, a man who loves her but has ambiguous allegiances. Furthermore, she is the weapon Gardneria has been searching for across the continent.  

Elloren’s country, Gardneria, and the rest of the continent are fully in the clutches of a fascist and theocratic government. To defeat her enemies, Elloren trains her magic and her fighting skills under their noses. At least, that was the plan. Soon after she arrives in the desert to train with the world’s greatest sorceresses, they quickly turn on her, convinced that she will bring about the devastation predicted by the prophecy of the Black Witch. In the hopes of joining her friends, Elloren returns to Gardneria and to her mysterious husband, Lukas.  

Elloren is a hopeful, fierce protagonist, dead set on saving the world—no matter what the rest of the world thinks of her. This turns out to be more complicated than expected when Lukas reveals his plans to destroy Vogel, Gardneria’s dictator. As their plans develop, Elloren meets new friends, strengthens the Resistance network, and struggles to recover from the disastrous losses of the past.  

With characters now separated, The Shadow Wand divides into multiple perspectives, though Elloren’s is by far the most dominant. Due to the influx of character perspectives and new storylines, The Shadow Wand is more complicated than the previous two books. To help readers remember all the details, the book includes far too much exposition, which slows the story’s pace. Since the beginning and conclusion are packed with vital information, readers must pay close attention to the details. The plot revolves around characters’ emotional distress, lacks action, and is boring at times. The inconsistent pacing may also annoy readers. Despite this flaw, the story has solidly developed characters, a villainous society, and a positive message. The Shadow Wand highlights the importance of friendship and perseverance even when it seems like the world is ending.   

The Shadow Wand escalates Elloren’s journey through the growing intolerance and paranoia of the magical world of Erthia. The tragedies carried over from the previous book are emphasized through Elloren’s grief, and while the novel takes a darker turn, it has hopeful messaging and ultimately delivers further emotional depth to every character. The Shadow Wand teaches readers the importance of never giving up in the face of the impossible, whether fighting external threats or mental health challenges.  

The world of Erthia will enthrall readers as it grows even more intricate in The Shadow Wand. Readers who enjoy teenagers fighting authoritarian regimes, complex magic systems, and political intrigue will love Elloren’s determination. The addition of her friends’ perspectives provides a broader picture of the intolerance on their continent and how to combat it. The Shadow Wand is about dealing with consequences, learning from mistakes, and fighting even when no one thinks you can succeed. It concludes with an unexpected cliffhanger that will have readers reaching for the fourth installment.  

Sexual Content 

  • On the Gardnerian front lines, Elloren’s ally, Thierren, recalls moments with his fiancée. He thinks about how “she’s allowed him one brief, intoxicating kiss,” and how he “can still feel those soft lips, the contours of her slim waist under his palms, her body pressed against his.” 
  • While trying to escape the island she’s trapped on, Elloren’s ally, Sparrow, runs into one of the border guards, who calls her lovely. The guard has been harassing Sparrow for the past couple of weeks. He lightly touches her face and asks her to accompany him back to his room. When she refuses, he says, “You’ve put me off long enough . . . I’ve been patient, Sparrow. More patient than any other Mage here would ever be.” She escapes before he becomes a real threat. 
  • Having just arrived in the East, Tierney meets with other Water Fae, and one of them, Fyordin, becomes territorial over her. After Tierney speaks to another kind of Fae, he asks if she is “going to take the Death Fae as [her] lover?” 
  • Elloren’s love, Yvan, thinks about his time with Elloren on a military base. “Their separation is too much [for him] to bear at times, often keeping him up tossing late into the night, his skin feverish as his fire lashes out . . . desperate to find his Wyvernfire-bounded love.” 
  • Elloren reunites with Lukas at a party, and he “kisses her deeply, the feel of [their] powers merging both startling and all-consuming.” 
  • Lukas’s father disapproves of his marriage to Elloren, and in an argument with Lukas, he requests that Lukas “seal the fasting and the breed on the girl. And quickly.” 
  • Later, when Lukas tells Elloren about the conversation with his father, Lukas says that “the minute there’s a possibility that I’ve got you with child, [my mother] will leave you alone.” Elloren replies that “no one is getting [her] with child.” Lukas agrees and says that he has Sanjire root, a form of birth control.  
  • At their wedding, Lukas and Elloren seal the marriage with a kiss. Lukas “pulls [Elloren] into his arms, and brings his lips firmly to [hers]. . . he draws [her] tight against his body.” Later, during the reception, they discover that if Lukas kisses her, he can help shield her against Vogel, so he “kisses [her] so intensely that every one of [her] affinity lines tighten and grow as molten as wildfire.” 
  • After the reception, there is a five-page sex scene where Lukas and Elloren consummate their marriage. Lukas “moves in [her], slowly at first” and she “gasps at the fullness of him.” There’s talk of moving quickly and then slowly, but there’s very little description of anatomy. 
  • When Elloren is being trained in magic, the only way she can calm her magic down is when Lukas kisses her. So, she “capture[s] his mouth, and bear[s] down, boring power into his lines in a shuddering bolt. A burn races along [her] skin and into his.” 
  • After a long day of training, Elloren and Lukas have sex again. Elloren “kiss[es] him passionately, [her] soft curves fitting against the hard lines of his body” and they “give each other everything.” They wake up together in the morning. The scene is described over a page. 
  • Before a stressful next day, Elloren kisses Lukas. He says, “If we had Sanjire root, I’d take you right here. Against that wall.” They kiss but do not have sex.

Violence 

  • In The Shadow Wand, international relations have deteriorated, and the whole continent is at war. This is primarily because Gardneria has become a fascist, authoritarian state led by an intolerant, isolationist, and xenophobic religion. This novel contains descriptions of hate crimes, sexual abuse and assault, and war crimes.  
  • Elloren’s uncle doesn’t want her mother to fight the Gardnerians. Elloren’s mother says, “They’re rounding up all the Fae, Edwin! The children too. We have to help them! . . . The Gardnerians are doing the same thing that the Kelts and the Urisk did to us. Children are being seized. Whole families. Do you know what that’s like? Watching your family, your people, herded together to be killed? The children screaming?” 
  • When Thierren is on the front lines, he witnesses Gardnerian forces burning the woods and Dryads. One of the Dryads warns them not to because “if the trees die, we die. You die. We all die.” Though Thierren tries to stop it, the forests are burned to the ground completely, and all the Dryads are executed. 
  • When Elloren is training in the desert, one of the groups who have helped Elloren hide turns on her, convinced that Elloren will try to kill them all because she’s the next Black Witch. While many of them resent her, they haven’t yet resorted to violence. One of them eventually goes rogue and attempts to kill Elloren, and the rest are forced to step in to save Elloren. So, “Quoi Zhon reaches for another star as Kam Vin slams an elbow into the woman’s arm, the silver star flashing with reflected firelight as it drops into a patch of smoldering embers. Then Kam Vin strikes the back of Quoi Zhon’s head, and the sorceress collapses facedown on the sand.” Nobody dies. 
  • Thierren, Sparrow, and Effrey are caught trying to sabotage Gardnerian forces. Thierren tries to fight “the ferocious desire to draw his wand, cut down every Mage in the room, and flee East.” He ultimately does nothing as the Gardnerian guards restrain him.  
  • While training in the East, Yvan is ambushed by Gardnerians, and he “falls to the ground, his whole body arcing against the terrible pain. . . as vine spears impale his chest.” Yvan loses consciousness, and it is implied that he has been killed.  
  • After Elloren turns herself in to the Gardnerians, her aunt Vyvian confronts her. Vyvian says, “Do you know what we do now to race traitors, Elloren Gardner? We execute them.” Vyvian threatens her niece, though she doesn’t act on any violent thoughts. 
  • At Lukas’s party, Elloren’s old bully, Fallon Bane, confronts Elloren and attacks her. Elloren then throws her “fist forward and punch[es] [Fallon] in the face as hard as [she] can.” Fallon tries to fight back, but Elloren runs.  
  • Eventually, Elloren runs into Fallon’s brother, Damion. Elloren attacks him. “[She] slams [her] whole weight against him and lunge[s] for his wand, but he anticipates [her], tightening his grip on his wand as [her] hand closes around his . . . in the blink of an eye, he sends out a spell. [Elloren] cries out as vine bindings fly from his wand and cinch tight around [her] body, the breath forced from [her] lungs.” 
  • Elloren and Damion fight until Lukas breaks them up. “Lukas pushes Damion roughly against one of the stone trees. ‘She’s mine!’ Lukas snarls before punching Damion in the face so hard that [Elloren] can hear something crack.” The fight is diffused, and everybody goes their separate ways. The entire scene spans approximately ten pages. 
  • Elloren thanks Lukas for his help. She thanks him for marrying her, saying, “If you hadn’t stepped in, Damion would have taken me back to his estate and raped me. And that would be my life. Every day.” 
  • On the way back to Lukas’s family estate, Elloren and Lukas are attacked by a sorceress assassin. Elloren’s “head jerks back as pain blossoms, [her] eyes temporarily crossed from the blow as the [the killing star] bounces off Lukas’s shield.” The sorceress soon escapes through a magical portal, and no more harm is done. 
  • When Sparrow is working at the Grey estate, she is sexually assaulted by Lukas’s brother, Silvern. He nuzzles her neck, and Sparrow tries to squirm away, desperation mounting. Silvern slams himself against her, as if for emphasis.” Mrs. Grey interrupts, and Silvern is sent away.  
  • In their escape from the Grey estate, Lukas and Elloren watch as dragons burn the estate to the ground, killing most of their wedding guests. “Soldiers scream as vivid blue flames and indigo smoke rise high into the air. . . they’re all dead, [Elloren] dazedly realize[s].” There are no dead bodies described. The scene lasts approximately four pages.  
  • While training in the desert, shadow creatures attack Elloren and her friends. “The thing’s powerful, serrated forelimb slashes down toward Lukas, who ducks and slides out of the thing’s reach.” They defeat the creature in five pages, and no one is seriously injured. 
  • As Lukas tries to give Elloren instructions with her magic, she accidentally “envelops the whole world in fire,” including setting herself on fire as “fire cuts off [her] vision and scalds through [her].” That’s the only description of her fire that’s given. She doesn’t even know she is on fire until her friends tell her afterwards. They eventually extinguish the fire, and no one is seriously injured. Elloren discovers she is immune to fire. 
  • Shadow creatures again attack Elloren and her friends. “Lukas pulls his sword, lunges at the bat, and slashes the beast in two.” As more arrive, Elloren’s friends sacrifice themselves for her. She is the only one to make it through the magical portal to the East, implying that her friends died defending the portal behind her.  

Drugs and Alcohol 

  • When Elloren enters Lukas’s military camp, she notices that two Gardnerian soldiers “slide the tip of a green bottle out of [a] bag and hastily pour its contents into the water flasks that hang from their necks.” She identifies the contents as “spirits, forbidden by the mage council.” 
  • Before they consummate their wedding, Elloren asks Lukas to “bring spirits” for the consummation of their marriage. He says, “[he’ll] bring some wine.” Later that evening, Lukas “pours a small amount of the wine into the two glasses” for himself and for Elloren. They both drink it, but not enough to be drunk. 
  • After they escape from the Grey estate and meet up with Elloren’s ally, Valasca, Lukas says, “A glass of Issani wine would be good right now.” She brings out her own flask of alcohol and shares it with the group, everybody going to sleep drunk. 

Language   

  • Language is very tame. Words like stupid, idiot, and hell appear frequently
  • The word whore is used three times. 
  • Bitch is used twice. 
  • Slut is used once.   

Supernatural 

  • This series contains all kinds of supernatural creatures. The Shadow Wand has Lupines, Fae, shadow creatures and monsters, witches, Selkies, Icarals, Kelpies, Elves, dragons, wyverns, and people with skin of all colors of the rainbow. 
  • Most of the magic appears in battle and Elloren’s training. Once, while training, Elloren describes her magic as “a savage connection to the wand.” Multiple times she has a feeling like “burning fire” and strong connections to the forest. She claims to have no control over her magic and claims that there was a time “[she] would have killed everyone [she] was with. [She] killed Ni Vin’s horse. [She] melted it.” 
  • The priest and dictator, Vogel, is described as being able to see through a “bird’s central green eye, as well.” All the shadow creatures have eyes through which Vogel can see and spy. His magic is described numerous times as “dark, evil, and demonic.”  
  • The Elf and Icaral, Wynter, can also communicate with birds, but do so in a less evil manner. She sends some of the birds “East on a hopeful search for Naga, her dragon kindred.” 
  • There are various kinds of magical travel in this novel, including portals, winged flight, and rune ships. One of the rune ships is described as having “huge, whirling flank runes and base runes,” casting “the vessel in a penumbra of sapphire light that’s reflected off the current of the Vo River.” 
  • The forests are described as sentient numerous times. After escaping into the woods from their wedding, Elloren tells Lukas that “[she’s] been bound,” her magic limited and locked up by the forest because it’s afraid of her. Elloren seems to be the only person who can communicate with the trees.

Spiritual Content 

  • The Shadow Wand is full of religious references as a theocratic and fascist government has taken power in Gardneria and is threatening war with the rest of the continent for religious reasons. This religion has strong allusions to the three main monotheistic religions: Christianity, Islam, and Judaism. Their religious structures dictate more conservative norms and different swear words than what people literally use. For example, in a speech to a large crowd, Vogel claims that “the Ancient One has brought us victory after victory over the heathen races who seek to destroy us. Who seek to pollute our lands. Enslave us. And corrupt all that is sacred. And so the Ancient One has enhanced our runic magic, calling upon us to wall out the Evil Ones with border runes and holy purpose . . . we will cleanse this land and bring the Reaping Times to all of Erthia.” 
  • Marcus Vogel has been voted the leader of the Gardnerian government. Elloren’s aunt describes him as a “young High Priest” and “the absolute picture of pious elegance.” In the same moment, Vogel gives a speech in front of the council, claiming that “power belongs in Mage hands. We are the only ones who can wield magic to do the Ancient One’s will. So we are the only ones who should control it. All of it.” He complains about other species having power when he believes they shouldn’t because their god says so. 
  • Thinking about the wedding, Elloren explains that part of Gardnerian marriage customs include the “Blessing of Dominion. . . when the couple is required, by The Book of the Ancients, to enter the wilds alone and scatter the ashes of a destroyed tree to symbolize the Magedom’s dominion over Erthia.” 
  • During the wedding, Vogel officiates and declares that “We gather in the sight of the Holy Ancient One to celebrate the joining of these two Mages. In union with each other and in union with the Holy Magedom.” 
  • In the land of the Amaz, a refugee Elf explains to an audience that the Elf coming-of-age ritual requires them to wear a magical necklace called the Zalyn’or, which brainwashes them into the Elven religion. She says, “It forces complete belief in the supremacy of [Alfsiger religion and culture]. And it suppresses all rebellious thoughts, and all physical desire too.” All Elves in The Shadow Wand wear it and are unable to remove it. 

by Kate Schuyler 

The Girl Who Fell Beneath the Sea

For generations, Mina’s homeland has faced destructive storms that have destroyed the land. In the hopes of stopping the destruction, a young woman is chosen to be the Sea God’s bride and thrown into the sea as a sacrifice to him. This year, Mina’s brother’s lover, Shim Cheong, is chosen. But before Cheong can be thrown into the ocean, Mina jumps in her place. She’s willing to sacrifice herself to protect her brother and his love, her family, and her home.

After jumping, Mina finds herself in the Spirit Realm, where a Red String of Fate binds her to the Sea God. . . who’s asleep. Worse, she encounters mysterious attackers who seek to disrupt her connection to the Sea God. They steal her soul, the very thing she needs to save her home, as it is what binds her to the Sea God. Despite being lost in a world she doesn’t understand, and facing visible and hidden foes, Mina sets out to save the Sea God, her community, and herself. It’s a race against time because she only has 30 days before she succumbs to the Spirit Realm.

Mina navigates the unfamiliar realm with the help of spirits, landing herself in the perfect place to regain her soul—and hopefully her connection to the Sea God. But in a twist of fate, she finds herself instead bound to Shin, one of the very people who severed her connection with the Sea God. Mina becomes his bride instead of the Sea God’s, once again pushing her further from her goal of saving her home. As she looks for a way back to the Sea God, adversaries—powerful spirits and even a goddess—are hunting her in an effort to gain power. And yet another opposition arises, this time from within herself, as Mina realizes that she is falling in love with Shin. Can Mina escape the clutches of those hunting her? Will she be able to reunite with the Sea God before it’s too late? And will Mina have to sacrifice what she loves to save her people?

Mina is a bright teenage girl with a strong will and a big heart, resulting in youthful passion and emotionally driven recklessness. A coward she is not. She describes herself as “stubborn,” and that’s not a bad thing, rather a manifestation of her love and fierce determination to help others and do what’s right. She’s deeply sympathetic and selfless, quick to help others at the expense of her own well-being. Mina is also not afraid to admit that she’s not perfect and that she can be wrong, which really contributes to her strength and likability as a character. Yes, she has her moments of immaturity, but her behavior makes sense given that she’s carrying a heavy burden and has just been dumped into a brand-new world.

Mina is backed by a slew of great side characters, including cheeky and clever spirits, as well as Shin and his guards, Namgi and Kirin. Namgi and Kirin are opposites of each other—Namgi is humorous while Kirin is stoic—and, as a result, they serve as two different kinds of guides to help Mina on her journey. Shin works as an excellent counterpart and love interest, as he is apathetic to the human world Mina is working so hard to protect, but he shares the values of love and duty that Mina embodies. His mysterious backstory unravels throughout the narrative, adding complications to the tale. Their love story—working like a gentle enemies-to-lovers relationship—intertwines with the characters’s progressions and the book’s lessons.

The Korean mythology on which the book is based creates the endlessly intriguing, immersive, and stunning setting of the Spirit Realm. Readers experience the world like Mina does—with a bewildered awe. The action scenes are an energetic rush that help break up some of the slower scenes, and a number of well-placed twists successfully keep readers on their toes without overwhelming them.

The narrative is full of heart, coming not just from the soft romance but also from Mina’s personality and her interactions with all the characters. There are certainly elements of the world and certain character backstories (especially Kirin’s and Namgi’s) that feel underdeveloped and warrant more expansion. Many details about the world and the characters are introduced but not followed up on, leaving readers with outstanding questions, which can be frustrating. There were also plot points and events that felt slightly repetitive, with sometimes too much back-and-forth between certain settings and characters.

Oh’s tale is an ocean of messages and lessons, addressing the relationship between people and gods, the power of belief, balancing duty to others versus individual desires, sacrifice and honor, and the importance of making decisions for oneself. Mina says early on, “I am the maker of my own destiny,” and that idea is carried through the rest of the story despite the pressures working against that very notion. The Girl Who Fell Beneath the Sea submerges readers in a charming, heart-filled tale that, despite minor flaws, shares powerful messages while delighting readers with a collection of curious characters and introducing them to the magical world of Korean mythology.

Sexual Content

  • Mina and Shin are having a heartfelt conversation that includes flickers of romance and handholding. “Shin’s breath catches. My heart begins to beat painfully in my chest. . . he slips his hand over mine, the pebble pressed between our palms, holding tight.”
  • To comfort her after a time of distress, Shin acts romantically towards Mina. “Shin lightly brushes back the wisps of hair that have escaped the tangle of my braid, clinging to my forehead and cheeks. The gentleness of his touch almost undoes the fragile walls I’ve built around my heart.”
  • Mina and Shin cuddle together in bed. “. . . He’s reaching for me, and I go to him, his arms circling around me. His breath whispers against my neck as he pulls me close.”
  • Mina sees Namgi “flirting with a boy in the crowd.”
  • Mina kisses Shin. “I lean forward, holding his shoulders for balance, and press a kiss to his lips.” Shin responds by kissing Mina back. “He takes my hand, pulling me forward until I’m in his arms, and then I’m kissing him. . . I throw my arms around his neck, returning each of his kisses with equal fervor.”
  • When Mina’s brother Joon reunites with his partner Shim Cheong, they kiss. “Joon gathers Cheong to him, kissing her soundly.”

Violence

  • One of the book’s core events is the sacrifice of a woman to the Sea God by throwing her into the ocean, where she’ll die by drowning. In a flashback, Mina and a woman preparing to be sacrificed discuss the deadly tradition. “There are even girls who truly believe all of this is real, and that they won’t drown, but will be saved by the Sea God.”
  • Shin fights off and kills intruders in a bloody fight to protect Mina. “[Shin] grabs the shoulder of the other thief, stabbing him through the stomach; [the thief] slumps to the floor.” This scene lasts two pages. Shin’s arm is wounded in the fight.
  • Mina burns her hand in a hearth. “My hand rips through the flames. A terrible sound comes from my throat, an agonized cry.”
  • Kirin cuts his hand to heal Mina’s burns with his magic blood. “With a quick motion, he makes a deep cut across his palm. Blood the color of starlight oozes from the wound.”
  • Lord Yu, the leader of Crane house (a rival house of Shin’s Lotus House), aggressively handles Mina because he wants to kill her, which, through the mechanics of the Red String of Fate, would also kill Shin. “Suddenly he lashes out, grabbing my wrist. I try to pull away but his grip is vise-like.” This results in a “great bruise” on Mina’s arm.
  • A hoard of Imugi, large, serpent-like creatures, attack Mina and the marketplace she’s in. Namgi transforms into an Imugi and battles the other Imugi, while two assassins hunt Mina, one of whom tries to strangle her. She has to fight them off with Mask and Dai, who are child spirits she befriended on her way to retrieve her soul, using daggers and firecrackers. “Arms wrap around my neck, hauling me off the ground. . . I struggle to breathe, my arms weakening, my vision blackening at the edges.” Mina kills one of the assassins and suffers minor injuries. Dai is severely injured, but lives. This scene lasts nine pages.
  • An assassin shoots Mina with a bow. “The bolt pierces my shoulder. I scream in pain. . . Blood pools beneath me.” She goes unconscious, but lives. This scene lasts two pages.
  • Another Imugi attack occurs, and Shin’s friend, Kirin, kills an Imugi to protect Mina. At the same time, Namgi fights off other Imugi. “[Kirin] unsheathes his sword and plunges the blade into the snake’s neck. . . the snake’s body begins to writhe in its death throes, spewing blood and venom.” Namgi is very injured and nearly dies but ends up recovering. This scene lasts four pages.
  • In a memory, Mina sees the Sea God get shot with an arrow and almost die. “The arrow pierces the Sea God’s chest. . . The arrowhead protrudes from his back, soaked in blood.” This scene lasts two pages.

Drugs and Alcohol

  • Namgi asks Mina for more “wine-spirits.” He is clearly drunk, as he slurs his words. A guard says Namgi is drunk.
  • Lord Yu offers Mina “wine-spirits,” which she drinks. “He lifts the bottle and pours some of the golden liquid into a cup. . . The liquor tastes bitter in my mouth.”
  • Namgi offers Mina alcohol to ease the pain from an injury. “‘What about a drink?’ Namgi suggests. ‘Liquor helps with the pain.’” Mina drinks the alcohol.

Language

  • Curse words are not used, though characters are occasionally said to be cursing. For example, Mina says, “inwardly, I curse.” She later describes, “Shin curses beneath his breath.”

Supernatural

  • This book takes place in the Korean Spirit Realm, so it is inherently magical, featuring many creatures from Korean legends.
  • The “servant” of the Sea God is “a massive, silver-blue dragon” that appears numerous times.
  • A core element of this book is the mythical “Red String of Fate,” a red ribbon tied between the hands of two people that’s only visible in the Spirit Realm. “The Red String of Fate ties a person to her destiny. Some even believe that it ties you to the one person your heart desires most.”
  • The Sea God’s city features many magical qualities. “Brightly colored fish swim along the breeze, as if the sky were an ocean. Whales like clouds float lazily overhead. And in the distance, the dragon slips through the air.”
  • When Mina’s attackers die, their bodies dissolve. “The bodies of the thieves begin to fade, smoke swirling after them. After a few minutes, all that’s left are piles of empty clothing and discarded weapons.”
  • The Imugi are first introduced when they interrupt a party. Imugi are “snakelike creatures, as large as dragons, but without horns or limbs. They blend with the sky in colors of deep red, indigo, and black” and can switch between humanoid and snake form.
  • Mina meets a “fox demon” who appears as “a white fox” with a “tail split in two.” Fox demons, according to legend, are “evil spirits that prey solely upon men.” This fox demon possesses a priestess to speak through her.
  • Kirin is a creature referred to as “the Silver One.” He has magic blood with the ability to heal wounds, and he can turn into a “four-legged beast with two horns and a mane of white fire. It has the shape, body, and legs of a deer, but the height and strength of a horse.” In this form, he can walk on water.
  • The “River of Souls” is a river filled with human souls rushing from the mortal plane to the Spirit Realm or the afterlife.
  • The Goddess of Moon and Memory rides on “what looks like a horse but with hooves of fire.”

Spiritual Content

  • Gods are a central part of the plot, worldbuilding, and even the book’s themes. They are mentioned frequently and appear numerous times.
  • The book revolves around the Sea God, the god of the seas and ruler of the Spirit Realm and all other gods. He ravages the human world every year with destructive storms because he is consumed by anger. When Mina first meets him, she discovers him “slumped over the throne, his face shadowed by a magnificent crown. . . dressed in beautiful blue robes, stitched silver dragons climbing up the fabric.”
  • Mina describes the existence and functionality of the gods. “The world is filled with small gods, for each part of nature has a guardian to watch over and protect it.”
  • Mina’s soul is taken out of her body and turned into a magpie. Namgi explains, “When Shin severed the Red String of Fate, it took your soul.”
  • Shin discusses the functionality of souls. “Every being has a soul, whether it’s hidden inside you, as it is for humans, or in a different form, as it is for beasts of myth. Gods also have souls” which are the things they are gods of.
  • Mina meets the Goddess of Women and Children and asks for another’s wish to be granted. A dying pregnant woman asks for her child to be saved. The Goddess cruelly declines, stating, “This girl is dead. Her child is dead,” and then she “flings the paper boat into the fire.” The paper boat is a physical manifestation of the dream.
  • The Goddess of Moon and Memory appears multiple times. “A bolt of lightning flashes and silhouettes her against the darkness. She’s the most awe-inspiring being I’ve ever seen, terrible and terrifying at once.”
  • One of Mina’s spirit friends, Dai, discusses the afterlife, including heaven. Dai says, “Beyond this world, there are others. One of those other worlds is heaven.”
  • Mina and Shin encounter Shiki, “the death god.” Shin describes him as “One of the more powerful gods.”

By Sarah Leberknight

Bloodmarked

All Bree wanted was to uncover the truth behind her mother’s death. So she infiltrated the Legendborn Order, a secret society descended from King Arthur’s knights — only to discover her own ancestral power. Now a medium, her ancestors’ voices sit in the back of her head along with the new arrival of Arthur’s presence, who is fighting to take over her body.  

Nick, the boy Bree loves, is missing. Both Bree and Selwyn, the mage sworn to protect Nick, want to search for Nick. But the arrival of the Regents, the group in charge of the Legendborn, makes their departure difficult. The Regents aim to contain and control Bree and eliminate the potential threat posed by Selwyn. After a daring escape from the Regents, Bree, Selwyn, and their friends begin their mission to find Nick. However, to find Nick, they will have to face the Shadowborn, demons drawn to Bree’s power, and the Mageguard, Merlins employed by the Regents.   

Bree struggles to understand and use her power. She needs to be a leader, but to do that, she may have to let go of Nick and save herself. She battles the expectations of the white supremacist Legendborn society against the expectations of her ancestors, all while grappling with the knowledge that her power exists because her ancestor was raped. After the Regents kidnap her, she desperately wants to find independence, but she is unable to abandon her friends, even for her own safety. While her friends advise her to save herself, she occasionally takes advantage of her role and orders them to obey her and do as she wants, but readers still find themselves rooting for her and her clear vision of justice.  

Bree continues to rely on her friends, making Bree and Selwyn’s relationship deepen, as does Nick and Bree’s romance. Nick and Bree are drawn together in their longing for each other and in Bree’s bloodwalks, where they are able to visit each other in Bree’s mind. Alice is also much more developed as a character; her friendship with Bree again provides a touchstone of stability amid the chaos of Bree’s life. Readers will enjoy the return of familiar characters and the arrival of interesting new ones. Almost everyone who meets Bree is won over by her selflessness and kindness, even in the face of threats to her life, and they return her loyalty in kind.  

Bloodmarked takes a deeper look at what it means for Bree to inherit power as a Black girl. Stunned by how much each of her friends cares for her, she strives to be worthy of their sacrifice. Bree also deals with relatable conflicts such as questioning authority, building confidence, and figuring out her identity. While much of the conflict is interpersonal, there are still moments of action and violence that sustain the fast-paced narrative. The novel concludes with a twist that will lead readers directly to Oathbound, the next book in the series.   

Sexual Content 

  • While Nick and Bree are separated for most of the novel, they are still in love, and the few times they do see each other, they hug and kiss. “Nick’s lips crash against mine, warm and fierce . . . What one of us wants, the other gives with lips, tongue, heat.” 
  • Nick and Bree are making out, but then are interrupted, as Bree is pulled out of the vision that allows them to visit each other. “Power cycling from his body to mine in a slow loop between his skin and mine . . . He moans, tugging us to the ground.” 
  • There is tension between Sel and Bree, as they both are attracted to each other, and they flirt with each other. Sel says, “I would say you look . . . devourable.” 
  • Sel has been creating an illusion of himself to trick Bree. She thinks that he was doing it to make her attracted to him, but he was really trying to disguise how unhealthy he looked. “What I thought felt like falling into him, maybe even for him, had been me, falling into Sel’s illusion.” 
  • Sel and Bree kiss. “Before he can respond, I pull his head down and press my mouth to his indignant scowl until it turns soft and warm . . . his palm wraps around the nape of my neck, turning the kiss fierce, his mouth open and hot. He pulls me in by the hip, closer, a pulse building between us, a shared demand.” 

Violence 

  • While practicing summoning her magic, Bree’s powers manifest in flames that burn her skin.  “The fine hair on my forearms singes; there’s a charred smell in my nose . . . The magic bites into my skin, the burns going deeper.” 
  • Bree is fighting intruders. She attacks with, “A right hook to their ribs. They pivot away before it lands—too fast—grasp my forearm, use my momentum, pull me off balance. I stumble into them, nearly slipping off the branch. They hold my wrist tight.” The fight is interrupted before anyone is seriously injured. 
  • Bree is pulled into Arthur’s memories, which are often scenes of war. “A battlefield soaked in red. My tunic and leathers, shining with it . . . We are always arguing, even here with our comrades screaming on the ground around us, bleeding— 
  • When a boy tries to restrain Bree, she accidentally breaks his hand. “This time I do use Arthur’s strength to break his grip . . . I hear a pop. A bone broken.”  
  • Demons attack the car Bree is in. The car crashes, and “a deep thwunk as the car hits something. . . I end up pressed against the seat looking at the sky through the front window . . . The car tilts again. I go tumbling . . . I hit the floor shoulder-first. Pain shoots across my chest.” 
  • Someone in Arthur’s bloodline raped Bree’s ancestor. Bree and other characters make references to the rape throughout the book. Bree says, “I am Arthur’s heir not by choice or honor, but by violence . . . I am the Scion of Arthur by rape.” 
  • William, one of Bree’s friends, tortures a demon after she attacks it. “When bones crack beneath the skin, they make a deep, wet popping sound. That sickening crunch echoes around us in the yard until there are no more bones to break. . . William’s forefinger and thumb have just . . . twisted her elbow joint completely apart. Her limb is still held together by flesh. But now it’s in two pieces.” They release her after she answers their questions, but Selwyn kills her as she’s running away. 
  • Max kills Nick’s father, Lord Davis, because he betrayed the Legendborn Order. “And the spear pierces Lord Davis’s chest straight through with a wet, loud thunk.”  
  • In retaliation, Nick beheads the attacker. “Nick’s crossed blades meet his opponent’s throat, then part — cleaving Max’s head from his body.” 
  • A demon attacks Bree. “My right ribs and side are opened in stripes. Muscle, glistening wet. A steady stream of red flowing down into the dirt.” She is seriously injured.  
  • Bree attacks the Mageguard after they threaten her and her friends. Bree shoves the Mageguard and hears “a deep snapping sound, mixed with wet. A bone breaking as he lands.” The Mageguard is unconscious for the rest of the fight.  
  • In an attack, Bree accidentally hurts Alice. Bree “pull[s] the attacker [Alice] up and over by their arm, throwing them into the broadside of the van with a heavy thunk.” 

Drugs and Alcohol 

  • The Regents kidnap Bree and keep her drugged to contain her powers. “I blink slowly and register the odd feeling in my chest . . . I feel hollowed out . . . It doesn’t occur to me until the end of the second day of confinement without the return of my abilities that the serum is probably in the food.” 
  • Bree, Sel, William, and Alice go to a bar where they are served drinks, but they don’t drink them. “[The waitress] looks down at Sel mischievously, then over her shoulder, before lifting a final, double shot glass.” 

Language   

  • Profanity is used regularly. Profanity includes damn, shit, hell, fuck, and asshole. 
  • Racist language is used toward Bree. One emissary of the Regents tells Bree that she should change her hair, “perhaps smooth things down for a cleaner look.” No racial slurs are used.  

Supernatural 

  • As a result of her Rootcraft and Bloodcraft, Bree has magic that is borrowed from her ancestors. She is the Scion of Arthur. Because she is a medium, she can communicate with Arthur, and she has his strength. Her root manifests in flames. She struggles to control both elements of her power.  
  • Bree explains her power. “Mediums can’t control the dead. Even if I could contact Arthur at will, I can’t—and won’t—rely on possession to wield his power.”  
  • Sel and the Mageguard are Merlins—humans with demon ancestry—who have heightened senses, strength, and speed. They can manipulate aether, and mesmer people, erasing their memories or creating illusions.  
  • Merlins are always fighting against succumbing to demonia, a loss of their human side. “If our latent demonic natures overcome us, we lose empathy, sympathy, kindness…Eventually, all that remains are the core hungers of demonia: the inescapable desires to create and consume human misery.” 
  • There are other Scions, descendants of the knights of the Round Table, who possess the powers they inherited from their ancestors.  
  • Bree performs bloodwalks, during which she communed with Arthur and her other ancestors. In these instances, when she touches Lancelot, she can summon Nick, as his descendant, and communicate with him. “I reach toward Lancelot—something Arthur did not do—and Lancelot does not react . . . My fingertips touch Lancelot’s shoulder. . . Lancelot flashes bright—and becomes Nick once more.” 
  • Bree and her friends go to a bar owned by a crossroads demon, who makes deals with humans to give them temporary magic powers.  
  • Bree and her friends visit a community of Rootcrafters, where Bree performs a ceremony to communicate with her ancestors. “Think of this place and ceremony like an amplifier for the ancestral stream. Volition and the communion circle will boost your call so you can talk to all of them at once”.   

Spiritual Content 

  • None 

Diana and the Island of No Return

Twelve-year-old Diana has always wanted to be a warrior. She has spent her childhood growing up on the magical island of Themyscira among Amazons—powerful, female warriors—where men are forbidden. Now that she’s twelve, Diana is convinced it’s time for her to start training to be a warrior, but her mother, the Queen of the Amazons, refuses to let her. Diana is a natural with weapons and footwork and she sees no danger in training.  

But Diana knows her mother is hiding something, which frustrates her to no end. So, when the annual Chará festival comes to Themyscira, bringing boatloads of fearsome women from around the world, Diana watches them train and socialize with envy. Diana’s best friend, Sakina, helps distract her. When Diana goes looking for Sakina’s missing pet, she hears someone in need. Venturing all the way down to the waterfront, Diana sees something she’s never seen before—a boy, named Augustus, bruised, battered, and starving.  

Diana is a fierce, intelligent, and curious protagonist. When she finds Augustus, she approaches the situation rationally and, though she doesn’t trust him, she wisely gives him the benefit of the doubt.  Diana promises to return with food and to hear his story. Back at the palace, she discovers all the festival-goers in magic-induced comas. Panicked, she returns to the boats and finds Sakina interrogating Augustus. Together, the girls use Diana’s Lasso of Truth to compel the boy to tell them about what happened to their families. Augustus explains that a demon has hypnotized everyone on his island and blackmailed potion-expert Augustus to fetch Princess Diana for the demon. Without any other options, the girls take pity on Augustus and swear to save his family, and their own, regardless of the danger. They courageously leave Themyscira on a flying chariot to confront a demon all by themselves.  

The novel features fantastic and inspiring young heroes who drive the story and develop beautifully as characters. However, the demon is a flat and generic villain who lacks a backstory. The novel gives very little description of the demon, which makes him seem weak and diminishes Diana’s triumph. The rest of the story is well-constructed, using simple language and an easy plot that will keep the average reader entertained. The settings of Themyscira and Sáz (Augustus’s home island) are magically and wonderfully described. In addition, the Amazons serve as a great example of women empowering each other, and the community in Sáz is kind and tight-knit. Regardless of the book’s flaws, it’s a sweet and creative read.  

Readers will love the strong warriors, independent young protagonists, and intricate mythology and magic of Diana and the Island of No Return. Diana and her friends encounter all kinds of challenges and traps, from pits of spiders to flying chariots to hypnotized prisoners, which makes for inspiring entertainment. Diana is a sweet and spirited character who grows when challenged, leads by example and stands by her own moral principles. Overall, Diana and the Island of No Return is a beautiful story with moments of magical wonder, unwavering self-confidence, and lovely, budding friendship.  

Sexual Content 

  • None 

Violence 

  • While all the guests of Themyscira, Diana’s home island, party at the palace, Diana wanders down to the waterfront, where she discovers a boy—which is strange since boys are forbidden on Themyscira. He is visibly bruised and injured. It takes some time to get the answers, but he eventually confesses that a demon had blackmailed him to kidnap Diana. “‘I’m sorry,’ the boy said. His eyes brimmed with tears. ‘I tried to refuse. First I pretended I’d done it and made a fake potion; but when he tested it out and saw that it didn’t work, he beat me.’ The boy waved at his bruises. ‘When he threatened to kill my father then and there, I buckled.’”  
  • As Diana, Sakina, and Augustus confront the demon, their plan to capture the demon fails, and Diana attacks him unsuccessfully. “Diana glanced about for something—anything—to throw at [the demon] and noticed a boulder, loosened from the fence. Gripping it, she heaved it up and hurled it at the demon. The rock flew through the air, whizzing toward him—and passed straight through the demon’s torso and out the other side, landing with a sharp crack on the street beyond the bonfire.”  
  • When Diana’s attack on the demon fails, the demon reacts, and “one arm clamped around Diana’s neck and she was lifted into the air by her throat. Diana coughed and wheezed, her breathing growing strained. The hold pressed tighter against her windpipe. Stars began to dance in and out of Diana’s vision. She scrambled against the grip, her nails scratching into flesh.” She breaks free and makes it out largely unscathed. 
  • After regrouping and coming up with another plan, Diana and her friends confront the demon. While Diana distracts him, he is violent. “In a split second, the demon darted forward. He grabbed Diana’s wrist. Sparks of pain shot up Diana’s arm.” Diana gets free, and they get rid of the demon, so no further harm is done. The whole confrontation scene is only about five pages. 

Drugs and Alcohol 

  • During Themyscira’s annual festival, Diana returns to the palace to find all the partygoers asleep. “The first thing Diana noticed once she stepped inside the guest hall was the scent filling the room: bittersweet, like the rind of an orange. She clasped a hand to her nose; her eyes watered.” Diana discovers that everyone had been drugged. Diana and her friends find the antidote and eventually wake everyone. 

Language 

  • None 

Supernatural 

  • While not a superhero yet, Diana has special abilities and grows up surrounded by magical happenings on a magically hidden island. This book has many references to magic on almost every page. An example of Diana’s abilities appears when she breaks free of the handcuffs the demon put on her. “The reality of what she’d done settled in on her. It should have been impossible to break out of those cuffs. And yet—she’d done it.” 
  • Diana also carries a family heirloom called the Lasso of Truth. She uses it multiple times against suspicious people. Diana says, “[The Lasso of Truth] shines a light on the truth. And you can’t break free of it. May as well stop trying.” Once ensnared by the Lasso, whoever Diana captures is compelled to tell the truth to any question posed to them.  
  • Diana’s friend, Sakina, also possesses special abilities that she frequently utilizes. Diana describes Sakina as “a Scholar, but [Sakina] also had a special ability to speak with animals.” Sakina has multiple pets that she converses with daily, and she often uses their help to set traps for the demon.  
  • Diana meets a new friend, Augustus, who comes from an island that makes magical, flying chariots. When Diana first meets him, he explains, “I brought a chariot with me. Uh, snuck it in the hull so no one would discover it. Thought I’d visit my family while I was here.” Diana asks, “It can fly all on its own?” Augustus responds, “with a certain potion, yes.” Augustus often uses magical potions to solve their problems, like protecting Diana and Sakina with force fields and defeating the demon. 
  • The demon also has several magical abilities that he uses for nefarious purposes. He hypnotizes Augustus’s loved ones to make Augustus do the demon’s bidding. “It’s hard to see them like that,” Augustus says, “They’re good people. There’s a ninety-nine-point nine percent probability that not one of those people hunting for us would hurt so much as a fly. But now they have clubs. And their eyes. . . It’s scary to see them so blank. Like the lights are off and no one is home.” 

Spiritual Content 

  • Diana is the child of an Amazonian warrior. Therefore, she often references the Greek gods and Greek mythology. An example of this happens when she describes the palace of Themyscira, which has “columns with marble statues of the goddesses Athena, Artemis, and Hera [gazing] down on the Amazon warriors [who are training].” They do not interact with any gods in this novel.  

by Kate Schuyler 

Within These Wicked Walls: A Novel

Andromeda is a free spirit, and she won’t let anyone get in her way. She is a debtera, an exorcist hired to cleanse sites and people of the Evil Eye. Trained from a young age by one of the most prominent and dysfunctional debteras in the country, Andromeda is good at her job. The only problem is that she’s not officially licensed, and after a falling out with her mentor, Jember, her only hope of steady work is to find a Patron—a rich, well-connected individual who will vouch for her abilities. 

Out of desperation, she takes on the one job even Jember is afraid of: working at the Manor of Magnus Rochester. Knowing no one in their right mind would hire an unlicensed debtera, Andromeda refuses to be afraid and faces the Manifestation of the Evil Eye with determination—because if Magnus hired her, and formidable exorcists like Jember are terrified of his curse, Magnus must be even more desperate than she is.   

Andromeda is a fierce but stubborn protagonist, committed to doing the right thing and keeping her promises even when facing great peril. When she arrives at the Manor, the servants already look down on her, but she keeps her head held high and proves that she is smarter than they think. Yet the Manifestation is far more complicated than any she’s seen before, and it doesn’t help that the young heir who hired her, Magnus, is too attractive for his own good. Fighting her growing attraction to Magnus and her new, budding friendship with one of the quieter servants, Saba, she discovers that both are hiding many secrets. As the curse grows more deadly, Andromeda’s new friends, her new love, and her old mentor all urge her to give up and leave the Manor, but her morals are too strong. Even when she finds out that Saba is dead but reanimated and haunting the house, she is still determined to save them all or die trying.  

Within These Wicked Walls is a retelling of Jane Eyre, made palatable for teenagers. However, it loses some of the original intricacy and depth of its inspiration. The romance between Magnus and Andromeda comes on a little too quickly to be natural, and their romance is too soft and kind to be related to that of Jane Eyre. Nevertheless, Magnus and Andromeda are sweet together and have occasional swoony scenes. That said, Within These Wicked Walls does do an acceptable job of adapting the overall story with new natural laws, a new tone, and into a new country with different customs.  

While the book’s magic is intriguing and contributes to the horror and gothic themes, it may be confusing for those unfamiliar with magic or supernatural elements inspired by Ethiopian folklore, such as amulets and spells. To add to the confusion, the story lacks the necessary backstory regarding Magnus and his family, as well as the overall setting. Regardless of complicated supernatural details, the novel is still an easy read with a relatively simple plot, managing to build an excitingly suspenseful and scary tone throughout.  

Readers who enjoyed These Violent Delights, Pride and Premeditation, and House of Salt and Sorrows will love the magical curses, vicious gothic tone, and Andromeda’s fierce independence, not to mention the growing romance between Andromeda and Magnus. All of this makes the book worth reading, regardless of the flaws. Andromeda’s focus and her pride teach about perseverance when no one believes in you and trusting yourself and your instincts, no matter what danger lies ahead.  

Sexual Content 

  • After the house throws a book at Andromeda, she finds sketches of women inside the book. She confronts Magnus about a specific sketch. Andromeda believes that the sketch shows him kissing his friend, Kelela. “What about that scandalous one of you two kissing?” Andromeda asks. “Does [Kelela] know about that one?”  
  • During that same conversation, Magnus explains that it’s a picture of him and Andromeda. Moved, she lays her “hand against his still-red cheeks and [kisses] him . . . His soft lips press hard against [hers] at first, as if he lost his footing.” 
  • After Magnus saves Andromeda from the hostile ghost of the Librarian, he reassures her that he likes her and kisses her. The “kiss wasn’t like the last one. It was certain and sweet. . . it felt like a promise.” 
  • While Magnus holds a dinner party with friends, Andromeda discovers that he’s betrothed to Kelela. Feeling betrayed, she confronts him and he “kisses [her]. [She bucks] anyway, shoving hard against his chest, trying to pry his hand from the back of [her] neck, to turn [her] face away from his. But when a verbal protest finally [makes] it to [her] lips it [doesn’t] sound like a protest at all.” 
  • After an emotional conversation with Kelela about Magnus, Andromeda talks to him. To reassure Andromeda of his feelings yet again, he kisses her. “‘My darling,’ he [coos], running his fingertips across [Andromeda’s] lips, ‘it’s always been only you.’ And he press[es] his lips where his fingers [have] warmed.” 
  • As Andromeda spies on her mentor, Jember, and Magnus’s mother, Saba, Saba climbs “onto the table, crawling over and closing the gap between [Jember and her] as she kiss[es] him.” Saba and Jember have a history, but the kiss is as far as it goes. 
  • After getting rid of the Evil Manifestation on Magnus’s house, to celebrate, Andromeda shifts “to [her] knee to lean up, kissing [Magnus’s] lips. His hand skims [her] jaw, the pure love in his touch pushing away the remainder of [her] sadness and regret.” 

Violence 

  • When Andromeda first tries to exorcise the house of the Manifestations, she is attacked by an invisible force. “But whatever had tripped [her] was still there, and [she] kicked at it, yelping as it grabbed [her] foot. [She] stumbled to [her] feet, looking around in the dark. The Something grabbed [her] more firmly this time, and [she] quickly stomped to get it off and rushed to [her] room. But as soon as [she] shoved the door open it grabbed [her] again, this time wrapping around [her] ankle to hold [her] still. It felt familiar and terrifying, and when [she] looked down the moonlight flooding from the window in [her] room revealed a hand coming from the ground, long fingers curling around [her].” She makes it out unscathed, and the invisible force vanishes. The whole scene is about two pages. 
  • When Andromeda visits Jember, she remembers his past disciplining techniques when raising her. “[Jember] gripped his maqomiya, the long prayer staff grinding into the floor like it was trying to drill through it, and [Andromeda] couldn’t fight the wince [her] body had long been conditioned to perform at the sight of it. [She] backed away a few steps, even though [her] mind rationalized that Jember hadn’t disciplined [her] in years, and never within the walls of the church.” 
  • Andromeda is attacked by the Librarian, a ghost in the library. “Two books slammed [Andromeda] in the hip and arm, as if trying to make [her] drop the table, but [she] grimaced and raced it over to the small space [she]’d found.” The Librarian throws books at her until Magnus rescues her 
  • While being controlled by the Evil Eye, the servant, Saba, attacks Andromeda, and Andromeda must fight her off. Andromeda “snatched Saba’s forearm with one hand, digging [her] fingers in and reaching for [her] knife with the other just as [she] kicked [Saba] in the shin. Saba stumbled back a few steps, and [Andromeda] heard the shinkt of a breaking plate, a sharp, warm pain rising up [her] fingers that the rest of the cold house might’ve numbed.” Andromeda makes it out of the event largely unscathed, though Saba loses an arm. The scene is described over a chapter. 
  • Andromeda and her friends attempt to rid the house of the Evil Eye Manifestation using Kelela as bait. Kelela is attacked by a hyena, and Andromeda “pulled [her] knife, dodging out of the way as the hyena backed out of [her] bedroom door, snapping its jaws and clawing at the fireplace poker Kelela was swinging at it . . . [Andromeda] stabbed the hyena in the back so it would turn on [her].” Kelela is wounded, but everyone else makes it out okay.  
  • After a particularly emotional day, Andromeda tries to leave the house, but Saba physically restrains her. “So [Andromeda] screamed, wordlessly, trying to aim the sound at [Saba’s] ear, and kicked. She had no hair to pull, no flesh to dig [her] nails into, but [Andromeda] managed to get knife from pocket and stab [Saba] in the back. [Andromeda] felt the break of pottery, [her] knife easily piercing through. [Andromeda] cocked back [her] knife to stab again, but [her] body went backward instead as Saba dropped [her] onto [her] back in the sand. . . This time when [Saba] picked [Andromeda] up she held [her] out at arm’s length, facing away from [Saba].” Neither is gravely injured at the end. 
  • When Andromeda asks Jember for advice on defeating the Manifestation, he explains that many debtera have suffered in trying to do so. “Only four debtera in history have survived their encounters with a hyena. All of them suffered nerve damage from their injuries. None of them could bear to touch another living person again. Three of them killed themselves before old age could.” 
  • During the final battle between Andromeda and the evil magic infesting the house, Andromeda and her friends are attacked multiple times. “Jember screamed again just as [Andromeda] finished [a thread for the amulet to defeat the Manifestation], and his body moved to let in more light. It was only a second, a breath. But [she] saw the hyena’s green eyes glint at [her], even as its jaws were sunk securely into Jember’s side. It threw Jember across the room, and [Andromeda] leaped up and ran to the desk, climbing on top of it, watching it the entire time. [She] saw blood drip from its mouth. Saw it charge at [Andromeda].” Jember dies of his injuries. Andromeda and Magnus survive unharmed. The scene is described over a chapter. 

Drugs and Alcohol 

  • When getting hired at the Manor, the servants ask what it’s like to train under someone as talented as her mentor, Jember. She thinks to herself, “Why would you want to spend any amount of time with that heartless addict?” She does not elaborate. 
  • When Magnus and Andromeda have their first dinner together, “Magnus took a bottle of wine out from under the table and uncorked it, pouring it far higher than one serving.” They do not become intoxicated. 
  • Before Andromeda goes to visit Jember at the church, she stops by a market and buys wine, taste-testing it first. “For a moment [Andromeda] just marveled at the honey wine before indulging in a gulp. Sweet, then bitter, a little spiced, burning. It made [her] a little light-headed. Last time [she]’d lived with Jember was the last time [she]’d had any. . . it tasted like home. And at that thought, the wine turned to poison in [her] mouth.” She puts the bottle into her bag and leaves for the church without drinking more.  
  • When she returns to the Manor, Magnus takes the bottle from her without asking her what it is and drinks some. “‘It’s honey wine,’ [Andromeda] said, taking the bottle from him and cradling it close. He coughed, then dry heaved like a cat with a hairball. [She] rolled [her] eyes. ‘That’s what you get for not asking before taking a sip.’” 
  • Returning to ask Jember for advice, Andromeda wanders into his bedroom. She describes it: “glass bottles and jars littered the bed, and there was a paper bag of pills on the side table that were most definitely illegal.” There is no description of him taking the pills or an indication that he is using them.  
  • Before their confrontation with the Manifestation, Andromeda asks Jember to tell her the story of how he found her, an orphan, on the streets. He starts the story by saying, “I was on my way to drink myself to death . . . ” Andromeda stops him, asking him to restart without the admission of depressed and suicidal ideation. 

Language 

  • Words like damn, stupid, and hell appear frequently. 
  • Occasionally, “dick” is used as an insult  

Supernatural 

  • Within These Wicked Walls follows Andromeda in her work as a debtera, someone who rids sites of dark magic and supernatural spirits. She describes her job as “[leading] the worship services with hymns and chants, as well as [performing] all the duties of the priests, without benefiting from being ordained or esteemed. We were healers. Artisans. Trained to attune ourselves to the spirit world deeper than anyone else would dare to.” Due to this, there is magic and supernatural content described or unfolding on almost every page. Andromeda makes contact with spirits, called Manifestations, multiple times, and they even occasionally cause violence/death or permanent damage.  
  • Andromeda wears a magical amulet to protect herself from the Evil Eye. She “hid [her] amulet under [her] dress again, adjusting the collar so the metal chain wouldn’t show. It was a survival habit Jember had taught [her] to live by since the age of five: Protect your amulet better than it protects you.”  
  • The amulet is introduced in Chapter 1. Andromeda describes it as follows: “the Evil Eye was the first Manifestation of sin—namely jealousy and greed. In a constant state of longing, it latches on to any human who desires the same thing it does. Thriving crops, a random string of good luck, even receiving too many compliments could draw unwanted attention.” 
  • Andromeda finds evidence of evil spirits in supernatural signs, such as “random items falling off walls in one room. Strange ripples on the floor, like drops of water, in the next. A room that just seemed unnaturally covered in soot.” 
  • During one of the nights Andromeda stays at the Manor, Andromeda and Magnus are attacked by the house and Magnus almost drowns in blood. Andromeda “gaped at the bedroom, at what seemed to be blood filling the room from the floor up, like the swiftly rising tide of a river. Magnus was still in his bed, fast asleep. [She] slipped in through the crack [she]’d managed, the shifting of the liquid shutting the door behind [her]. . . [She] waded across the room through the quickly rising blood, the shield of [her] amulet pushing the blood away from [her] body.” She saves him, and they are both unscathed. This is another example of Manifestations.  
  • While at the Manor, Andromeda makes friends with a mute servant, Saba. She eventually comes to discover that Saba is Magnus’s mother, dead and reanimated to seem alive by the Manifestation. During a Manifestation, the Evil Eye takes control of Saba and uses her to attack Andromeda. Since she’s dead, she does so supernaturally. An example of this is when Saba’s arm falls off during the attack. Andromeda “looked quickly up to Saba, as she stood still, her right arm missing and hollow at the forearm, making her look like a beautiful, sad porcelain doll.” 

Spiritual Content 

  • Andromeda and her mentor, Jember, are debteras. This means that they exorcise Evil Manifestations of magic from buildings or sites. Exorcisms are typically used in Christianity to remove demons or holy spirits and send them back to Hell. In this book, the word “exorcise” is often used, but it refers to ghosts and dark magic rather than demons.  
  • Kelela believes Andromeda is an uneducated working woman. Andromeda tells her, “I actually read a few languages. One of the benefits of being raised in a church.” There is no detail about the church in this chapter, and Andromeda is not very outwardly religious. 
  • Andromeda goes to visit Jember at the church. “There were a handful of people standing in prayer in the direction of the altar, where Jember sat on the stairs constructing an amulet .  . . finally, the prayer was finished, and each worshipper made the sign of the cross on themselves, touching forehead to chest, shoulder to shoulder.”  
  • Before their final confrontation of the Manifestation, Andromeda asks Jember to help her calm down. Andromeda asks, “Can we pray together?” He responds with “God hasn’t heard me for quite some time.” They do not pray together, and the conversation evolves into other topics.  

Baker’s Magic

After running away from her abusive foster family, the protagonist, Bee (short for Beatrix), finds herself in Zeewal, a small village in the struggling kingdom of Aradyn. After failing to steal baked goods, Bee quickly earns an apprenticeship with the town’s baker, Master Bouts. Bee learns all there is to know about baking, and she soon discovers that she has the magical ability to infuse her treats with her emotions, causing customers to experience her happiness, pain, and annoyance. Her skills lead Master Bouts’ bakery to be summoned to deliver pastries to Master Joris, the kingdom’s head mage and de facto ruler. This allows Bee to begin an unlikely friendship with the orphaned Princess Anika, Joris’ ward, who will soon inherit the kingdom of Aradyn.  

However, when Bee learns of Joris’ plot to marry Anika off to a neighboring kingdom and steal her throne, Bee devises a plan with her friend, Willem (Wil), to take Anika away from Joris. Wil, Anika, and Bee go on a journey to find the Island of the Mages, hoping that the mages’ council can protect Anika and put a stop to Joris’ reign. On their adventure, they encounter the Tulip Pirates of the ship the Egbertina-Henriette, thieves who steal the lucrative tulips that Joris grows in Aradyn. With help from the pirates, a wizard named Bartholomew, and a few tree spirits, Bee and her friends learn just how harmful Master Joris has been to Aradyn. This causes Bee to grow ever more determined to rid the kingdom of the mage once and for all. 

Bee is an inquisitive and caring protagonist whose self-assurance and sense of identity grow throughout the book. She begins as an orphan with a lonely and miserable past, but through her own determination and kindness, she unites her past and present and finds a true family. Despite being only twelve years old, Bee displays a strong moral compass that propels her to do everything she can to help her friends and her kingdom. Bee’s friendship with Wil quickly develops into a strong connection, marked by laughter and selflessness. Their loyalty to each other contributes to the heartwarming atmosphere of the novel. 

Princess Anika is sheltered and naive about the outside world, but she never displays the haughtiness expected of her. The unlikely friendship that the three of them form exemplifies the book’s message that our differences are less than our similarities, and heroes can come from anywhere. Another central idea of Baker’s Magic is the importance of trees. Joris uses his magic to banish all of Aradyn’s tree life before the book begins, and this results in flooding and food shortages. The characters gradually learn the importance of trees, educating audiences along the way. 

Come along for Bee’s exciting adventure across land and sea. Each stage of the journey brings new twists and turns, from the humorous Council of Mages to the lonely floating islands. Audiences seeking minimal interpersonal conflict will appreciate the good-natured characters. The central antagonist, Master Joris, is the source of every problem and the only irredeemable figure, so his defeat solves every conflict. This results in a clean, yet simple narrative that is best suited for younger readers. The stakes are high, but the book is ultimately low-stress.  

Lighthearted, comedic characters like the Tulip Pirates serve to counteract the looming threat of Master Joris, and there are helpful figures around every corner that aid the central trio on their journey. However, Bee’s history of abuse may be disturbing for some readers, and the young protagonists are often in life-or-death situations. The back of the novel contains a recipe for the most popular baked good in the story, the “Bouts Bun,” which adds a unique participatory aspect to the book. Overall, Baker’s Magic is an uplifting and entertaining read that puts a fantastical spin on the world of baking. Readers can take another magical adventure by reading The Very Nearly Honorable League of Pirates Series by Caroline Carlson and The Grimmelings by Rachael King. 

Sexual Content 

  • There is no explicit sexual content or mentions of sex, but there are minor references to romance and attraction. For example, Wil, the loyal son of the Zeewal blacksmith, kisses “Anika’s limp hand” before going into battle alongside the pirates. 
  • Princess Anika kisses Captain Zay, a pirate and the leader of the ship called the Egbertina-Henriette (Egg Hen), on the cheek. 
  • Anika and Wil form a relationship by the end of the novel – “the princess, in love with the blacksmith’s son!” 

Violence 

  • After attempting to steal from Master Bouts’ bakery, Bee is tripped and falls to the ground. “She landed on the hard stones with a bone-jarring thump.” Bouts grabs her “in a painfully tight grip.” 
  • Long before the story begins, Bee’s mother drowned in a shipwreck that nearly killed Bee as well. 
  • After opening the closet in the palace kitchen, Bee’s shoulder is injured by a falling broom handle. “A broom handle popped out, smacking her hard on the shoulder.” 
  • The kingdom of Aradyn is threatened by large storms that destroy houses and drown civilians. Past storms have given Master Bouts a fear of floods and drowning. 
  • Wil is apprenticing as a blacksmith, so he has many burn scars. “He held out his hands, and Bee noticed, for the first time, the scars on nearly every finger, the back of his hands, his wrists.” 
  • Bee confides in Anika about her former foster family. “The master shouted and threw things. And the mistress beat me.” 
  • Master Bouts attempts to save a burning omelet but forgets “to use a cloth,” resulting in his hand burning. 
  • To escape an arranged marriage, Anika runs away from Master Joris, the conniving head mage of Aradyn. He sends magic after them, but they escape unharmed. This tense escape scene lasts two and a half pages. 
  • Master Joris uses his magic to send rocks after Bee, Anika, and Wil as they try to escape him on a boat. “Then, all at once, splashes surrounded them, and something crashed against Bee’s temple, so hard that the night sky spun before her eyes.” Bee’s injury causes her to bleed from her head, and Wil is bruised. 
  • Bee nearly drowns when her boat sinks, but pirates save her. “Something grabbed her by her cropped hair and yanked, pulling upward. Oh, it hurt!” Wil and Anika are also saved from drowning. 
  • The pirates go into battle with a Zeewal merchant ship to steal their supply of tulips. Bee and Anika watch as a merchant’s sword nearly slices Wil. “The blades flashed as Wil bent backward over the rail, his sword raised against the oncoming steel that threatened to slice down onto his neck.” Captain Zay saves Wil by cutting the sailor, and the blood makes Wil vomit. No lives are lost in the battle, and the scene lasts for two and a half pages. 
  • Bartholomew, a hedge wizard and Bee’s long-lost father, uses magic to turn the entire tree island clockwise. He loses control of it, and Bee is nearly tossed off the island by the centrifugal force. The spinning only ceases when Bartholomew is thrown from his feet due to the force of the spinning. 
  • Bee, Wil, and Bartholomew are attacked by Joris’ taxidermy collection. A fox, a mole, a rabbit, and a mouse attack first, and Bee is bitten by the mouse. Birds then peck at them from above, and the next wave is a horde of flying, stinging, and crawling bugs. This scene lasts for three pages. 
  • When Bee is trapped in one of Joris’ snow globes, Bartholomew sends rocks to break the glass of her prison. “The glass showered down over Bee, and she rolled into a ball to try to protect herself from the bombardment of shards and stone. One ricocheting rock hit her in the ribs, and she gasped with the pain of it.” 
  • Master Bouts is being kept in the palace prison when Joris’ magic causes it to flood, and Bee momentarily thinks that he has drowned. Anika also almost drowns, but Captain Zay saves her. 
  • Pepin, Anika’s pet hedgehog, bites Joris’ leg to prevent him from escaping Bee, Anika, and the pirates. “Master Joris let out a shout and tried to shake Pepin off, but he hung on, his sharp teeth embedded in the mage’s calf.” 
  • Joris is ultimately defeated by anthropomorphic trees that return to Aradyn from exile. The trees use their roots to grab him and take him underground. “The mage let out a shriek of terror and tried to kick and twist free. But the roots held him tight as he struggled. Slowly they pulled him downward into the mire.”

Drugs and Alcohol 

  • Alcohol is mentioned sparsely throughout the book. For example, Master Bouts and Wil mention a cooper whose wine “tasted better than the palace’s own vintage.” 
  • Master Bouts smokes a pipe, but tobacco is never mentioned by name. 
  • Wil’s father, Master Weatherwax, drinks a “tumbler of ale” after dinner. 
  • On the pirate ship, Bee bakes cookies with “sugar, flour, and rum.” She later uses beer to make the Bouts Buns’ dough rise on the ship. 
  • Captain Zay puts rum in her and Bartholomew’s coffee, but she refuses to give any to Bee, Wil, or Anika due to them being underage. 

Language   

  • Bee and Wil often call each other names, either jokingly or out of anger. When Wil calls her baking “off,” Bee angrily responds, “It’s you who’s off!” 
  • Wil angrily shouts to Bee and Bouts, “The cursed door’s locked!” 
  • When Joris figures out that Bee is hiding in the castle, he demands, “Come out of there this minute, you sorry wench.” 
  • The pirate Limmo tells his crewmates, “It ain’t suppertime yet, you feckless oafs.” 
  • The pirate Haleem mentions a parrot that “used to curse a blue streak.” 
  • One of the members of the Council of Mages calls their fellow mage an idiot. 
  • The pirate Filmon says that, when Captain Zay was under Bee’s truth spell, “She told us we were rogues and rapscallions and should go to the devil. . .” 

Supernatural 

  • Hedge wizards and witches are regular people who “have some magic.” With practice, they can increase their skills and become mages. 
  • Bee has the power to infuse her baked goods with her emotions, causing her customers to feel her feelings. As Master Bouts puts it, “I think your pastries make people feel the way you do.” She inherited this magic from her father, a hedge wizard. 
  • Master Joris is “the mage of all Aradyn,” a powerful magic-user who can control every aspect of the environment but has no sway over water. Each kingdom has a head mage appointed by the Council of Mages. 
  • Joris creates sparks when he walks. “Bee noticed, to her astonishment, that as his heels struck the ground, small sparks flew upward.” Joris can also create elaborate firework displays. 
  • While staying on the island of the Council of Mages, Bee, Wil, and Anika are able to ask for what they want, and it magically appears. Bee loudly yells for water, and a tiny storm cloud appears to rain into a water basin. 
  • The “moss maidens” are spirits connected to trees. When Joris banished Aradyn’s trees to a floating island, the moss maidens were trapped with them. The maidens can communicate with their trees, and with Bee’s guidance, they use tree roots to paddle their island prison toward Zeewal. These trees later grab hold of Joris and imprison him underground. 
  • After being called a murderer by Bartholomew, Joris stamps his foot in rage and creates a large crack in the earth. “The crack in the ground became a cleft and then a crevice, and it widened with every passing second.” 

 Spiritual Content 

  • None

by Gabrielle Barke 

The Iron Flower

Elloren Gardner knows the truth about her world, and there’s no going back. Elloren and her friends were only trying to do the right thing when they rescued a Selkie and freed a military dragon. The last thing they expected was to be thrust into a realm-wide underground resistance against Gardnerian conquest. After just a few months at Verpax University, she’s abandoned her Aunt Vyvian’s more conservative and discriminatory values for the Resistance and is more dedicated than ever to protecting her friends. However, to do so, she is forced to pretend that she’s the same pious, ignorant girl she was at orientation.  

As war looms over the continent of Erthia, Elloren is trying to secure safe passage to the east for her friends. But more Gardnerian soldiers descend on the University, led by none other than Lukas Grey. To complicate things, Elloren is stuck in her own little love triangle, between a Commander who is not all he seems and the mysterious Yvan Guriel, who contains more power and allure than anyone she’s ever known. As his magic calls to her, Elloren finds it more and more difficult to believe she’s truly powerless. However, the last thing Elloren and her friends expected was to be thrust into a realm-wide underground resistance against Gardnerian conquest. 

Outspoken and authentic, Elloren is an inspiring character who studies medicine to help others. She also flaunts University traditions as well as negotiates with queens and renegades. In The Iron Flower, Elloren has found her family, and her relationship with each member becomes increasingly complex. They bond during emotional and traumatic times, but their home soon begins to fall apart with every raid, riot, and murder. Elloren is a force of nature and a lovable character who defies everything she’s ever known for what she knows is right. Her narration is simple and clear, even with all the moving parts, the average reader can’t help but root for her.   

The Iron Flower picks up where The Black Witch leaves off, with Elloren joining the Resistance and Marcus Vogel being elected and cementing power as Gardneria’s High Mage and leader of their government and military. The story includes new and old characters, as well as multiple plot lines, which can make the novel overwhelming and confusing at times. While a lot happens outside of university grounds, Elloren’s own story moves slowly at the beginning, peppered with exposition dumps and emotional turmoil. However, everything speeds up about halfway in and the conclusion is packed with twists and bloody endings. This book successfully builds a believable trajectory of the Gardnerian government’s descent into authoritarianism, while also teaching about standing up to bullies and knowing when to pick your battles.   

Readers who enjoy political intrigue, magical battles, and teenage drama will love The Black Witch Series. The Iron Flower adeptly continues Elloren’s journey through the magical world with powerfully moving tragedies and victories of the Resistance. Elloren and her friends are brave, complex characters who highlight the themes of acceptance, love, friendship, and kindness. The Iron Flower is about hoping for the best, even when nothing seems like it will work out, and it concludes with an exciting cliffhanger that will have readers eager to read the next book in the series, The Shadow Wand 

Sexual Content 

  • Waiting for a Resistance meeting to start, Elloren sees “Iris [tilt] her head and [kiss] Yvan’s neck, nuzzling against him with a soft moan.” Yvan shuts it down before it goes further. 
  • Lukas and Elloren reunite after months of no contact. Lukas “leans in to kiss [Elloren], [she] lets [her] lips soften, like sugar melting against his heat.” 
  • While at a ball, Elloren talks to one of her friends, Jarod, who is a werewolf with the ability to scent emotions and arousal. He points out two men standing at the fringes of the dancing. Jarod says, “Those two men, they’re madly in love with each other. I can feel it from all the way over here.” 
  • When Elloren’s brother, Rafe, and his girlfriend, Diana, sneak into the dance, “he kisses [Diana] deeply” in front of the whole room.  
  • As Elloren dances with Lukas, she feels “a sudden, overwhelming desire to be dancing with [Yvan] instead. To feel his lips against [hers]. To have his arms around [her]. And to be close to his fire.” 
  • Andras, the child of Amazonian warrior women, describes their fertility rites. The woman who chose him “felt that [his] seed would produce especially fine, strong daughters.” 
  • While reviewing Resistance plans with two professors, Elloren remembers that “Diana told [her] about [them]—that they’ve one of the strongest attractions to each other that Diana has ever sensed in any couple.” 
  • Lukas announces his desire to marry Elloren, and then he kisses her. “Light as gossamer, he kisses the base of [her] neck, his lips rousing [her] fire lines with a heated longing that tingles straight through [her].” 
  • Mid-conversation with one of her friends, Elloren thinks about their marriage rituals, how “the consummation of the sealing union is expected [the] same night, prompting the fastlines to flow down a couple’s wrists as proof of consummation.” 
  • After freeing a Selkie from a prostitution ring, Elloren’s friend, Gareth, describes the inside of the brothels. He explains, “They were clothed, though barely. They had them standing in a row for the men to look at. Like livestock at a fair. Most of them seemed scared. A few of them, especially the younger ones, looked completely traumatized.” 
  • Elloren’s roommate, Ariel, plans to sacrifice herself so that another roommate, Wynter, can go free. Ariel confesses that she loves Wynter “not as a sister. [She] love[s] [her].”   
  • After a succession of traumatizing events, Elloren seeks comfort in Yvan. They have a tender conversation and then “he brings his lips to [hers]. His lips are warm and full and salty from his tears, his kiss tentative as a surprising warmth blooms from where his mouth touches [hers], his heat sliding through [her] affinity lines in a tingling rush.” 
  • At the end of the novel, there is a big plot twist that leaves Elloren and Yvan reeling from new information. “He kisses [her] again, his lips growing heated, his fire building and then flashing though [her] lines with a feverish urgency that makes [her] shudder against him.” 

Violence 

  • During their first Resistance meeting, Yvan warns the room about a new brutal practice. Elloren’s friend from work, Bleddyn, describes it as “cutting off the points of [Urisk] ears, like [they’re] animals. And shearing the hair from [their] heads.” The Urisk people are commonly enslaved in this novel, though the Resistance is working to free them. 
  • While waiting near a military camp for Lukas, Elloren “remember[s] the stories Yvan told [her] about how Gardnerian soldiers set their dragons on the Kelts during the Realm War. How the soldiers wiped out entire villages and burned them to the ground.” Descriptions of war and vague, past violence appear frequently in the book. 
  • During the holiday ball, Elloren sees her friend Aislinn, who’s unwillingly betrothed to an abuser, Randall. Randall “roughly grabs Aislinn’s free arm and yanks her toward himself.” In the process, Aislinn “makes a hurt sound and instinctively recoils.” One of Aislinn’s friends growls and threatens Randall, but ultimately, Aislinn leaves with Randall, and no blows come to pass. 
  • As Elloren discusses Rafe’s unwillingness to join the army, someone says that if Rafe doesn’t cooperate, “He’ll be shot.”  
  • With the fascist government gaining power, Elloren’s friend, Tierney, worries about her aquatic-creature friends. She says to Yvan and Elloren, “[the government has] pounded iron pikes into the waterways. Five of [her] Kelpies are now dead.” 
  • On a walk into town with Elloren’s friend, Tierney, Elloren spots graffiti on a wall that says in all caps, “reap the evil ones/Erthia for Gardnerians/take back the western realm.” Once they reach town, they notice a hate crime has been committed and non-Gardnerians have been attacked. They find Bleddyn “only semiconscious, her unswollen eye unfocused.” When she wakes to see Elloren, she “jerks her whole body violently away, her expression twisting into a desperate snarl.” They take Bleddyn home to heal her. Along the way, they find another friend, Olilly, whose ears had been partially but brutally cut off.  
  • After finding a Selkie in the woods in The Black Witch, Elloren and her friends are trying to free the rest of them in The Iron Flower. Frustrated at their lack of progress, Elloren yells at Yvan, “They’re beating the Selkies. Raping them!” 
  • Since Elloren and her friends can’t free the Selkies on their own, they ask the Amaz for help. During their visit, the Amaz are conflicted over housing Elloren and they almost come to blows over it. Their Amaz appointed bodyguard, Valasca, “pulls out a knife, leveling it at Alcippe,” another Amaz who opposes Elloren’s presence there. There’s a good deal of yelling and physical threatening before everyone backs down.  
  • To explain Alcippe’s hatred of men, Elloren’s Amaz bodyguard explains: “When Alcippe was twelve, she returned from tending livestock and found her mother unconscious on the floor. Blood was streaming out of her mother’s nose and ear, and her eyes were swollen shut.” Alcippe murdered her father for his abuse of her mother. 
  • Trying to find the valuables of the Selkies, Gareth infiltrates the brothels where they were housed. To describe where they keep the valuables, he says that “All the Selkie taverns have the same [storage] system—apparently, they streamlined things after one Selkie [freed herself] and murdered several people.” 
  • On a dark day, a werewolf shows up at Elloren’s footstep with news that all of the werewolves have been slaughtered, save him and her two friends at university. He cries, “I went out to hunt . . . and when I returned . . . I. . . I found them. . . all of them. . . dead. . . our homes turned to blackened ash.” In response to hearing her family was dead from Elloren, one of the last remaining werewolves, Diana throws herself off a building, but she survives.  
  • To distract the guard and smuggle her friends to another country, Elloren poisons the university’s students and the guard. The poison isn’t lethal, but it renders everyone unconscious for almost two days. 
  • During her escape, Diana gets revenge for the murder of her family. When the guard wakes, they find that “fifteen Gardnerian soldiers are dead. The University groundskeeper is dead, viciously decapitated. The ears pulled clear off a group of Third Division Gardnerian military apprentices.” 
  • When the government declares that all Icarals must be imprisoned, Elloren’s bully, Fallon Bane, and her brother watch as “a male Icaral [is] hauled up for execution, two soldiers grasping its arms, the creature’s wing-stumps flapping in panic.” There is no explicit description of his death, but it is implied. 
  • At the end of the novel, Elloren’s aunt discovers how rebellious she has become. Aunt Vyvian reveals that Elloren’s uncle is sick, and it is implied that Vyvian is responsible. As Elloren sobs next to him, Uncle Edwin “slumps back, his head lolling, his eyes gazing over,” and he dies. Vyvian’s guards “jump to [Elloren’s] side, roughly pushing [her] back and restraining [her].” Her aunt forces her to marry Lukas, but he lets her go when the process is over. 

Drugs and Alcohol 

  • Elloren’s roommate, Ariel, is addicted to an opiate-like drug called nilantyr. When the Gardnerian military raids her room, they seize her stash. There is no description of the raid, only her withdrawal symptoms. Within an hour, Ariel is “starting to tremble,” which soon “worsens to full-body quaking.” Ariel then “vomits all over the clothing she’s pulled from [Elloren’s] drawers.”  
  • While visiting the Amaz, Valasca “pulls a flat flask out of her tunic pocket, unstoppers it and hands it to [Elloren].” At Elloren’s hesitance to take it, Valasca says, “Oh, I forgot. You Garndnerians don’t drink spirits.’” Eventually, Elloren gives in and they both drink. Elloren goes to bed drunk. 
  • During a visit to the capital city’s prison, Elloren and Yvan notice that the Icaral inmates are being drugged. They see a little girl in a cell with her “white tunic stained down the front with black vomit,” as a “woman appears to be trying to force-feed nilantyr to the child.”  
  • When Elloren and Yvan find Ariel in one of the cells, Elloren describes her “gaze [as] unfocused, her mouth curled up at the edges into a numb, blissful grin.” As they try to escape with Ariel, Yvan makes a surgeon and an apothecary eat the nilantyr on their way out, to knock them out and not alert the guards.  

Language   

  • Language is very tame, but includes words like stupid, idiot, and hell that appear frequently. 
  • The word whore is used three times. 
  • Bitch is used twice. 

Supernatural 

  • This book features a diverse array of supernatural creatures, including witches, kelpies, Icarals, fairies, elves, werewolves, other animal shifters, Selkies, dragons, green- and purple-skinned peoples, and Amazonian women who utilize rune magic in battle.  
  • The Iron Flower has spells, runes, and mentions of magic on nearly every page. Elloren often has dream-like visions of the future that she can never quite remember; things like “a battlefield beneath a reddened sky” or “a white wand gripped in [her] hand.”  
  • Their magic is defined by their “affinity lines,” which are how they describe their affinity for certain kinds of elemental magic. One of Elloren’s professors tells her “just because [she] can’t access [her] power doesn’t mean her affinity lines are weak,” meaning that Elloren may have more of an affinity for magic than she thinks. 
  • The Amaz are protected by runes, another form of magical spells, where the wielder doesn’t need strong affinity lines. Elloren describes part of the Amaz settlement as “farms set under geometric glass domes marked with huge scarlet runes.” 
  • Potions and magical medicines are made in this book. As an example, on a walk into town, Elloren watches as a “disheveled-looking apothecary is busy pulverizing a dragon’s talon into black powder.” Elloren and Tierney gather their alchemy materials from him.  

Spiritual Content 

  • During a Resistance meeting, Elloren is informed that “the mandatory wandfasting age for Gardnerians has been lowered to sixteen.” Those over the age of sixteen “will be forced into a fasting” by their religious government.  
  • On a walk into town, Elloren spots graffiti on a wall and describes it as “a phrase from [their] holy book. /Bring the reaping times.” 
  • Elloren says Gardnerians hate forests because “it’s part of our religion. We’re meant to subdue the wilds. They’re supposedly filled with the spirit of the Evil Ones.” 
  • On family weekend at Verpax, the werewolf pack visits and Aislinn’s family “pointedly make[s] the holy gesture to ward off the stain of the Evil Ones.”  
  • Elloren explains why Gardnerians have arranged marriages. She says, “Mating is considered sinful in our religion. Its sole purpose is to bring forth as many mages as possible. Mating for any reason beyond that is considered immoral. We’re supposed to rise above our base natures. Not be wild things.” 
  • A man and his Amaz mother discuss the werewolves. His mother says that the werewolves are “everything the Goddess despises. And after they die, it will be as if they never existed, whereas [you and I] will go to Goddesshaven.’” 
  • Around a campfire, Elloren’s brother, Trystan, remarks that their friends are “all Evil Ones” and that “according to the glorious and most holy Book of the Ancients, [they’re] all Evil Ones. Except, maybe, for [Elloren].” 
  • In a political speech to a large crowd, the fascist leader in power claims that the Gardnerians will “flush [the Evil Ones] out of our cities. [They] will flush them out of the wilds. [They] will flush them out of this realm and the next. [They] will flush them out with the full power of the Ancient One behind [them].” 
  • While visiting the Amaz, Elloren notices a painting that depicts “the three First Women walking in a beautiful garden with the Great Goddess; the slaying of the cruel male partner by the only faithful daughter; the Goddess rewarding this faithful daughter, naming her Amaz.” 

A Fairy Finds Her Song

Every fairy has a gift that makes their wings grow—but Lily, a young fairy, is having trouble discovering hers. She watches her fairy friends Jasmine, who has super strength, and Sky, who can fly to extraordinary heights, excel in their talents. With the help of Jasmine and Sky, and her human friend, Willow, will Lily be able to discover what makes her special? 

Lily’s human friend, Willow, plays a pivotal role in Lily’s breakthrough. One day, Lily finds a lost bird and sings a song to communicate with it. Her song helps the little bird reunite with its mother. After witnessing this, Willow suggests that Lily’s songs may be her gift. Feeling encouraged, Lily sings songs and forms connections with frogs, bees, and butterflies. As Lily sings, her wings start to grow. 

Though she struggles, Lily never loses hope that she is destined for something great. Lily thinks, “My gift is hard to find. It must be extra special.” Her fairy friends encourage her to attempt new things, such as trying to see objects clearly in the dark, until she finds something that clicks. Lily’s determination will inspire young readers to stay curious and never give up on their own journeys to self-discovery. 

Young readers will be enchanted by the vibrant, magical illustrations that will transport them into Lily’s whimsical world. The artwork mirrors Lily’s growth throughout the story. Initially, she appears small in comparison to her fairy friends and certain animals. By the end, Lily soars high with her large, glowing wings as her three friends cheer her on. These drawings will help young readers identify Lily’s growth—both in her wing size and her character. 

Alongside these detailed illustrations, each page contains one to four short, simple sentences. The book opens with the lines “I am Lily. I am a fairy.” Beginning the story with these two sentences will help readers immediately identify and connect with the main character. Each page has one to two sentences that include sight words. The concise language makes this story accessible to young children who are beginning to read independently. 

While the simple plot is easy to follow, Bea Jackson weaves a meaningful message about individuality into the narrative. Through Lily’s journey and friendships, young readers will learn that everyone has different strengths and talents, and that with practice and perseverance, they can discover their own. A Fairy Finds Her Song is a joyful celebration of the unique gifts that we carry—and how using these gifts to help others can make the world even more magical. 

Sexual Content 

  • None 

Violence 

  • None

Drugs and Alcohol 

  • None 

Language   

  • None 

Supernatural 

  • None

Spiritual Content 

  • None 

by Madeline Hettrick 

Wrath of the Triple Goddess

Percy Jackson has fought monsters, titans, and gods. But now he faces his greatest challenge yet: college admissions. In order to attend New Rome University, Percy needs to earn three recommendation letters from Greek gods. After earning his first letter by finding the cupbearer Ganymede’s missing chalice, Percy was enjoying living a quest-free life. But as the son of Poseidon, Percy rarely gets a break from being a hero. When Hecate, the goddess of magic and crossroads, promises to write a recommendation letter for Percy in exchange for a week of pet sitting, he can’t refuse.  

With the help of his girlfriend Annabeth, and his best friend Grover, Percy hopes that looking after Hecate’s hellhound and polecat will be a piece of cake. But Hecate’s mysterious mansion is filled with temptations, and her mischief-minded pets are eager to cause trouble. When Grover’s appetite gets the better of him and he drinks one of Hecate’s potions, chaos is unleashed. And so are Hecate’s pets. As Grover tears through the house in a potion-induced frenzy, Hecuba the hellhound and Gale the polecat escape to romp around New York City.   

Percy, Annabeth, and Grover must find Hecate’s missing pets and repair her mansion before she gets home, or they will face the goddess’s wrath.  

Percy Jackson is a witty, strong, and heroic character. As the narrator, he guides the reader through the story in a way that is engaging and humorous. Throughout the novel, Percy proves himself to be a compassionate and capable leader. He learns from his mistakes and uses the knowledge that he has gained from previous experiences to ensure that he keeps his friends safe. He also maintains a positive outlook, despite the challenging circumstances. 

Percy is joined by Annabeth and Grover, who are both strong and inspirational characters. Annabeth, the daughter of Athena, is a fierce warrior and strategist. She often uses her wisdom and intelligence to think her way out of situations, and she uses her skills to protect her friends. Grover is a selfless satyr with a big heart. He is in tune with nature and his emotions, using these skills to advocate for the natural world.   

While Wrath of the Triple Goddess is the seventeenth book in the Percy Jackson universe, it is still understandable and enjoyable for readers who are unfamiliar with Rick Riordan’s previous works. The main details are summarized for new readers, and the plot is straightforward. Readers also do not need to be familiar with Greek mythology to enjoy this book. Longtime fans will appreciate reading about the adventures of familiar characters and will enjoy many references and callbacks to the previous books.  This novel contains Rick Riordan’s recognizable style and humor but differs from Riordan’s previous works since the conflict is less high-stakes, and the overall tone is more whimsical.    

This story contains themes of friendship, perseverance, and compassion. Throughout the novel, Percy and his friends succeed because of the faith they place in each other. They are stronger as a team and work together to solve their problems. The trio also faces many different challenges, but they are determined to keep on fighting. They don’t give up on each other or their goals. Ultimately, the characters are compassionate and forgive one another for the mistakes they make. Rather than blaming Grover for the pets going missing, Annabeth and Percy reassure him that it wasn’t his fault and work with him to find a solution. Wrath of the Triple Goddess is a light-hearted and entertaining addition to the world of Percy Jackson.  

Sexual Content   

  • Before parting ways, Percy and Annabeth kiss goodbye outside Annabeth’s school. “She gave me a big wet kiss.”  
  • Percy and Annabeth kiss after eating an antidote, which helped them recover from a magical gas that gave them animal features. “I kissed Annabeth, though my breath probably smelled like cinnamon and bug shells.”  

Violence   

  • Percy discovers a hellhound puppy with a wound on its back. Percy suspects the puppy was attacked by some type of monster. “His black fur was matted with gunk. Flies buzzed around his cherry-red eyes. His ears were back, and he trembled with fear. A nasty-looking cut zigzagged across his back, like he’d been attacked by something with claws.” The puppy recovers.  
  • Zombies attack Percy, Annabeth, and Grover. Percy “cut down the first reanimated corpse, then sliced another two undead into dust. Meanwhile, Annabeth launched herself at another dead guy, driving her dagger into his face, while Grover goat-kicked one right through the windshield of a parked Toyota.” The trio defeats the zombies. 
  • A bear-monster attacks Percy, Annabeth, and Grover. Percy “got to the bear before she could claw Annabeth and [he] slashed with [his sword]—cutting clean through [the monster’s] right paw. The paw went flying.” The bear-monster recovers.  

Drugs and Alcohol   

  • Percy and Annabeth drink nectar to regain their strength. “Percy gulped it down. A surge of warmth washed through [his] organs. [He] recognized the sensation. It was nectar—the drink of the gods.” 

Language    

  • Percy learns that he will be picked up from school by a family member, rather than taking the subway by himself. When he learns this, he thinks “it made me look like a doofus. . .” 
  • Animals called “hellhounds” are referred to frequently. 
  • Characters rarely say expressions such as “Oh, gods.” 
  • Percy jokingly calls his friend Leo a doofus twice.  

Supernatural   

  • Hecate is referred to as the “goddess of ghosts. 
  • Percy thinks he sees a ghost while walking towards a park. Percy “thought [he] saw a glowing blue apparition—the figure of a child on a bicycle, pedaling away from us in terror. When [Percy] blinked, it was gone.”  
  • Percy communicates telepathically with three eels in Hecate’s mansion. The eels lie to Percy to try to get him to feed them extra fish. “The eels were telling me all about it telepathically. Their thoughts chiseled their way into my skull like ice picks.” Percy occasionally communicates with the eels throughout the novel.  
  • Grover drinks a potion from Hecate’s laboratory that turns him into a giant goat. Percy discovers him sleeping on the floor in Hecate’s ruined mansion. “And in the middle of all this chaos was a mountain of hairy flesh, snoring with gusto, its two massive shaggy legs propped against the kitchen island, its moose-size hooves pointing towards the ceiling.” Grover recovers and goes back to normal after letting out a large belch.  
  • During a battle against zombies, a zombie touches Percy, and he has a vision of the Siege of Troy. “When I looked up, I was no longer in Queens. I knelt on a barren, battle-scarred hillside. To my right, the city of Troy was burning.” Percy wakes up from this vision and continues fighting.    
  • Grover goes into a trancelike state and summons a large number of squirrels. “Then the squirrels began to arrive. Three scrambled down the nearest tree trunk and hopped onto Grover’s back. Another raced out of the bushes and leaped onto his shoulder. Two more tunneled through the leaves and skittered up Grover’s legs. Within a minute, there were dozens, maybe hundreds.” Grover speaks with the squirrels, and they help him find Hecate’s missing pet polecat. After communicating with Grover, the squirrels leave, and Grover recovers. 
  • Percy shadow-travels with Hecuba, the pet hellhound. Shadow-travelling is a type of teleportation that hellhounds are capable of. Percy “was pulled off [his] feet. A dark portal whirled at the edge of the roof, and as Hecuba jumped through it [he was] sucked into the shadow-world.” Percy and Hecuba shadow-travel across the world for seven pages and stop when they get back to Hecate’s mansion.  
  • Percy is sprayed in the face with a potion that paralyzes him. “The [potion] got in my nostrils, my eyes, my mouth. . . Then my mouth stopped working. My arms turned into sandbags. My legs crumpled. I crashed sideways to the floor, completely paralyzed.” Percy recovers after being revived by Grover.  
  • A magical gas hits Annabeth, Percy, and Grover, which transforms them. Annabeth’s head turns into an owl’s, Percy’s arms turn into octopus tentacles, and Grover’s goat legs turn into human legs. “Where [Annabeth’s] face had been a second before, two huge black eyes stared out over a hooked golden beak. Her head had turned into a heart-shaped expanse of white plumage, rimmed with speckled brown feathers. From the neck up, [Annabeth] was a barn owl. . . Where my arms used to be were eight thick purple tentacles lined with pink suction cups. . . [Grover] was staring down at his legs and weeping. Where his furry goat hindquarters had been, there was bare skin, forward-articulating knees, and instead of hooves. . . feet.” They all return to their normal selves after eating a magical antidote.  
  • Percy makes a magical antidote to return himself and his friends to normal after the magical gas transformed them. “Annabeth tore into the second [antidote] with her sharp, hooked bill. . . She doubled over, breathing heavily. When she straightened again, she was normal Annabeth – human face, human hair, with the scent of her usual apple shampoo.” The antidote is effective, and they return to normal.  
  • Percy, Annabeth, and Grover summon ghosts in a graveyard to help them repair Hecate’s mansion. “The dark silhouette deepened, peeling itself from the bricks and taking on a smoky form like a cloud of coal dust.” They take the ghosts to the mansion, and once it is repaired, they release the ghosts.   

Spiritual Content   

  • This novel is centered around Greek mythology and contains frequent depictions of and references to Ancient Greek gods. 

by Kelly Barker 

Powerless

Decades ago, a plague swept across the kingdom of Illya, separating the survivors into two categories. The Elites gained supernatural abilities that allowed them to seize control of the government. Then there were the Ordinaries, who lack abilities and are systematically killed off by the Elites to maintain power.  

Paedyn Gray, an Ordinary thief living in the city slums, fakes psychic powers using her natural observational skills to survive. When she saves Prince Kai from an attack, she is invited to compete in the Purging Trials, a yearly contest celebrating the Elites’ deadly powers. While competing, rebels recruit her for an uprising and, for the first time, Paedyn must not only survive but also find a cause worth fighting for.  

Paedyn is an underdog, fighting for an important cause with the odds stacked against her. Despite her determination to survive and uplift her people, Paedyn never loses her humanity. She assists others, such as by helping a friend find employment, and frequently expresses remorse over her past lies and deceit. However, while readers may sympathize with Paedyn’s struggles, her lack of competence can be frustrating at times. Paedyn rarely uses intelligence or creativity to problem-solve; more often, she is saved from difficult situations by other characters or sheer luck.  

The main victim of Paedyn’s duplicity is Kitt, the crown prince. Kitt is a kind-hearted and sheltered person, offering a much-needed break from the world’s brutality and conflict. He is a foil to his moodier and flirtatious younger brother, Kai. Kai is the king’s Enforcer — a job that includes systematically hunting down and killing Ordinaries. Although some readers may sympathize with Kai due to his troubled youth and angsty inner monologues, others will find his actions unforgivable. However, he is a consistently charming character and acts as a compelling love interest for Paedyn. Both Kai and Kitt are love interests, but readers savvy in the young adult genre will quickly predict that only Kai (who is introduced first and has far more page time) will win Paedyn’s heart. However, while the outcome is clear, the love triangle is still rife with angst. Kai, Kitt, and Paedyn have a tense dynamic, as the brothers are torn between their growing attraction for Paedyn and their long-standing sibling loyalty, and Paedyn is torn between new relationships and commitment to the rebel cause.  

However, the main focus of Powerless is on the Purging Trials, which add fast-paced tension full of high stakes. The competition is broadcast nationwide to showcase the Elites’ supernatural abilities, thus increasing the King’s power on a national and global stage. They include three trials, each centered around completing a unique objective, such as racing through a maze or stealing the most bands (a leather bracelet each contestant wears). However, Paedyn’s primary motivation is the secret mission the rebels give her — form close bonds with the princes, so she can exploit the intel they give her to find an entry point for the rebels to storm the final trial, alert the kingdom of their existence, and begin the uprising against their Elite oppressors.  

This story is told from the points of view of Paedyn and Kai. Both have the same major conflict — the struggle between duty and love. While Paedyn knows the only way to complete her mission is to betray the prince, she nevertheless grows attached to him over the course of the trials. Kai wrestles with the role he was born into, forced to carry out the King’s dirty work that frequently clashes with his own morality, all the while unknowingly falling in love with one of the very people he is destined to kill. Paedyn and Kai’s angsty will-they-won’t-they romance is the emotional core of the story and provides some nuance to an otherwise black-and-white moral dilemma as both characters are forced to consider stances that cut against their world views.   

Powerless explores several interesting themes, including systemic oppression, governmental tyranny, and the tradeoff between survival and humanity, but does not engage with any of them on an especially profound level. This book shines brightest as a piece of entertainment, as Paedyn competes in a deadly contest and juggles the attention of two attractive princes. While Powerless isn’t unique, it is a fun and engaging read — a perfect way to introduce new readers to the young adult fantasy genre. 

Sexual Content  

  • Overwhelmed by the power plays and politics she must engage in at a gala, Paedyn escapes to a rooftop, where she and Kai share a brief kiss. She describes how the “sparks between [them] are almost tangible… [their] lips brush.” The kiss leaves them both wanting more. 
  • To comfort Kai’s nightmares, Paedyn sleeps in his bed. While they do not engage in sexual activity, they do cuddle, and physical attraction is implied for both parties. “An arm wraps around my middle… he’s wasted no time in pulling me against him… [he wants] to get under my skin and make me flustered with every finger he has on my body.” The steamy scene lasts two pages. 
  • Kai frequently lusts after Paedyn in his internal monologue, though not graphically. He waxes poetic about her cheekbones, hair, and how, “like the hottest flame, her eyes are blue and full of fire.” Likewise, Paedyn lusts after Kai, though more reluctantly. For example, she observes that Kai looks “just as annoyingly attractive as always.”  
  • At a banquet, Kai becomes intoxicated and hints at wanting a sexual encounter with Paedyn. He traces her mouth with his thumb. While she turns him down, she agrees to allow him to “touch [her] when [he] is sober,” under the assumption he will not remember the conversation the following morning.  

Violence  

  • During the trials, Sadie, another contestant, attempts to kill Paedyn with a knife. In the tense scene, Paedyn and Sadie trade kicks and punches, then Sadie gains the advantage and “holds the knife above her head, ready to plunge it into [Paedyn’s] rapidly beating heart… Blood pours out of Sadie’s mouth… She looks down… to the sword now protruding from her chest.” Kai stabs Sadie with a sword, killing her, though Paedyn does not see the swing.  
  • As punishment for Paedyn’s involvement with his sons, the King forces Paedyn to watch her best friend, Adena, die in the final trial. “The gnarled wood flies, guided by an invisible force, before it meets her back, skewering her right through the chest. The scream couldn’t tear through my throat fast enough.” While the killing takes less than a paragraph, the scene lasts about four pages, most of which is devoted to Adena and Paedyn saying goodbye.  
  • After discovering her lies, the King and Paedyn duel. The king overpowers Paedyn, throws her to the ground, and “points the tip of his sword… then drags it down… slow, slicing pain trail[s] from [her] jaw and down [her] neck… His slices are deep and disgustingly slow,” as he carves an “O” for Ordinary into Paedyn’s chest. However, Paedyn knocks the King off balance. The sword she drives “through his chest shuts him the hell up.” The gory scene lasts five pages.  
  • As an Enforcer, Kai must systematically hunt and kill Ordinaries. However, his activities as an enforcer are not depicted but rather alluded to in his backstory and future expectations. In an inner monologue, Kai explains the “types of missions Enforcers get sent on are anything but heroic… Everything from battle strategies and executions to interrogations and torture.”  

Drugs and Alcohol  

  • Wine and champagne are served at a banquet. There, Paedyn and Kai sip the wine. Andy, a participant in the Trials, has “far too much wine,” to the point that other dancers worry she will “fall on top” of them.   
  • At another banquet, Kai drinks wine to the point that he is “not sober” and attempts to initiate a sexual encounter with Paedyn, who turns him down. 

Language 

  • Profanity is used often. Profanity includes damn, hell, ass, shit, and bitch. For example, before Paedyn kills the King, she calls him a “son of a bitch.”  
  • Once, Kai tells Paedyn, “God, you’re stunning.”  

Supernatural 

  • The majority of the characters have superhuman abilities, such as super strength, speed, cloning, etc. For example, when Sadie fights Paedyn, Sadie clones herself, so Paedyn is outnumbered. Another time, Kai and Kitt spar, and Kitt uses his pyro abilities to throw balls of fire at his brother. Kai dodges with a shield of water, using his ability to harness whatever superpowers are nearby.  

Spiritual Content  

  • None 

by Kerry Lum 

King of Scars

After a brutal civil war that shook his fragile nation, King Nikolai Lantsov was pushed onto the throne of Ravka and must attempt to pick up the pieces. However, just as his kingdom is still scarred by the actions of the tyrant and powerful Grisha (magic-user) known as the Darkling, Nikolai is similarly haunted by the past. Nikolai begins shapeshifting into a hideous flying monster at night, threatening not only the lives of people around him but his tenuous claim to the throne.  

Simultaneously, Ravka begins experiencing strange magical phenomena that some call the work of Grisha, while others attribute it to the work of the Saints. Nikolai and his trusted Grisha general, Zoya Nazyalensky, follow the trail of these phenomena to the Shadow Fold, the site of the Darkling’s abuses of Grisha power and his death. With the help of a Darkling-follower named Yuri Vedenen, Nikolai and Zoya hope to use this journey to rid Nikolai of his demon and secure the future of the kingdom. Their quest leads to discoveries about the worshipped Saints, the Grisha, and their world as they know it. 

Meanwhile, Grisha spy Nina Zenik is still reeling from the loss of her love, Matthias Helvar, and recovering from her addiction to the deadly jurda parem, a drug that makes Grisha incredibly powerful at the cost of their free will and, usually, their lives. Nina is on a mission to gather intel in the cold and closed-minded land of Fjerda, which hates Grisha like her. In addition to arranging safe passage away from Fjerda for any Grisha she can, Nina must also finally lay Matthias’ body to rest. When Nina and her fellow spies discover a river that has been poisoning a Fjerdan river city called Gäfvalle, they trace the source to a mysterious factory that piques their interest. Hiding in a convent, Nina’s mission to uncover the hidden truth causes her to uncover a larger scheme against the Grisha and Ravka.  

King of Scars switches third-person perspective every chapter, following Nikolai, Zoya, Nina, Isaak, the Ravkan soldier who takes Nikolai’s place during his quest, and Dima, a minor character in the beginning of the story. The focal point of each chapter is specified in the chapter’s title (i.e. “Nikolai” or “Zoya”). Nikolai, the “King of Scars,” is the primary focus of the story and duology, and most of the issues faced by the other characters are tied back to his country’s problems. Despite having multiple perspectives, the story remains easy to follow due to its pacing and the frequency of expositional dialogue. Each perspective takes on the unique personalities of the characters, and, although every persona has its flaws, all of them are relatable and entertaining. Each one is given a proper backstory and depth, which keeps this ensemble story engaging. 

This book contains numerous storylines and a multitude of characters. Nothing feels unimportant due to the author’s care in making the characters and their lives feel three-dimensional. Side characters usually get only a sentence of exposition, so it can be difficult to remember the relationships and connections between them. Many of the less significant characters, such as Adrik, David, and Leoni, play central roles in other stories within the Grishaverse, and the events they mention are often elaborated upon in other books. While much of the backstory is explained, King of Scars takes place after the Shadow and Bone trilogy and the Six of Crows duology. Thus, King of Scars is not meant to be read first, and doing so would undoubtedly confuse.  

King of Scars is about determination, change, and hope. Ravka is a nation constantly plagued by war and despair, and the central characters are as well. Nevertheless, despite facing many challenges in the past, present, and future, none of the protagonists relinquish the fight. They grow stronger, learning new powers, abilities, and tactics to succeed. The overarching theme of resilience makes for a worthwhile read for audiences interested in the Grishaverse and its characters.  

Sexual Content 

  • After Nikolai has a particularly brutal transformation, he says to Zoya, “When you purse your lips like that, you look like you’ve made love to a lemon.” 
  • Zoya tries to find Nikolai a wife. Zoya argues that the precautions they take to prevent his nightly transformations into the winged monster should not inhibit a strategic marriage, remarking, “She can lock you in at night and kiss you sweetly in the morning, and Ravka will be secure.” 
  • To cover up the fact that Nikolai’s curse makes him disappear, he and Zoya pretend to have spent the night together. Nikolai jokes, “Kiss me sweetly as a new bride would.” To be more convincing, Zoya makes their clothing appear more disheveled. A guard who encounters them asks, “She only play with royals?. . .She looks like fun.” While Nikolai and Zoya’s affair is a ruse, Zoya does admit that she would have “possibly taken him to bed for a few hours” under other circumstances. This scene lasts for about two pages. 
  • Lazlayon, aka The Gilded Bog, is a compound in Ravka that the rakish Count Kirigin runs. It is a “pleasure compound” that Nikolai designs to serve as a front for secret technological experiments and innovation that will help Ravka compete on a global scale. During his first visit, Nikolai sees a “man wearing nothing but an admiral’s hat.” The Gilded Bog is a recurring setting with a reputation for being steamy. 
  • In a meeting with Ravkan officials, Zoya and Nikolai compare international alliances to nighttime companionship. Zoya asks, “Who do we want to go home with when the music stops?” Nikolai adds, “Pick the wrong partner and we could be in for a disappointing night.” 
  • The previous king, Nikolai’s father, had a reputation for having many affairs. Nikolai admits that those who claim “to be a by-blow of [his] father” may be telling the truth. Genya Safin, a Grisha tailor whose beautiful face was mutilated by the Darkling, was essentially the king’s concubine. Zoya says that Genya was “tossed into the old king’s bed” by the Darkling. 
  • There are also rumors that Nikolai’s mother cheated with a “Fjerdan shipping magnate” named Magnus Opjer, who is Nikolai’s true biological father. This is explained over three pages. 
  • Brothels exist in multiple locations. Zoya mentions them, and Nina worked in one during the events of Six of Crows. The activities inside the brothels are not described. 
  • Isaak admits to “falling a bit in love” with Genya while she is altering his appearance. A few pages later, Genya excitedly kisses Isaak’s cheek in response to his effective impersonation of Nikolai, and Isaak blushes. 
  • Zoya is not sexually active, but her dalliances are mentioned. She refuses to tell Nikolai where she goes at night, and the narration later says, “Zoya did not desire; she was desired.” Zoya later says, “Every lover [she’s] taken” has asked about her scars. 
  • The tension between Nikolai and Zoya is palpable. Zoya thinks before their journey to the Shadow Fold that Nikolai looked like “a boy in need of kissing.” Nikolai briefly kisses her knuckles later, and Zoya admits to herself that she “long[s] to try” to make Nikolai fall in love with her.  
  • One night, Zoya takes off her kefta and shows Nikolai the scars on her back, and Nikolai stamps down “an unwelcome bolt of desire.” 
  • Nina often uses flirtation as a tactic in her covert operations. The Wellmother, the leader of the Fjerdan convent, accuses Nina of wanting to “become a rich man’s mistress” after seeing her interact with the fearsome Fjerdan officer Jarl Brum. 

Violence 

  • Since the book contains an excessive amount of violence, not all of it is included below. 
  • The book opens with Nikolai turning into a winged demon and attacking a farm. Dima, a young boy who fears the creatures of the dark, is threatened by a demon that has “dark stains around its mouth and on its chest,” which Dina realizes are blood. Zoya chains the snapping monster before it can harm any humans. This scene is described in two pages. 
  • Nikolai has scars that are “a reminder of the torture he had endured at the hands of the Darkling” during the Ravkan civil war. This torture is what led to his demon curse. 
  • Adrik Zhabin, a Grisha Squaller remarks, “I’ve been shot, stabbed, bayoneted, and had my arm torn off by a shadow demon.” All of these events take place in the previous series. 
  • Zoya reflects on “the Darkling’s slaughter of Novokribirsk,” which resulted in the death of her aunt Liliyana. 
  • Nina prepares fish for the market. “She drove her blade into the fish’s belly, yanked up toward its head, seized the wet pink mess of its innards, and tossed them onto the filthy slats where they would be hosed away.” 
  • Captain Birgir is a violent inspector who tortures and murders Grisha. Nina reflects on multiple instances of his brutality: “She’d seen Birgir and one of his favorite thugs, Casper, drag a mother and daughter off a whaler bound for Novyi Zem and beat them bloody . . . Then he’d doused them in a slurry of waste and fish guts from the canneries and bound them outside the harbor station in the blazing sun.”  
  • Nina keeps shards of bone that she uses like darts. She first uses them on the Casper: “The darts lodged in Casper’s windpipe, and a sharp wheeze squeaked from his mouth. Nina twisted her fingers, and the bone shards rotated. The guard dropped to the dock, clawing at his neck.” 
  • Nina kills Captain Birgir to protect Grisha refugees. Nina drives “a shard of bone through his heart,” and the fearsome captain dies. 
  • Nina and her fellow spies save a girl who was thrown from her horse and nearly trampled to death: “All it would take was a single heavy strike and the [girl’s] skull would be crushed.” This incident occurs over three pages. 
  • The Ravkan Triumverate council talks about “the Lantsov pretender,” Dunyasha Lazareva, who was found “splattered on the cobblestones outside the Church of Barter . . .” 
  • Zoya has an altercation with Nikolai’s monster form. Her shoulder “crack[s] against the edge of a column,” and her arm is dislocated. The demon and the Grisha battle for three pages before the Shu soldier siblings Tamar and Tolya arrive as reinforcements and save Zoya’s life. 
  • Wolves attack Nina while she is burying Matthias. First, Nina uses her bone shards and “pierc[es] the animals’ bodies,” but the remaining wolf bites her arm. Another wolf emerges and fights the remaining wolf off. The fight occurs over two pages. 
  • The Saints trapped in the Shadow Fold—Elizaveta, Grigori, and Juris—fight Nikolai and Zoya upon their arrival. Elizaveta swarms them with bees, and Grigori fights in the shapeshifting form of various animals. Juris takes on the form of a dragon, and he and Zoya fight one-on-one: “The dragon unleashed its fire and Zoya let loose the storm…then the flames collapsed. The dragon reared back, a choked wheeze emerging from its throat. Zoya had stolen its breath…” The battle spans five pages and concludes in a tense truce. 
  • In an act of betrayal, Elizaveta impales Nikolai’s palms and legs with thorns to prevent him from slaying the shadow demon. This action initiates a multi-chapter battle between those on the side of the Darkling and those who are not. 
  • Zoya is encased in amber for the final battle, but she escapes and runs to Juris for backup. She finds him dying. Juris says, “My flames burned me from the inside.” To take on his power, Juris urges her to kill him, and she does so by stabbing a broadsword into his heart. He, in turn, pierces her chest with his dragon claw, solidifying the sacrificial bond. 
  • Elizaveta kills Grigori with her insects: “Tiny holes and furrows began to appear on his flesh as burrowing insects consumed him.” 
  • Zoya is the one who ultimately defeats Elizaveta in the Shadow Fold. She turns the Saint’s powers against her, reversing the path of Elizaveta’s vicious thorns and impaling her “on the claws of her own creation.” 
  • Nina uses her power to manipulate the dead and summon an army of corpses. As the corpses claw through the Earth, the dead speak through Nina and recount their tragic endings at the hands of the Wellmother and the Fjerdan guards. One woman says, “You cut me open and took the child from my womb. You let me bleed to death as I pleaded for help.” 

Drugs and Alcohol 

  • Nikolai uses a tonic “to keep [him] tucked into bed and the monster at bay.” Later, the tonic is enhanced to knock him out completely. He needs a separate wake-up elixir to emerge from sleep. 
  • Nina is a recovering addict and survivor of the drug Jurda Parem, a synthetic substance created to enhance Grisha’s powers. “The drug was the product of experimentation in a Shu lab. It could take a Grisha’s power and transform it into something wholly new and wholly dangerous, but the price for that brief bit of glory was addiction and eventually death.”  
  • Nikolai has commissioned a man to “develop both an antidote to jurda parem and a strain of the drug that might allow Grisha to heighten their powers without making them addicts.”  
  • A river is poisoned by runoff from a factory. After testing the water, the Grisha spy, Leoni, falls ill. A version of jurda parem is infecting the water, resulting in the “orange eyes and rangy bodies” of the wolves that Nina encounters. 
  • Absinthe is a drink that “tastes like sugar dipped in kerosene.” 
  • The Fjerdans have been dosing pregnant Grisha women with jurda parem. Nina sneaks into their facility and finds, “Women and girls . . . in narrow beds . . . addicted to parem.” Their children would be born addicted to the substance, making for “perfect Grisha slaves.” 
  • Characters drink alcohol frequently at social and political gatherings. For example, The Gilded Bog reportedly has “a wine cellar said to stretch for a mile underground. . .”  
  • Zoya and Nikolai share a bottle of brandy. 
  • While impersonating the king, Isaak is nearly poisoned by arsenic gas.  

Language 

  • Profanity is rarely used. Profanity includes damn, ass, shit, and hell. For example, Nina says to the deceased Matthias, “Matthias, your country can kiss my fat Grisha ass.” 
  • Bastard is used a few times. Nikolai ponders how, “The rumors of his bastardy had circulated since well before birth.” 
  • Instead of saying “oh my God” or similar phrases, characters fill in the word “Saints” or “Djel” (a term for god in Fjerdan culture). For example, some say, “For Djel’s sake.” 

Supernatural 

  • As detailed in the Shadow and Bone trilogy and the Six of Crows duology, the Grisha are individuals with various magical abilities, categorized into three broad groups, each with smaller subcategories. This is called “The Small Science.” 
  • The Corporalki are “The Order of the Living and the Dead” (Heartrenders and Healers). Nina was a Heartrender who could control the living before the drug jurda parem changed her powers and gave her control over the dead. 
  • The Etherealki are “The Order of Summoners” (Squallers, Inferni, and Tidemakers). Zoya is a Squaller with power over wind and air. “The wind did what she willed it, had since she was a child.” 
  • The Materialki are “The Order of Fabrikators” (Durasts and Aklemi). Leoni is an Alkemi who can control and study poisons. 
  • The deceased Matthias Helvar’s voice speaks to Nina until she finally buries his body. Upon laying him to rest, Nina finally admits that “Matthias’ voice was not [real]. It never had been.” 
  • The Shadow Fold was created by “merzost,” also known as “abomination” or the corruption of Grisha power. The Darkling had aimed to create more amplifiers, magical artifacts that enhance Grisha magic, but instead created abominations.  
  • Zoya explains to Nikolai that amplifiers are “tied to the making at the heart of the world, the source of all creation.” Grisha’s magic is intrinsically connected to the world itself and the powerful forces that created it. 
  • Three “Saints,” Elizaveta, Juris, and Grigori, are all trapped by the Shadow Fold. Nikolai, Zoya, and Yuri are all transported there, where time is immeasurable. Elizaveta can control natural organisms like bees, other insects, and plants. Grigori is a shapeshifter whose form constantly morphs between human, bear, and amalgamated forms. Juris is a less chaotic shapeshifter who can take on the form and powers of a dragon. 

Spiritual Content 

  • People in Ravka pray to the Saints, all-powerful beings of old who performed miracles and were revered for their martyrdom. There are “churches” dedicated to the Saints. 
  • Tolya and Tamar are both very religious. When Tolya recites “liturgical Ravkan,” Tolya explains, “It’s from the Book of Alyosha, which you might know if you ever went to church.” 
  • Zoya admits that she isn’t “much for praying” to the Saints, and it is later revealed that her faith was destroyed by past unfulfilled prayers. 
  • In the country of Fjerda, Djel is worshipped as an all-powerful god. The people believe the river’s poisoning was “a sign of Djel’s disfavor,” requiring “a priest to say prayers.” 
  • “The great ash” is a sacred tree to Djel.  
  • People in Fjerda sometimes make signs in the air, “meant to wash away evil thoughts with the strength of Djel’s waters.” Water is also sacred in Fjerdan culture. 
  • One of Nina’s main goals is to lay Matthias to rest so that “he could find his way to his god.” 
  • The Apparat is the Ravkan “spiritual counselor to the king,” but the current one is considered self-serving and a traitor. He is followed by the “Priestguard,” holy soldiers who supposedly originated from shapeshifters who survived the obisbaya ritual. 
  • Yuri is a young monk who follows the “Cult of the Starless Saint.” He urges Nikolai during a large demonstration, “Tell your false priest [the Apparat] to do what is right and recognize the Starless One as a Saint.” He believes that the Starless One deserves Sainthood because of the “good” he did for Ravka, despite the horrors that he committed. 
  • The line between the Grisha and the Saints is consistently blurred, and multiple characters imply that the martyred Saints, whom many civilians worship, were actually powerful Grisha, not otherworldly beings.  
  • Grigori says that creation “belongs to the First Maker alone,” implying the presence of an all-powerful creator figure. 

The Black Witch

Seventeen-year-old Elloren Gardner looks exactly like her grandmother but lacks her grandmother’s magic. Her grandmother was the Black Witch, the Gardnerian people’s savior and leader against the evil demons and blasphemers. Yet Elloren was raised along with her two brothers by her uncle deep in the woods, and all she wants to become is an apothecary so she can heal others. So when her aunt comes to take her to Verpax University, Elloren is overwhelmed by the outside world. Per their customs, her aunt wants Elloren to enter into an arranged marriage and fulfill her people’s prophecy by becoming the next Black Witch. However, by the time Elloren reaches school, the stories she grew up hearing don’t exactly add up.

Undaunted and determined, Elloren is a powerful and curious protagonist who strives to uncover the truth, as her country’s history isn’t all as it seems. While all the Gardnerians at her school revere her for who she resembles, every other group fears and avoids her. Her childhood isolationist and supremacist views fade the longer she spends time at school, and she soon gains the friendship and respect of other outcasts. Dealing with the complications of teenage life, including crushes and bullies, Elloren learns how to adapt to new situations and speak her mind. With the help of her new friends and her brothers, Elloren discovers the dangers and corruption of her increasingly religious government. How can she change a world that doesn’t want to change? This complex fantasy world will enthrall the reader with alluring, emotional characters and a powerful cause to root for.

Like many long fantasy series, The Black Witch‘s intricate worldbuilding can be overwhelming at times, and there are many details to track. Despite this, the plot remains simple and predictable. Much of the groundwork laid at the beginning of the book reveals some of the plot’s surprises, making them less impactful. It’s also difficult to root for the main character, Elloren, because she initially appears ignorant and unobservant, making her seem two-dimensional. However, her character evolves and gains greater depth throughout the story. Ultimately, the draw of the novel isn’t a unique plot but rather solid characters, worldbuilding, and the positive message it conveys. The author constructs a society that slowly descends into fascism, and the characters find their

Readers who enjoyed Harry Potter, The Hunger Games, and Dorothy Must Die will love the political intrigue, elaborate magic system, and fierce resistance network of The Black Witch. The book is filled with all kinds of supernatural creatures, from werewolves to elves to demons, vying for a good education in a world embroiled in international power struggles. Elloren is an inspiring character who grows when challenged, leading by example and standing by her moral principles. Overall, The Black Witch is a beautiful story with moments of unifying outrage, magical corruption, and lovely, budding friendship.  

Sexual Content 

  • While at a party, Elloren meets the famous Lukas Grey, who can’t take his eyes off her.  Lukas “raises [Elloren’s] chin, leans in and brings his lips to [hers] with gentle pressure.” 
  • Frustrated with Yvan’s hatred of her, Elloren dreams that Yvan “pulls [Elloren] toward himself and joins his lips to [hers] in fierce urgency.”  
  • Three friends question Elloren about her experience with Lukas, asking, “Have you kissed him?” Elloren is evasive and didn’t answer the question. 
  • After class, before going back to her stressful rooming situation, Elloren kisses Lukas. She thinks that her “lips are still warm and swollen from his fevered kisses.” 
  • After Elloren’s friend, Aislinn, kisses someone, she says she “didn’t just like it. [She] loved it. [They] kissed for over an hour. It was like heaven.” 
  • While Elloren is talking to her other brother, Trystan, he approaches her subtly. Elloren says, “You can’t really think he’s beautiful. You can’t think that way. Trystan, tell me you don’t mean it that way.” His non-response implies that he does admire men that way. 
  • Elloren discusses rumors of werewolf culture with friends. They think werewolves “stand up in front of everyone, pick out someone to mate with and mate with them right there, in front of everyone. Sometimes [they] mate when [their] men are in wolf form and [their] women are in human form.” This is all conjecture on the part of the characters.  
  • Diana, a werewolf, leaves the woods “completely naked. Seeing [Elloren], Diana breaks into a wide exhilarated grin. She strides toward [Elloren], oblivious to the two Gardnerian men down the path who halt to gawk at her.” Elloren’s culture is more conservative, so it takes a while for Elloren to convince Diana to clothe herself. 
  • After an emotional moment, Rafe, who had been friends and hunting partners with Diana for a long time, “brings his mouth to [Diana’s] and they kiss, gently at first. Then Diana moans and presses herself into him, their kissing quickly becoming passionate.” It was their first kiss, and rather spontaneous. 
  • To clear up a misunderstanding, another werewolf, Jarod, describes their culture. “When two Lupines decide to take each other as life mates, one of them stands up and announces his or her desire to be with each other to the whole pack. The two then go off privately into the woods.’” 
  • When Elloren asks Shane about his sister who is an old friend of Elloren’s, he says that someone “used [his] sister, forced his filthy self on her.” 
  • Prostitution is described a couple of times very vaguely. Elloren’s brother, Rafe, says that “some of our men do this. The seals are called Selkies, and they can take human form.” Elloren responds, “What? Aunt Vyvian told me people kept them as pets.” The Selkies are sea creatures who take human form. Gardnerians enslave them in prostitution because if one possesses their “skins,” the Selkies can be controlled. 
  • A Selkie named Marina says, “She was claimed by [a] man. Money given for her. He took her for his own and abused her. Many times.’” 

Violence 

  • Elloren explains that she “came to live with [her uncle] when [she] was three, after [her] parents were killed in the Realm War. It was a bloody conflict that raged for thirteen long years and ended with [her] grandmother’s death in battle. But it was a necessary war, my beleaguered country relentlessly attacked and ransacked at the beginning of it.” 
  • Along with descriptions of prostitution, there are descriptions of women in “actual, locked cage[s], only big enough for [them] to sit in, not stand,” and “two boys are poking at [one woman’s] side with a long sharp stick.”  
  • When Elloren is talking to a friend’s brother about his sister’s new fugitive status, he mentions that he “lacked the necessary level of detachment needed to kill [his] own sister.” 
  • Before reaching university, Elloren is viciously attacked by a creature with wings called an Icaral, because her grandmother was the Black Witch. Her grandmother killed many Icarals in the Realm War, and they held a grudge. “A strong bony hand slams against [her] mouth. An arm flies around [her] waist and locks [her] elbows against [her] sides in a viselike grip.” The demon is killed by a soldier as “a longer blade bursts through the creature’s chest” and “a fountain of blood spurts out.” The battle is described over three pages.  
  • At school, a classmate, Fallon Bane, bullies Elloren, intentionally tripping her. Elloren’s “foot painfully hits something solid,” and she “topples to the ground.” 
  • Some of the servants also bully Elloren. While working in the kitchen, a “hard kick to [Elloren’s] rear sends [her] sprawling” into mud and manure. 
  • When Elloren spends her first night in her room, her roommate threatens to kill her. She even goes so far as to “scrape [her] nails down the length of the door,” while Elloren hides in the closet. 
  • To prevent bullying, Lukas threatens the servants who were bullying Elloren. He says, “It would be a shame if something went amiss during military training exercises, and your parents’ home was fired upon.” He also threatens the lives of the servants’ children. 
  • Elloren’s friend, Wynter, trips. When Rafe helps her up, Wynter’s brother thinks Rafe is being inappropriate. The brother “reaches for his knife [and yells], ‘Stay away from our women!’” 
  • A hate crime is committed against Elloren’s friend, Ariel, and her pet chicken is found with “two stakes driven through its breast, its head dangling. Its severed wings are staked on either side of the animal’s body. Blood streaks down the door and pools on the floor below.” 
  • After Fallon Bane calls Diana unsavory names, Diana “leaps out of bed and slams Fallon to the ground” and tries to “impale Fallon’s new uniform.” 
  • There’s a vague description of abusive child labor and slavery a couple of times. One of the professors explained that “embroidery that intricate . . . was done by Urisk workers . . . many of them children. Working for practically nothing, beaten if they try to protest.” 
  • As Elloren and her friend, Yvan, walk in the woods, they discover a woman being kept in a cage by the groundskeeper. They see him “kick[ing] her hard in the side with his heavy black boot” and him “strik[ing] her so hard that she cries out and falls backward to the ground.” 
  • A woman wants all the Selkies killed. The woman “introduced the motion. To the Mage Council. Earlier this year. To have them shot as soon as they come to shore.” 
  • As fascist ideology grows, Elloren thinks that their leader, Vogel, tried to make it legal to “execute anyone who defaces the Gardnerian flag” or who maligns their religion. 
  • Elloren discovers a mistreated dragon lying “on her side, eyes closed, in a large pool of blood, her spectacular onyx hide covered, just covered, with gashes and lash marks. One of her wings and a hind leg are bent at odd, unnatural angles.” 
  • After a big dragon jailbreak, there’s a description of “dead men and dragons strewn across the field.”

Drugs and Alcohol 

  • Elloren’s friend, Ariel, is described as having been locked up in a sanatorium and heavily medicated, so much so that she is addicted to a fictional substance called nilantyr that seems to have an effect similar to opiates. Ariel’s friend explains that, “When she takes the nilantyr, the memories disappear. It all goes blank and empty. It is a cold peace, but peace nonetheless.” 

Language   

  • Words like stupid, idiot, and hell appear frequently. 
  • The word whores is used once. 
  • Bitch is used twice. 

Supernatural 

  • This book features a diverse array of supernatural creatures, including witches with green skin, werewolves (referred to as Lupines), demons (known as Icarals), Amazonian women who utilize runes in battle, fairies, elves, Selkies, and various half-human, half-animal beings.  
  • The story is set in a world where magic is a reality, encompassing spells, runes, and other forms of magic. Almost all of Elloren’s classes at Verpax involve magic, and most of the violence in the book involves magical battles. There are no explicit spells spoken in battle. An example of this violence occurs when Elloren and her friends try to free the dragons, and “a glowing red orb whirls by overhead, along with stray wand fire, the orb exploding behind me into a circle of red flame.” 
  • In classes, spells are used to train younger students and test their magical ability. For example, when Elloren arrives at Verpax, the Commander of the Guard tests her magical ability by having her “lift the wand awkwardly and point it at [a] candle” and whisper the word “illiumin.” Elloren is shocked by the wand and drops it quickly. Spoken spells are rare in the book; most of them are implied.  
  • Gardnerians marry using magical bonds that appear as tattoos on their skin, exhibiting their marital status and binding the couple together more literally. If they run or divorce each other, the tattoo damages their skin and can kill them.  
  • When Elloren was a child, she was required to be wandtested to see how powerful she was. She describes it as “a powerful energy shoot[ing] through [her]” even going so far as “an explosion. Fire shooting from the tip of the stick. The trees around [her] suddenly engulfed in flames. Fire everywhere. The sound of [her] screaming.” 

Spiritual Content 

  • The Black Witch establishes a complex religious system that mirrors modern monotheistic religions and intertwines it with politics. This religion has strong allusions to the three main monotheistic religions: Christianity, Islam, and Judaism. Their religious structures dictate more conservative norms and different swear words than what people literally use. References to their religion are heavily present in the novel, and priests hold prominent positions in high government and university institutions. 
  • Asleep and thinking at night, Elloren provides context for the color of her skin, as “like all Gardnerians, [her] skin shimmers a faint green in the dark. It’s a mark of the First Children, set down on us by the Ancient One above, marking us as the rightful owners of Erthia. At least, that’s what our holy book, The Book of Ancients, tells us.” 
  • An example of the more conservative customs, “wandfasting” means arranged marriage at a very young age. When describing one of her friends, Elloren thinks about how her “zealously religious family fasted her at thirteen to Tobias Vassilis.” Later, Elloren’s aunt explains that “wandfasting” is a beautiful sacrament, meant to keep them pure and chaste. The aunt says, “The lure of the Evil Ones is strong . . . wandfasting helps young people. . . stay on the path of virtue.” 
  • Elves are considered “idol worshippers.” 
  • After a particularly violent day, Elloren tries to calm herself by reading from their holy book. She reads that “all of creation joined together to worship, glorify, and obey the Ancient One.” The book describes the Gardnerian creation myth in detail, complete with justifications for species biases and discrimination. 
  • Elloren rooms with two Icaral girls. When Elloren tells her friends about this, they say that Elloren “should go to evening service with [them],” and that “the priest can exorcise [the Icarals’] evil.” Later, one of Elloren’s professors refuses to teach one of them because “to look at [her] would be against [his] religious beliefs.” 
  • When Elloren’s friend’s family visits and they meet one of the werewolves, they whisper a prayer: “Oh, most holy Ancient One, purify our minds, purify our hearts, purify Erthia. Protect us from the stain of the Evil Ones.” 
  • One of Elloren’s professors comes from a culture similar to that of the Amazons (called the Amaz), and their creation myth is different. Professor Volya explains that “the First Men were not grateful at all for what the Goddess had done for them. Instead, they tried to convince the Three Sisters to join them and slay the Great Mother, so that they could rule over all Erthia.” 

by Kate Schuyler

Shadow Fox

Shadow the fox does not trust humans. Well, except for Nan, who feeds her chunks of fish behind a lakeside motel every night. When Nan goes missing, a man from the mysterious Whistlenorth Island comes ashore to seek the aid of Nan’s granddaughter, Bee, whom he thinks is destined not only to help Nan, but also to save Whistlenorth from the greedy and destructive Night Islanders.  

The plans go topsy-turvy when it becomes obvious that Bee does not have the magic powers of a chosen one — but Shadow does! Can a fox really rescue an island of people? As Shadow grudgingly comes to trust her new human companions, she and Bee develop a mystical bond, a special connection between human and animal that might be the key to driving the Night Islanders from Whistlenorth for good.  

The story is told from Shadow’s point of view, offering a unique perspective and allowing readers to understand how environmental destruction impacts wild animals. Shadow was hunting when a group of men cleared an entire swath of forest and killed Shadow’s mother and sister. Afterwards, Shadow doesn’t want to “like” anyone, especially humans. Shadow’s quest isn’t just about saving the people of Whistlenorth; the fox also has to accept her family’s death and allow others into her heart.  

Shadow and Bee discover they have a special magical bond that allows them to hear each other’s thoughts. Bee often comments on Shadow’s thoughts and helps her understand the human world. In addition, Bee gives Shadow confidence by saying, “Don’t you ever doubt yourself! I used to think that being wild was a bad thing, but being wild is the best thing.” In the end, Shadow realizes that she doesn’t need to act human to defeat the Night Islanders. Instead, she needs to think like a fox. This reinforces the idea that Shadow does not need to become a tame pet in order to save Whistlenorth.  

Shadow also has a special bond with a bird that she helped hatch. At first, Shadow does not want to care about the bird, but the bird refuses to leave Shadow’s side. Shadow notices the bird is “gazing at me as if I am his everything. I am the sun and the moon and the fish and the stars. Yes, he is just a bird, but he is everything worth fighting for, all wrapped up in feathers.” Shadow’s relationship with the bird and Bee helps Shadow overcome her grief and allows others into her heart. In addition, it is these relationships that give him the ability to save Whistlenorth. In the end, Shadow is motivated to save the isle because it’s the only way to save her friends. 

Shadow Fox has a strong environmental focus that helps readers understand the importance of caring for everything “wild.” The death of Shadow’s family highlights what happens when natural areas are destroyed to make room for progress. The environmental focus is seamlessly integrated throughout the book, without being overwhelming or preachy. Bee’s grandmother warns: “‘Make no mistake. If the foxes disappear, if the birds disappear, humans are next. We might still be breathing, we might still be alive, but inside, in here—’ She taps her heart with two fingers. ‘It’s all over.’” 

By telling the story from Shadow’s point of view, Sorosiak creates an endearing protagonist that readers will fall in love with. Shadow’s thoughts and actions are consistent with a wild fox, which often brings humor into the story. Shadow often thinks about food—including her favorite food, fish—and this leads to some silly moments. In addition, Shadow makes many references to fish. For example, Shadow describes the wind saying, “It pelts my face like a dead trout. Or a cold, stiff sturgeon.”  

Shadow Fox begins by describing the magical islands of Whistlenorth and the dangers presented by the Night Islanders. The worldbuilding is essential; however, it lacks action and suspense. When Shadow and Bee get to the island, the story becomes more interesting and intense. However, the large cast of supporting characters, the complicated plot, and the detailed fight scenes will require readers to pay close attention to the text. Despite this, animal-loving readers will be drawn into Shadow’s adventure and cheer when Shadow not only defeats the Night Islanders but also defeats her fears. For more stories that teach about the importance of caring for our environment, check out Spark by Sarah Beth Durst, Out of My Shell by Jenny Goebel, and the Wild Rescuers Series by Stacy Plays. 

Sexual Content 

  • None 

Violence 

  • Shadow is in a barn when a groundkeeper appears. “One of his gloved hands grips my neck alongside the metal loop, and he lifts me straight into the air.” The man tells Shadow, “I was going to turn you into the wildlife authorities, but maybe I should turn you into a hat.” Shadow uses magic to escape. 
  • Bee sees bed birds. “They are a famous species. Little blue birds. They sneak through cracked-open windows at night and bite humans, sleeping in their beds.” 
  • Shadow’s mother and sister were killed when humans took “down a swath of the forest in a day,” and sliced down the trees. Afterwards, Shadow felt “a feeling [she]’d never felt and never want[ed] to feel again. The total loss, that emptiness, the knowledge that nowhere—nowhere out there—were [her] sister and mother breathing. Their breath was smothered out.” 
  • The Night Islanders are killing everything—plants and animals—to extract magic. A Night Islander wears a “metal cage that’s around his face, just two little holes cut out for eyes, and wearing . . . a beaver hat. The tail dangles along his neck. The matted pelt shrouds his head.” 
  • Two Night Islanders travel to Whistlenorth with the intent of kidnapping the chosen one. Shadow calls one of the men “the Hunter.” Shadow realizes that the Hunter and other Night Islanders are the ones that killed her family. “The ones with the metal and the smoke and the saws. . . They were Night Islanders!” 
  • The Hunter grabs Bee. Shadow attacks and “clamp[s] the second attacker’s leg in my jaws. He lets out a single yelping note, louder than a fox, before kicking, kicking, flinging me against the nearest tree. Arching through the air, I hit the bark with a thwomp. . . The blow has me seeing tiny bees, buzzing above my ears. One of my ribs bends inward, bruising but not breaking.”  
  • To escape the man’s grasp, Bee “opens her mouth and bites the Hunter’s mitten—hard. Another shriek escapes him, voice dark and blooming like blood. . .” Bee is unable to escape, and the Hunter kidnaps her. 
  • To free Bee, a pack of snow foxes attacks. “Advancing forward, all one hundred of them pounce, paws first, tongue second. Spit flies. Tongues reach out. . . The foxes lick ears. They lick toes. They lick fingers and noses and palms, slurping-slurp.” The foxes’ spit numbs the Night Islanders so they are unable to move.  
  • Shadow finds Bee. “The sleeve of her sweater is tied around her mouth and nose, blocking her breath. . . her wrists are bound with a strip of fishing net.” The snow foxes surround the Hunter, and he is “pinned in all directions by snouts and teeth.” 
  • The Night Islanders use their magic to make “spikes rise from the earth. . . They’re taller than the tallest oaks, sharper than thorns.” Shadow, Bee, and the bird are “hemmed in on all sides, like an ice cage.” 
  • To trap some of the Night Islanders, Shadow uses magic to summon “the canoes from the lakeshore. . . Falling to the earth, they trap a few Night Islanders beneath them.” 
  • The Night Islanders combine their magic to create a mound of snow that traps Bee, Shadow, and others. “Under the snow-flood, my body wiggles and flits. Thrashing, flaying! . . . And my breath has nowhere to go! The snow is packed so tightly. . . The Hunter and the Night Islanders. . .. They’ve summoned all the snow from the island to bury us alive.” Everyone escapes.  
  • The only way to defeat the Night Islanders is to take their magic. The bird uses magic to make a flock of birds out of snow. The birds disappear and reappear inside of the Night Islanders’ stomachs. “The Hunter shrieks, hippity-hopping on his toes. Now the other Night Islanders are clutching their stomachs, massaging their throats, beating their chests.” 
  • Once the birds have collected all of the magic from the Night Islanders’ stomachs, “the birds reappear as a flock. . . a little bit melted at the tips of their feathers but roughly intact. Their bellies bulge with magic. . . waddling calmly away.” The Night Islanders return to their isle.  

Drugs and Alcohol 

  • None

Language 

  • A man calls Shadow a “good-for-nothing.” 
  • When learning that the fox and Bee don’t swim, a man yells, “Fish sticks almighty.” “Fish sticks” is used as an exclamation four times. 
  • Bee uses “jeez” as an exclamation twice.  
  • Shadow uses magic, causing a dining room table, table settings, and hundreds of fish to appear suddenly. Nan exclaims, “Oh, holy herring in cream sauce.” 
  • When a Night Islander wakes up to the smell of fox urine, he yells, “What the—.” 

Supernatural 

  • Magic is prevalent throughout the book, so not every instance is listed below. Some people have magic that allows them to summon things. Shadow can “change smoke into tiny foxes and summon cans of pudding. Not so intimidating. Unless, I suppose, you’re afraid of pudding. Or aluminum.” 
  • Some people are cultivators. “We make things grow. Or shrink them. Some can even take an object and reshape it into something else. . . Like pudding cans into teaspoons.” 
  • Bee reads a book of predictions written by a woman who “had a knack for predicting the future, but she didn’t get it right all the time.” There are several general predictions. One says that Beatrice Shadowen from Minnesota, US, “will be chosen by nature to save the island from the magical extinction.” 
  • Nan explains where magic comes from. She says, “The magic comes from nature: the trees, the rivers, the soil. Think of it like oxygen. We breathe in magic, then breathe it out—intentionally—to make something happen.” 
  • Magic allows Bee and Shadow to hear each other’s thoughts and allows Shadow to understand human speech. Bee tells Shadow, “It’s not like I asked for this power. . . You got most of the magic, but—somehow—I got the power to understand you.” It also allows Shadow to read human books. 
  • After the groundkeeper captures Shadow, the fox becomes warm. “My belly prickles with the heat.” The fox becomes so hot that the “groundkeeper shrieks, his hand unclenching. . .” Somehow, Shadow had turned the groundkeeper’s gloves into pumpkin soup. Afterwards, “the groundkeeper is murmuring, examining his hands, which are slick with hot orange goop.” Both Shadow and the groundkeeper are confused about how the gloves changed.  
  • Shadow has a habit of taking people’s shoes. While in the barn with the groundkeeper, “one of my shoes is hovering in the air. . . Then another one. A bright-blue flip-flop, suspended like a hummingbird.” The groundkeeper runs away before seeing the shoes “circling the air before stacking all around [Shadow], a tower on four sides. With a flip-flop roof!” 
  • A swarm of bed birds surrounds Shadow, making her skin tingle. “Tiny sprigs of fur are beginning to sprout. Midnight-black tufts grow and rush over the paw. On my belly, too, is a feeling. A feeling like lying in the sun.” When the birds leave, Shadow’s fur is full and healthy. 
  • When Shadow thinks of fish toast, it appears. “A slice of white bread, smothered in lake-trout paste. It just. . .appears, right by my paws. Without thinking, I shove the toast in my mouth. . .” 
  • Shadow helps a bird hatch, and the bird imprints on the fox. Later, Shadow discovers that the bird has magic. The bird can disappear and reappear somewhere else. The bird can also transport others.  
  • While practicing her magic, Shadow makes a spoon grow. The spoon gets so big that “soon, it’ll be punching a hole in the houseboat. . . The houseboat creaks again, this time from the pressure of the spoon. It’s bending, metal thrusting against the rafters. . .” With Nan’s help, Shadow shrinks the spoon to its normal size. 
  • To help fight the Night Islanders, Shadow conjures dozens of foxes made of snow. Some are “spikier, with pine needles sticking from their snow like hackles.” To get to the Night Isle, the bird transports Shadow and the snow foxes.

Spiritual Content 

  • None 

Latest Reviews